Global News Journal
Beyond the World news headlines
Does Obama deserve the Nobel Peace Prize?
U.S. President Barack Obama has won the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize. The Norwegian Nobel Committee said Obama had been awarded the prize for his calls to reduce the world’s stockpiles of nuclear weapons and work towards restarting the stalled Middle East peace process.
The committee praised Obama for “his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples.”
“Very rarely has a person to the same extent as Obama captured the world’s attention and given its people hope for a better future.”
The laureate wins a gold medal, a diploma and 10 million Swedish crowns (1.4 million dollars or 878,000 pounds).
Obama was one of a record 205 nominees for this year’s prize and the decision has come as a surprise to many. Zimbabwe’s Prime Minister, Morgan Tsvangirai, had been tipped as one of the favourites.
Despite his ambitious international agenda, Obama is yet to make a significant breakthrough in the Middle East or effectively deal with the threat of Iran’s nuclear programme and his country is currently fighting wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Has Obama done enough to justify winning the Nobel Peace Prize? If not, who do you think should have won?
Comments RSS
Hello everyone. To all of those in doubt as to why President Obama righteously won the Nobel Peace Prize, I am going to summarize here. First and foremost, he is trying to reduce the stockpiles of nuclear weapons around the world, he is also very involved in the Middle East peace, and he is looking for different alternatives to the war in Afghanistan, rather than send out thousands of troops unnecessarily. He is working hard and fixing what past leaderships could not. Now, if you’re still in doubt of who better than President Obama to receive such a nomination, I ask you, who in your opinion do you think should or could have earned such a nomination??
I think the committee is recognizing the profound impact our new president has already had in the world as he has made clear clear that the old US policy of “my way or you are my enemy” has changed. He has made clear that we will be working together with the other countries of the world instead of imposing our will. As that new vision becomes reality this award will become even more justified.
An organization that gives a “peace prize” to Yassir Arafat, the godfather of 20th century terrorism, has zero credibility to begin with. Obama and the Nobel Committee deserve each other.
Obama is an inspiration to the world. He has created a sense of hope that cooperation is possible where before there was only conflict. This, in itself, is a great achievement. Those who decry the award are part of old ways of thinking. The world needs to move on to new ways to solve problems. I am proud that an American President is leading the way.
The Nobel Prize committee had already lost credibility. Attaching “Nobel prize winner” to your name is no longer a resume enhancer. But this… this is just so over the top!
I am saddened by the news of awarding Nobel peace prize to Mr Obama, The person has not proven anything prior to becoming president nor he is able to find the peace between two parties (Republican and Democrats) in USA.
I think by just giving four speeches, at different venues if you can get Noble Peace Prize, many people are eligible. OK even if he is eligible for the award, is it possible for him to keep working on them until his peace proposals are achieved even after his presidency. Just for this prize sake if he can solve Israel and Palestine issue that is enough by the time he leaves his office.
I can not imagine him standing next to the greats like Nelson Mandela, Aung San Suu Kyi, Dalai Lama who sacrificed their life for the people.
Last but not least Noble Peace Prize has last its value and dignity. I am glad that Mr Gandhi was not bestowed with this unworthy prize, since he can not be compared with any body in this century. His contributions are well above this prize level.
I also feel Mr Obama should decline the award saying that he not yet deserve the Award, that would boost his image and honest opinion.
American , you should proud of your president.!!!!!
The Nobel committee completely cheapened the Nobel prize. Words are just words and BHO has lots of words.
How can you put Obama in the same class as Mother Theresa? He does not deserve this. Can you spell POLITICAL!
All Americans should be proud of their President! This is not the first time the Nobel Peace Prize has been awarded to promote future work towards peace rather than rewarding past achievements. This is one aspect where the Peace Prize for a long time has differed from the other Prizes. Without Mr. Obama, the outlook for peace and progress towards a socially just world would be much bleaker.
The criticism coming from right wing republicans is a clear reflection of how badly they want Obama to fail! The can’t bear to see him, or America under him, succeed in any way, which says a lot for their patriotism and perhaps in some cases even racism. There is no doubt that Obama deserves this honor even if it is in small part due to the huge relief that the whole world felt after Americans finally came to their senses and overwhelmingly voted for a sensible and pragmatic person like Obama to succeed the most hated warmongering President and Vice President in the history of America, who as you recall, were originally appointed (not elected) to the White House by the Supreme Court who overturned the wishes of the majority of Americans who voted for Al Gore.
