Betting on (expensive and over-owned) Indian equities
How much juice is left in the Indian equity story? Mumbai’s share index has raced to successive record highs and has gained 24 percent so far this year in dollar terms as investors have bought into Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s reform promises.
Foreign investors have led the charge through this year, pouring billions of dollars into the market. Now locals are also joining the party – Indian retail investors who steered clear of the bourse for three years are trickling back in – they have been net investors for 3 months running and last month they purchased Rs 108 billion worth of shares, Citi analysts note.
Foreigners meanwhile have been moving down the market cap scale, with their ownership of the top 100-500 ranked companies rising from 13% to 15% over the quarter. That’s behind the broader BSE500 index’s outperformance compared to the Nifty index, Citi said.
Citi earlier this month predicted another 3 percent gains for Indian stocks by year-end. Equity derivatives indicate that is feasible – stock exchange data shows foreign investors are loading up on call contracts on the Nifty index at the 8,000 point and 8,100 point levels -a call option gives its holder the right to buy the underlying cash shares. The index is currently trading at 7,800 points.
Now people are starting to wonder how much further this has to run.
One problem with the Indian market is the valuation. Always expensive by emerging market standards, Indian shares are trading at more than 16 times forward earnings on average, a bit above its long-term average and the second priciest market in Asia. Growth is chugging along at below 6 percent and high inflation means interest rates may rise further. Investors’ positioning moreover is pretty heavy -India is the second biggest emerging market overweight among funds after China. HSBC analysts advise keeping India at marketweight in portfolios, arguing that market upside would be limited from here.
A lot depends on the ability of the Modi government to kick-start stalled infrastructure projects, the value of which is estimated at $134 billion. Societe Generale is optimistic, predicting the Nifty to hit 10,500 points by end-2016.
Our base case scenario is that the government will be able to revive projects worth $60 billion. This should lead to a sustainable improvement in GDP growth and corporate earnings and to a structural rally in the Sensex. In India, capex is one of the most important data with a direct impact on the equities. We believe that if the government is able to revive the long-term investment cycle, the current bull run in Indian markets may well outlive the term of the current government in office (i.e. beyond 2019), and we can expect much higher GDP growth rates and Sensex targets.
Three months into his term, Modi has disappointed some by failing to unveil sweeping reforms. But he appears to have done enough to keep the momentum alive — in his Independence Day speech last week, Modi didn’t unveil any big-bang reforms but vowed to fire up India’s sluggish bureaucracy, improve governance and boost manufacturing. For now, investors are giving him the benefit of the doubt.