U.N. official clarifies ‘elation’ at Haiti rape reports

February 27, 2010

The deputy head of the United Nations’ peacekeeping mission in earthquake-ravaged Haiti, Anthony Banbury, raised some eyebrows this week when he told journalists that reports of only three recent rapes in the impoverished Caribbean nation “almost elates me” — ostensibly because the situation could be much worse.

A day later Banbury issued a statement clarifying his views on the issue:
“My remarks make clear my strong commitment to human rights protection issues, and my conviction that three rapes is ‘far too many’. I said that reports of only three rapes ‘almost elates me’ because of deep concern – by myself and human rights protection experts – that the large numbers of people who are living in cramped and onerous conditions in displaced persons camps could lead to serious protection issues, especially with regard to sexual violence against women and children. If the total number of rape cases is indeed three, while ‘far too many’, it would show that efforts by the U.N. and our partners to enhance protection measures for women and children in the camps were working to a large extent, and our worst fears were not materializing. This would be a source of encouragement. I have dedicated many years to protecting the human rights of vulnerable populations, and my career to public service. Far from belittling the crime of rape, my clear intention was to convey a sense of U.N. commitment and concern about human rights protection.”

What do you think about Banbury’s remarks?

photo credit: Reuters/Carlos Barria (A U.N. soldier in Port-au-Prince)


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

I think Banbury is sincere/correct in his words and the media always has to put their spin on whats said..Think about it 100s of thousands of people living in dispair, w/very little and in the open(3 rapes happened)
Great job doin A. Banbury

Posted by BoangSonoy | Report as abusive

Great job doin UN..more needs doin to help these folks..
Peace to Haiti

Posted by BoangSonoy | Report as abusive

I think the journalist that blew it out of proportion should live in a camp for a day or two…

Posted by DWParker1 | Report as abusive

They need to send them boxes of pepa spray and give to all the women and children for rapist.

Posted by rueters1000 | Report as abusive

One can easily see why Banbury was elated. He was not elated by the rapes but rather by the very low number of rapes , 3 and that statistic is something to be pleased about.

Posted by jkelland | Report as abusive