I voted for him and still have a lot of hope that he will bring change to our system, but does the prize go to someone who has yet to achieve? My understanding is that he was nominated two weeks after being sworn in. I believe that he could achieve the prize after his first term. I hope this is not used against him and of course devalues the award itself. Just don’t understand why it was awarded at this time? Hope it was not a set-up?
This was a test of integrity, and the President failed it badly. He has given his enemies plenty of new ‘ammunition’ on many fronts: that he values hope and feelings over actual achievement, that he delights in hob-knobbing with the self-anointed elite, that it’s all about him. President Obama could have acheived much more by thanking the Nobel Committee, but turning down the award. Imagine how the agendas of ‘the 12 days’ are already being scoured for anything pertinent!
President Obama absolutely deserves it. I think Obama was an excellent choice and was pleasantly suprised when I woke up this morning and saw he’d been selected. I was initially rooting for the Colombian Senator, so I’m a bit disappointed for her, but if she had to lose to someone, who better. Yay!!!
“May God bring peace to whole universe”. Now someone please nominate me for next peace prize.
As if his head isn’t swelled enough. Now he can be associated with a terrorist murderer (Arafat), a phony science liar (Gore) and an America basher (Carter). I guess when you go around the world and tell everyone how horrible the USA is that constitutes peace. Seems to me Ahmedinejad goes around the world hating on America too. Maybe he’ll be next years recipient. Seems to fit the pattern. I wonder how many millions the Commandant in Chief will spend in tax payer $$$ going to Oslo to accept the award. I’m sure his wife will fly separately.
A nominee 2 month into the presidency, why not? It’s all about having great speech writers and knowing how to deliver the message.
I just wish we could stop all of this. Let’s focus on getting things done. How the world views us is important, but not our goal. Their views will be decided more on what we do anyways. Our President shouldn’t accept this award. Rather the world would be better served if he ask that this years award be given to all countries that from this day forward work toward a common goal down the road of peace.
The criticism coming from right wing republicans is a clear reflection of how badly they want Obama to fail! The can’t bear to see him, or America under him, succeed in any way, which says a lot for their patriotism and perhaps in some cases even racism. There is no doubt that Obama deserves this honor even if it is in small part due to the huge relief that the whole world felt after Americans finally came to their senses and overwhelmingly voted for a sensible and pragmatic person like Obama to succeed the most hated warmongering President and Vice President in the history of America, who as you recall, were originally appointed (not elected) to the White House by the Supreme Court who overturned the wishes of the majority of Americans who voted for Gore.
I guess we now know where at least some of that “stimulus” money went. What a joke … all of the other other Nobel Prize winners have just had their stature reduced.
Why award the “Prize” this year? Years when the “Prize” was not awarded: 1914-1916, 1918, 1923 & 1924, 1939 & 1943, 1948, 1955 & 1956, 1966 & 1967, and 1972. Obviously, in many of these years U.S. Presidents were involved in ongoing warfare by the U.S. defending itself and “fighting for peace”. At least in 1972 Richard Nixon successfully negotiated with North Vietnam effectively ending American involvement in the Viet Nam War, his groundbreaking visit to the People’s Republic of China opened diplomatic relations between the two nations, and he initiated détente and the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty with the Soviet Union. Still no “Prize” for actual deeds.
Why do you think Dalai Lama deserve the Peace prize? He continues to split the country and people. His religion is against the Church if you believe in Jesus. Read your bible.
Who is more deserving? I think the Nobel Committee has done their homework whether you agree or not you must respect the Nobel Committee.
I like Obama but lets be honest: For what???
It’s huge risk on the Nobel committee side.
He is still sitting president. What if he invades Canada and nukes Iran? Seriously, they just made fools of themselves.
I think I finally understand.
The Nobel Peace Prize is not about peace, it’s about who can tell the biggest lie!
Just like when Carter and Arafat won the prize for talking peace, while Arafat was supporting attacks on Israel.
Just like when Al Gore lied about global warming so he could earn millions.
Now we have Obama lying about hope and change, while tearing this country apart for political gain.
There is no change, just the failed leftist policies of the past. And hope is fading for all the people loosing their jobs and their life savings as he spends this country into the ground.
Iranians have had criticisms of American administrations, but this is the first time in 30 years that any U.S. statesman, besides Jimmy Carter, has had the courage and vision to move forward with negotiations, despite heated verbal attacks from Iran’s detractors, and instructed his spokesperson to begin the necessary dialogue and move away from military confrontation. Let us continue to follow this path in Afghanistan and the entire Middle East, where dialogue is only the first step toward a real peace on the ground.
