Reuters Blogs

Good, Bad, and Ugly

Reader reaction to Reuters news

November 16th, 2009

Hey you, make my day?

Posted by: Robert Basler
France makes Eastwood’s day, gives him top honor

He called Eastwood, whose line “Come on, make my day” from Dirty Harry became a global catchphrase, “a myth, a giant, an example of the admiration we have for American culture.”

The Dirty Harry quote in the Clint Eastwood story reads “Come on, make my day,” but should read: “Go ahead, make my day.”

Jim S.

Several readers noticed that one. We corrected: GBU Editor

U.S. director and actor Clint Eastwood reacts after he was named as a Commandeur de la Legion d’Honneur during a ceremony at the Elysee Palace in Paris,  November 13, 2009.  REUTERS/Thibault Camus/Pool

Join the Good, Bad, Ugly Facebook Blog Network

October 12th, 2009

Animated objection?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Marge Simpson makes cover of Playboy

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - “D’oh!” doesn’t even start to cover it. Marge Simpson — the blue beehived matriarch of America’s most loved dysfunctional family - is Playboy magazine’s November cover, the magazine said on Friday.

Simpson, tastefully concealing her assets behind a signature Playboy Bunny chair, is the first cartoon character ever to front the glossy adult magazine, joining the ranks of sex symbols like Marilyn Monroe and Cindy Crawford.

The article says of the Marge Simpson character that she “is the first cartoon character ever to front the glossy adult magazine.”

This is incorrect. Leroy Neiman’s “Femlin” cartoon character has been featured on the cover of Playboy several times . Here is one example from August 1960:

Holy Smokin

Your article claims this is their first cover to feature a cartoon character. I believe that honor goes to Jessica Rabbit for their November, 1988 issue.

Mike

Some people may be over-thinking this a bit. I suppose it comes down to your definition of “cartoon character,” but the Femlins don’t seem to rise to the level of a walking, talking, animated character with a voice recognized by millions.  As for the Jessica Rabbit cover, it seems that was a real Playmate dressed as Jessica Rabbit, which isn’t really the same as having a cartoon character on the cover.

Pretty much everybody is reporting this as a first, and I haven’t seen the Playboy folks contradicting it. If anyone should be aware of their past cover content, they should: GBU Editor

Right: Marge Simpson is seen on the cover of the November issue of Playboy magazine in this handout released to Reuters on October 9, 2009. REUTERS/Playboy Magazine/Handout

Left: Femlin on a cover.

Join the Good, Bad, Ugly Facebook Blog Network

October 6th, 2009

Box office figures…

Posted by: Robert Basler

Zombieland” top destination at box office

Drew Barrymore’s directing debut, “Whip It,” and documentary filmmaker Michael Moore’s “Capitalism: A Love Story” each reported about $4.9 million in ticket sales.

“Capitalism” played in almost twice as many theaters as “Whip It,” which had been expected to open in the high-single-digit millions ahead of the Gervais comedy.

The article claims the movie “Whip It” that tied for seventh place with “Capitalism..” played in half as many theaters as the Michael Moore pick though the opposite was true.

My questions is if anyone is going to fixed this error and notify the outlets you sent the story to? why does it take so long to correct an obvious error such as this?

Sean

Several readers pointed this out. We corrected: GBU Editor

Director of the movie and cast member Drew Barrymore poses at the premiere of “Whip It” in Hollywood, September 29, 2009. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni
September 22nd, 2009

Casting aspersions?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Few deals, some Oscar bets at Toronto film festival

He pointed to Rodrigo Garcia’s relatively low-cost “Mother and Child,” which stars Annette Bening, Naomi Watts and Samuel L. Jackson

Corrections are required. This is not the first time that you, Reuters, have misinformed other media especially those at the Toronto Film Festival that this film stars Annette Bening, Naomi Watts…..etc. and they’re all quoting you.

As per the official cast listing that has been publicly announced, this film stars Naomi Watts, Annette Bening…. You people have once again slighted Ms. Watts and deprived her of what she deserves just because you think Ms. Bening is a bigger name.

S.T.

I don’t agree with your assessment that deviating from the order in some official cast listing means our story “misinformed” anybody, much less that it needs correcting. Both actresses are in the movie, right?

This story was from the Toronto International Film Festival, whose synopsis listed Bening first.

But look, just for you, here’s a picture of Watts and not one of Bening

Cast member Naomi Watts attends the gala screening of “Mother and Child” at Roy Thomson Hall during the 34th Toronto International Film Festival on September 14, 2009. The festival runs from September 10-19. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni

Join the Good, Bad, Ugly Facebook Blog Network

September 18th, 2009

Repost the story?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Gelbart’s colleagues remember “master of masters”

LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) – The classic series “M*A*S*H,” the hit movie comedy “Tootsie” and the Tony-winning play “A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum” are part of the enduring legacy that writer Larry Gelbart left behind when he died September 11 at age 81.

“He was the single funniest human being I’ve ever known as far as being able to make a quip, a repost and make you laugh without using a straight line,” said Carl Reiner…

This article is poorly written, which is a shame since, ironically, it is about a great writer.

For example, it speaks of the “legacy” that Gelbart “left behind” which is redundant. Even worse, it uses “repost” instead of “riposte” as a term for comic rebuttal.

R.K.S.

