Funds Hub

Money managers under the microscope

Staying positive

February 16, 2009

rtr23yfeThere seems to be an endless wave of bad news hitting the hedge fund industry at the moment — gates and suspensions, record poor performance, the Bernard Madoff scandal and so forth – but there are still one or two reasons to be positive.

According to a survey of institutional investors by alternative assets data group Preqin, conducted in January (and therefore after the alleged Madoff fraud came to light), only 8 percent said they were no longer confident about hedge funds and would reduce investments.

By contrast, 26 percent said they would be increasing their allocations this year.

This appears to be a more positive picture than for high net worth individuals, who, according to some anecdotal evidence, have become more cautious on hedge funds.

Institutions such as pension funds, in contrast, tend to have time horizons running into decades, so a year of bad performance is not necessarily the be all and end all.

They have also seen equities, which constitute a far greater portion of their portfolios, plummet last year, leaving hedge funds, relatively speaking at least, looking quite good.

Having followed wealthy individuals into hedge funds and helped fuel the industry’s massive growth of recent years, they could end up supporting it through the difficult times.

But the survey also highlights some less appealing trends for hedge fund managers.

The industry’s lucrative 2 and 20 fee structure looks more and more under threat, with around 35 percent of institutional investors saying they felt more confident to negotiate fees.

And some investors in the survey said they would no longer invest in funds of funds because they didn’t think they were value for money.

For a section of the industry already under pressure — for performing even worse than single-manager funds, after a huge rise in the dollar hit cash reserves and because some fund selectors failed to spot Madoff — this is yet another ominous sign.


If history shows us anything its that no matter how bad this were they always get better. Then they get worse. Then better. If we do not pay attention to history we are bound to repeat it. Repeat it. Repeat it. There have always been financial scandles and there will always be great recoveries. We cannot dwell on the bad. This is a time to lead not follow.


Yes, paying more attention to history would probably have helped in this crisis. But it’s a tough one when it comes to hedge funds – the industry has not been going, on this scale at least, for very long so there is not much history to learn from.

Posted by Laurence Fletcher | Report as abusive

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see