Obama has done a lot to deserve the NOBEL peace prize! He went around the world to all the dictators and communists requiems and apologizes for the United States of America and all the horrible things we have done in the world. He has bankrupt this country so very soon we will no longer be a superpower that way all the 2-bit dictators and communists run countries can do what they want and we will not be able to stop them anymore. Al Qaeda and the militant Muslim work can run amok and take over. Yes, sir OBAMA really does deserve the NOBEL peace prize.
Rodney King famously asked for us all to just get along. Where is his peace prize?
BREAKING NEWS: President Obama has just been announced King of the World! Stay tuned for his acceptance speach while he stands at the front of the USS. America, with his arms out-stretched
He may have the biggest heart in the world, but his deeds absolutely do not merit the world’s greatest award for peace. Why not wait a few years and see what he accomplishes first? And yes, this makes a mockery of the Peace Prize.
Is this a practical joke? Someone please explain to me exactly what (other than giving lofty speeches) he has done to earn this. If I envision peace then can I get one too? How about if I envision peace, prosperity and also wish that Islamic extremists stop trying to kill me…now can I have one? Quick, before I lose the vision.
It’s 250 miles from Copenhagen to Olso. I guess that was stimulus money well spent. Norway’s economy should blossom, Denmark, not so much.
Truth is, i believe President Obama is a good man. but he is a man. i voted for him and would again. do i agree with all his policies? No. I don’t think i should have to agree with everything he says in order to believe in the man, since as two different people we are going to have different opinions. I believe he may have received the peace prize a bit early, before he has any true accomplishments that are worthy of such a dignified award. but by reading what President Obama has said i think he is of the same mind set as me, but is still honored to be bestowed with the award and knows better than to do something as stupid as refuse it. lastly, just because someone really does not like obama, that does not make them a racist! saying that is tantamount to racism itself, because you are implying that a white man cannot disapprove of a black man without it being based upon his race. people have always vehemently hated politicians, and while i don’t think it’s an intelligent way to go about looking at politics, it usually has nothing to do with race.
First and foremost, this is an honor for our president and our country. Then it’s followed with commentary on the news this morning saying some on right are thinking it could backfire on him. WHO ARE THESE IDIOTS!
Good for Obama, good for the country and YES WE CAN!
I think it’s kind of funny that many of you call Obama a socialist, since he’s not. You don’t even have a socialistic party of significant size. It’s obvious that you don’t know the real meaning of the word socialist. And yes, there are some people that could have deserved the prize more than he did for example Tsvangirai, but he is really trying to change the American policies from the Bush era (except from the war in Afghanistan, which will continue). I also saw a comment about Reagan and that he should have won the Nobel Peace Price, and that’s the silliest thing I’ve ever heard.
Let’s see…..Carter got it for LEAVING the Americans hostage in Iran; Arafat got it for killing the Jews…..now Obama gets it for placing the Jews at odds with Iran AND for leaving OUR troops lacking in support.
He kisses up to Chavez and the Honduran dictator who was OUSTED by his own government. Make sense???? Nope, but the Norwegians have lost their ability to make sense ever since they saw Carter as something other than an idiot! Obama has done NOTHING except ruin the American and the World economy. Bush and Reagan were far and above MEN of Character and Honor. This is a farce and a joke!
YES.President Obama deserves it.
The whole world was needing someone so sensible as President of the United States
Very disappointing. Many people have done so much, not to take away from the President’s agenda but what has he done that has been so inspiring? Since when was conjecture viewed as an accomplishment. Very sad and disappointed, now the Nobel award is on the same level as UN. Unreliable, Unreasonable, Unworthy, Unacceptable.
Troubled and saddened, not surprised.
I think the peace prize, whether people think he deserves it or not, is in perfect timing and taste. For to give this American President this type of award at this juncture is less a political endorsement and more in the vein of peaceful pressure upon the recipient. Here, as the President sits lately with his war panel, discussing strategies in Afghanistan, he is reminded of his powerful speeches and indicators of a peaceful approach with the bestowal of this award.
I am pleased he has received this award right at this moment as it puts the reputation of the award itself back to work, where it needs to be. By bestowing this award on an individual in the apparent process of seeking peace, the panel has bet it all on actions taken in the now – and stands not only to encourage a president in a tough situation, but also to renew the status of the award itself, and those who wish to respect it.