Ouch. Ouch: GBU Editor

Writer Larry Gelbart accepts the Impact award during the taping of the 7th annual TV Land Awards in Los Angeles, April 19, 2009 file photo. REUTERS/Fred Prouser/Files

August 26th, 2009

Basterdized spelling?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Tarantino’s “Basterds” leads world box office

LOS ANGELES, Aug 23 (Reuters) - Director Quentin Tarantino scored the best opening of his colorful career with his World War Two thriller “Inglourious Basterds,” which topped the worldwide box office after selling $65.1 million worth of tickets, its distributors said on Sunday.

The last time I looked, it was spelled ‘Bastards’. It’s not a typo either. The journalist has spelled it incorrectly throughout the article.

Can I replace him?

Writing Star

No, you may not replace him. He correctly identified the title of the movie throughout the story. It wasn’t our idea to spell it that way: GBU Editor

Cast member Brad Pitt attends the premiere of “Inglourious Basterds,” August 10, 2009. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni

Join the Good, Bad, Ugly Facebook Blog Network

August 11th, 2009

Contending with the facts…

Posted by: Robert Basler

“On the Waterfront” screenwriter Schulberg dies, 95

His screenwriting included 1957’s “A Face in the Crowd,” but it was the classic “On the Waterfront” for which Schulberg will be best remembered.

The 1954 film, based on the award-winning Tennessee Williams play about corruption on the New Jersey waterfront, earned 12 Oscar nominations and won eight of Hollywood’s top honors including screenwriting for Schulberg.

In your obituary of screenwriter Budd Schulberg, you mention that “On The Waterfront” was adapted from a Tennessee Williams play about longshoremen. That is incorrect. The screeplay was not based on a Williams’ play, but rather, on a series of articles in THE NEW YORK SUN, “Crimes on the Waterfront” by Malcolm Johnson.

Adam

We corrected: GBU Editor

Actor Karl Malden accepts his Lifetime Achievement Award during 10th annual Screen Actors Guild Awards in Los Angeles, in a 2004 file photo.  The actor, known for roles in films like “A Streetcar Named Desire” and “On the Waterfront,” died July 1, 2009 at age 97. REUTERS/Mike Blake/Files

August 10th, 2009

The caste of characters?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Ridley Scott, DiCaprio travel to “Brave New World”

Characters who figure in are Bernard, a lower-caste member, and Lenina, the woman with whom he is infatuated. DiCaprio would likely play Bernard, who is persecuted when the leaders of the society find his behavior antisocial.

Bernard is an Alpha-Plus, the highest cast in the book. Please revise.

Keith

In the book Brave New World, the character of Bernard is NOT a low-caste member. He’s an Alpha Plus, as any who’s actually read the book can tell you.

Orthia

Just a heads up… might want to revisit Wikipedia or whatever “esteemed” research source you are using: Bernard is NOT a ” lower-caste member.”

Oh wait–even Wikipedia had it right. Bernard is a member of the HIGHEST caste in Huxley’s dystopian world.

Megan

I’m happy to say for the sake of literature that a number of readers spotted this one. We corrected: GBU Editor

Director Ridley Scott arrives for the UK premiere of “Body of Lies” in London, in a 2008 file photo. REUTERS/Toby Melville

Join the Good, Bad, Ugly Facebook Blog Network

July 27th, 2009

Alice in Blunderland

Posted by: Robert Basler

Tim Burton explores “Alice in Wonderland”

Q: What did you take from Lewis Carol’s source material?

A: It’s based on all of Lewis Carol’s material, including the “Jabberwocky Poem.” Past “Alice” films were always just a girl wandering around passively with a lot of weird characters. We tried to weave it into a story that has emotion to it and makes sense.

In case no one has brought it to your attention yet, the author of “Alice” is Lewis Carroll, not Carol.

Merrick

Q: What did you take from Lewis Carrol’s source material?

A: It’s based on all of Lewis Carrol’s material, including the “Jabberwocky Poem.” Past “Alice” films were always just a girl wandering around passively with a lot of weird characters. We tried to weave it into a story that has emotion to it and makes sense.

Hello, you or someone attempted to correct Lewis Carroll’s name in the Tim Burton interview for “Alice In Wonderland” — but the correction is wrong! It was initially “Carol,” now it’s “Carrol,” when it should be “Carroll.” Oy!

Merrick Again….

Thanks. Oy indeed. We corrected. Twice: GBU Editor

Visitors Dan Rutherford (R) and Kelly Bailey, dressed respectively like The Mad Hatter and Alice Kingsley from “Alice in Wonderland,” pose during the 40th annual Comic Con Convention in San Diego July 23, 2009. REUTERS/Mario Anzuoni

Join the Facebook Good, Bad, Ugly Blog Network

July 20th, 2009

Fire the editor?

Posted by: Robert Basler

Actress Mischa Barton on “psych hold” in L.A.

But her character was killed off at the end of the third season in 2006, and the show was canceled the following year. The actress has appeared in a strong of low-profile features since then.

String, not ”strong.” Tell your editor to be more observant. I expect this from bloggers but not Reuters.

Straak

You should probably fire the editor for this story.  You meant to say “string,” not “strong.” How do I get that editor’s job?

Hummer

Yes, we did mean ”string,” but firing the editor for missing a typo seems kind of harsh. Couldn’t we just beat him? GBU Editor

Actress Mischa Barton arrives for the British Academy Television Awards 2009 at the Royal Festival Hall in London, April 26, 2009. REUTERS/Luke MacGregor