Reuters Blogs

For the Record

Dean Wright on Ethics, Innovation and Values

14:27 April 15th, 2009

These pirates shouldn’t be punchlines

Posted by: Dean Wright
Tags: Full Disclosure, , , , , , , , ,

dean-150Dean Wright is Global Editor, Ethics, Innovation and News Standards. Any opinions are his own.

Kidnapping isn’t funny.

Neither are extortion, hijacking or murder threats.

So why have some in the media been laughing—or at least winking—at people who have been doing precisely that—the criminals who have been hijacking ships and crews off the Horn of Africa and holding them for ransom?

I think it has something to do with what we’ve chosen to call them: pirates.

Perhaps we in the media have all seen too many cartoonish films with Johnny Depp portraying the charming and engaging Jack Sparrow. Or maybe we remember an earlier era when Errol Flynn played a charming and engaging Geoffrey Thorpe who fights for commerce and his country (England) and the affections of a Spanish princess.

Maybe we need a break from the mostly grim coverage of the financial crisis and evaporating savings, continuing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, a tide of gun violence and unrest around the world.

The day after the crew of the Maersk Alabama kept control of their ship after the attack by pirates who later held Capt. Richard Phillips, the front-page headline in the New York Post was: “Yo, Ho, D’oh.”

A Google News search over the past month shows 414 stories with references to “ahoy,” 150 to “avast,” 76 to “walk the plank,” 61 to “Davy Jones,” and 165 to varying spellings of “arrgh.”

The White House press corps was not immune. As the Washington Post’s Dana Milbank wrote (sprinkling his piece with references to Davy Jones, walking the plank and scallywags), “ …the discussion of an American shipping captain’s successful rescue from pirates over the weekend brought the rare sensation of adventure on the high seas to the White House briefing room yesterday—and everybody seemed to enjoy the diversion.”

Maybe we do need the diversion, but this is deadly serious business and I wonder if we’re calling the Somali “pirates” something they aren’t.

At the risk of being accused of splitting hairs (oh, let’s split hairs!), dictionary definitions of “pirate” and “piracy” traditionally have much more to do with theft than kidnapping.

According to Merriam Webster online, “piracy” is defined as “1: an act of robbery on the high seas; also: an act resembling such robbery 2: robbery on the high seas 3a: the unauthorized use of another’s production, invention, or conception especially in infringement of a copyright b: the illicit accessing of broadcast signals.”

Putting aside the third definition (that’s another column), it seems that what the Somali “pirates” are doing is closer to extortion and kidnapping than robbery. They don’t want the grain in the holds of the Maersk Alabama and other famine relief ships headed to Kenya or even the vehicles on the decks of other seized ships. They don’t even want the ships. They want to exchange the ships and their cargoes for a ransom that is a very small percentage of what they are actually worth.

I know this isn’t the Council of Trent and I don’t hold out much hope of persuading my colleagues to call the “pirates” something else, like “kidnappers” or “extortionists” or “hijackers.” But I think we could turn down the “shiver me timbers” index considerably.

There are signs that the coverage of the kidnappings off the Horn of Africa are changing the ways some people think about “pirates.”

In Grand Rapids, Mich., Amy Hekman, a childhood literacy coach, told the Grand Rapids Press that when she’s talking to her children about the incidents, “I’ve been conscious not to use the word ‘pirate.’ I tell them a ship was captured.”

And 10-year-old Jacob Peterson told the paper that he’s not sure he’ll want to reprise his pirate costume for Halloween, because, he said, the Somali “pirates” “seem mean.”

Thank you, Jacob.

85 comments so far

Wonderful article……
the nations of the world should take
action and stop those…. rats
J.

- Posted by James Renko

They are pirates.They should be hunted down and hung. Taking other people and other peoples property is a crime.
Do you know what the punishment would be in a muslim country for such a crime? You would lose a part of your body.Yes the people who take these jobs know there will be danger on any given day.But the danger from Mother Nature is no in the same category as danger from humans
who know what they are doing is wrong.Arm the ships and crews. Put up 24 hour armed experienced personel on guard. What is cheaper 12 more employees or ransom and not havin your tools for commerce. And the aid will get where its needed.We did not create the Somolia problem, nor should we spend one red dime to do so. Fix America. Or let the bleeding hearts put their money out there to fix the problem. I want my taxes for my country, or I want them back.
Any country that has a ship thats has been hijacked should be doing what ever it takes to get their people free and their property back. If that means killing some heathens who care not one iota for human life so be it.

RL Thomas New Orleans,La USA

- Posted by R L Thomas

What the Somali pirates are doing is bad, specially now that they are really getting too greedy and overdoing it, but let’s not forget the reason why most of these guys are forced into piracy or the kidnap for ransom scheme. Their country is a mess. No real functioning government, their economy is toast. No jobs. So the lure of easy money by joining the pirates is strong. These guys are not killers, as far as I can find they haven’t killed any of their hostages at all. They are in it for the money. Most experts seem to agree that a military solution is going to be only a band-aid solution (there aren’t enough available battleships in the world to patrol the large area these pirates operate in), and that to permanently end the piracy problem in that region, the international community must first find a way to “fix” the problem in Somalia. Yup..easier said than done. I hope the international community does eventually find a way to help solve the problems of Somalia or at least aid in the creation of a functioning government.

- Posted by RC

I agree that, in this case, the term ‘pirate’ may not be used with great precision or within a lexicon’s strict definition of the word However, the hunting grounds these perpetrators lurk are, after all, the high seas. I think an open interpretation would support any culprit committing any crimes in that venue may be categorized as a pirate. Lighted up.
Which brings me to the subject of levity.
Being serious all the time will kill you just as sure as chronic smoking or excessive libation. I was raised to make joke in response to the adversity life throws at us. I’d rather make fun of the swashbucklers then discuss in solemn detail the crimes they commit. And at the end of the day I’ll bet my making them smile will be remembered and you bringing them down will be forgotten.
Yes, it is horrific that people in that one million square mile of sea are being subjected to acts of piracy. And have been for quite a few years. Anyone sailing those parts knows in advance they may come under fire from the lawless in the region. But, they’ve made their decision to brave it and go onward. That risk is an inherent part of the job they undertake and the large paycheck given them by the shipper reflects acknowledgment and compensation for that risk. I know a guy who use to sail a French vessel through the strait. I promised to never say it outright but in five years he retired better than most do in a lifetime. So, although I will pray for those in harm’s way, I will not feel sorry for them if that is what they choose to do for a living.

- Posted by Mark

I am writing this because I have someone on a ship right now out by those waters with the pirates. He works for the Maersk line and they have no support out there!! They will be going though the pirate area again. They were attacked 2 times the first time going through just before the Alabama was attacked. They left them alone only because they are bigger and faster then some of the other ships that were there at that time. They reported the incidence and no help was sent!! Now they have to come back again and they are concerned about their lives!! If everyone could say something to their Congressman and Senators maybe we can stop this insanity!!! These guys have family and friends who love them dearly and do not want them hurt!! Think about their lives right now!! What if they were your family or friend?????

- Posted by Charlie

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.