The (CDS) cost of being in the euro
What’s the damage from being a member of the euro? German credit default swaps, used to insure risk, have spiralled to record highs over 130 basis points, three times the level of a year ago amid the escalating brouhaha over Spain’s banks and Greek elections. U.S. CDS meanwhile remain around 45 bps. That means it costs 45,000 to insure $10 million worth of U.S. investments for five years, compared to $135,000 for Germany. (click the graphics to enlarge)
A smaller but similarly interesting anomaly can be found in central Europe. Take close neighbours, the Czech and Slovak Republics who are so similar they were once the same country. Both have small open economies, reliant on producing goods for export to Germany.
The difference is that Slovakia joined the euro in 2009.
Back then, with the world grappling with the fallout from the Lehman crisis, Slovakia appeared at a distinct advantage versus the Czech Republic. At the height of the crisis in February 2009, Czech 5-year CDS exploded to 300 bps, well above Slovakia’s levels. But slowly that premium has eroded. A year ago CDS for both countries were quoted at similar levels of around 70 bps. Now the Czech CDS are quoted at 125 bps, having risen along with everything else, but Slovak CDS have jumped to 250 bps, data from Markit shows. (bonds have not reacted in the same manner — Slovak 1-year debt still yields around 0.8 percent versus 1.4 percent for the Czech Republic; similarly German yields have fallen to zero; for an explanation see here).
According to Benoit Anne, head of emerging markets research at Societe Generale:
These days being outside the euro zone is better than being in it and being outside the European Union is better than being inside it. The Slovak market has suffered a huge cost from a market perspective because of its membership of the euro.
Should the crisis worsen and a messy euro zone breakup materialises, countries such as Turkey and Russia will fare better than Poland which is closer to the epicentre of the earthquake, Anne says:
The further you are from the EU, the better placed you are.