Counterparties: The economics of flying blind
Welcome to the Counterparties email. The sign-up page is here, itâs just a matter of checking a box if youâre already registered on the Reuters website. Send suggestions, story tips and complaints to Counterparties.Reuters@gmail.com.
The leaders of the G20 met in Washington today; their official communique was sent out, like any grand pronouncement, as a Word document posted on a Russian website.
The worldâs most powerful finance ministers and central bankers appeared to be working through some serious confusion today. Even Indiaâs finance minister seemed a bit puzzled by all the talk of Europe: “It was supposed to be a G20 meeting, but for a moment I thought it was a G7 meeting”, he said.
Three days after a grad student dismantled the widely-held idea of a 90%-of-GDP tipping point for national debt, the G20 agreed to move away from the idea of setting specific national debt targets. This a big change — just three years ago, the G20âs richest nations pledged to cut their deficits in half by this year. Now, as Reuters notes, Europe is not just re-thinking austerity, but promising to slow it down.
The IMF, which previously endorsedÂ Britain’s austerity program, has now changed its stance on debt. That may augur a direct confrontation with the Cameron government. Just today, the UK had its credit outlook downgraded by Fitch, in part because of a âweaker fiscal and economic outlookâ.
Mohamed El-ErianÂ blames the IMF for some of the global policy confusion.Â While he admires the Fund’s âhighly respectedâ analysis and âworld class insightâ, he says that policy implementation âfrequently falls hostage to pressure from its political masters in advanced economies.â
His case in point: during the Cyprus crisis, the IMF signed on to a flawed rescue plan, then quickly retracted its support. The âIMF felt it had no choice but to succumb to pressure by European politicians,â El-Erian writes. Neil Irwin, on the other hand, applauds the IMF for changing its mind on debt and says that the IMF has now become the kind of friend who urges you to work less and drink more. (At the end of a long week, we at Counterparties appreciate those kind of friends.)
The G20 bigwigs also seemed unsure about the effectiveness central banksâ easy monetary policy.Â On Friday, there were no G20 objections to Japanâs two-year $1.4 trillion monetary stimulus program. But the FTâs Chris Giles says that, after years of low rates and stimulus, the worldâs central bankers feel theyâre effectively flying blind, in an âenvironment of uncertainty about the way economies work and how to influence recoveries with policyâ.
Ex-ECB executive board member Lorenzo Bini Smaghi summed up the meetings. âWe donât fully understand what is happening in advanced economies,â he said.Â – Ryan McCarthy
On to todayâs links:
And, of course, there are many more links at Counterparties.