So, so far this president has accomplished:
- spending almost a trillion dollars of money that we don’t have to move the unemployment rate from less than 8% to almost 10%
- spent several billion dollars to give people who could afford, and probably were going to buy anyway, to buy a new car more money for their trade-in
- traveled the world making speaches that blamed all of the world’s problems on the USA
- promised to dismantle US nuclear weapons with no commitments from others to do the same
- lied to the American people about what his health care proposal is
- scared the business community so much, because of all of his spending proposals and tax increase, so that nobody is hiring anymore
- bought a new dog for his kids.
WOW – I can see why he won the peace prize!
Of course, President Obama deserved the prize. He had to correct the ignorant arrogance of the past administration’s decade of destruction. Congratulations.
And in a related story, the National Football League has announced that the winner of the 2010 Superbowl is the Kansas City Chiefs. The league commisioner said today the the 2010 Lombardi trophy was awarded to the 0-4 Chief’s becaause of their inspiriational rebuilding of the lackluster franchise.
lol…I’m not that surprised however, the Nobel commitee lost it’s credibility with me when Gore won for an decietful documentary. They are just trying to influence his decisions regarding Afganistan and Iran. What I am surprised by are the people on here sdaying he actually deserves this. What have you been drinking.
NO. However, I deserve a Pulitzer for a wonderful book I intend to write someday.
Mr. President:
Are you going to now keep your promise and donate your $1.5 million prize your families village in African finally?
“Oh, but there will be a big party here when Obama wins,” she adds. “We still have hope that he will bring electricity and build schools so the children have a good education. Maybe when he’s President of America, he’ll remember his roots and look after his community in Kenya.”
http://tinyurl.com/yhx9g5w
I was also surprized, if not shocked, when I heard the news – but then I started thinking and read the Nobel committee’s citation: “Only very rarely has a person to the same extent as Obama captured the world’s attention and given its people hope for a better future.” Hope is what people needed after what George W. Bush had done to the concept “Hope”. We are already seeing big impacts – like the changing situation on missile deployment by the US and Russia, Iran engaging in nuclear inspections/control dialog, Israel feeling the heat on developing on the palestinian lands. I realize we do not have any concrete results yet – but this noble peace prize should help move things in the right direction. Who says the Nobel peace prize can not be used to have an impact on the peace process – wasn’t the intent of the Nobel peace prize to inspire new people to work towards the world peace? In this case it should help the person, who is in the strongest position to impact change, stand more firmly for his vision and not get tired and beaten down by the kind of challenges the world-peace driving processes bring about. World outside of the US had never cared or been so enthisastic before, about who wins the US presidency. I believe, the guy fully deserved the prize!
Completely disappointing. People have a life filled with more accomplishments then he has had and don’t get this prize. He has done absolutely nothing so far as President other than spend the U.S. into the ground. This discredits the tradition and grandeur of the Nobel Prize.
I am an Obama supporter but I must admit that my first reaction to his winning the Nobel Peace Prize was similar to that commented on the board – why? Not to say that its completely unwarranted, but more because of who DIDN’T receive the prize. I am sure there are many folks with a life time of accomplishments who, at first blush, may be more worthy.
But really he does have some stunning accomplishment to his credit. First off, he is the first African American President of United States. Huge implications in North America. Despite his decision with regards to Afghanistan, as a young senator he voted against the Iraq war in a time when when it was not popular. In fact, one may argue had the US not distracted its efforts from Afghanistan at the time, he might not be confronted, to the same degree, with the decision he’s confronted now. His willingness to open talks with Iran. This in itself may be worthy of the prize. From my perspective this stance was politically risky and somewhat unpopular, but nonetheless the right thing for both sides. Finally, his immediate and unquestionable change in US international relations to the world (i.e., speech in Turkey to Muslim world, address at UN and G20 promotion of economic balance). These are not trivial matters.
Obama has divided our political parties, angered countless Americans with the planned cap and trade,government health plan (that will be forced on every American),greatly increased our debt, sided with dictators who hate America…
So far Obama’s time in office has been all about paybacks, his agenda, and himself. My “hope” is for a president who will lead the country, better our country, and better our world. This shows the NOBEL is a joke or liberal payback. You should DO something to earn this honor.
This man voted to continue the Iraq war, still has an estimated 120,000 troops in Iraq and plans to leave 50,000 there permanently. He has not closed Guantanamo and, in fact, seeks to codify enhanced interrogation and rendition into law. He has escalated the war in Afghanistan and increased unmanned drone bombings which kill innocent civilians in Pakistan. His rhetoric on Iran closely mirrors the run-up to the Iraq War. These are not the actions of someone who promotes peace.
Obama gets no money. This is a gift. It has to go to the US Treasury by law. Hope he cuts the deficit with it!