The Great Debate UK

from Commentaries:

Goodness, now Rio finds it can afford a dividend

Can it really be a mere six months since Rio Tinto agreed to sell its birthright to Chinalco, losing its chairman-designate in the process? Indeed it can, and it shows how fast things change in the whacky world of commodities. In February, the directors panicked that the business might run out of cash; now they are signalling that they should be able to find $1.75 billion, or around $1.15 a share, for a dividend next year.

In hindsight, it looks frightfully clever of them to use the balance sheet of China Inc. (for a mere $195 million break fee) to buy time to find a better way out of the financial hole they dug. After all, the Chinalco deal could not be consummated without shareholder approval, which could not be sought until various regulators round the world had agreed it, a process bound to take many months.

In fact, it looks as though they got the right answer for the wrong reason, allowing the new, post-Chinalco chairman Jan du Plessis to brag about “renewed financial strength and a leaner cost base.” Even so, it’s a bit rich for the directors to boast about “delivering on commitments made in December 2008”.

Thanks largely to last month’s thumping $15 billion rights issue, debt is no longer a problem. All the debt incurred to overpay for Alcan in 2007 has now been repaid, so Rio can get on with the important task of rebuilding its relationship with China, the most important customer for its iron ore. There is much to do here, following the arrest of its negotiating team, but the heat seems to have gone out of the confrontation, and neither side can do without the other.

from The Great Debate:

Bet on small firms to lead China global foray

Wei Gu--Wei Gu is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are her own--

Chairman Mao used to say the truth is always kept by the minority.

A little-known private Chinese machinery company's bid for a GM marque has been sneered at by even the patriotic Chinese media, but the deal could succeed where mightier plays like Chinalco's for Rio Tinto have failed.

True that private sector firms face an uphill battle in China against more dominant state-backed firms, but it seems like double standards when Western observers, who extol the virtues of the private sector taking the driver's seat, praise Chinalco's deal but dismiss Tengzhong's bid for Hummer.

The rights road to Rio


– Neil Collins is a Reuters columnist. The views expressed are his own –
Shareholders in Rio Tinto would very much like to buy a bond yielding 9 percent, convertible into ordinary shares at $45, a tiny premium to today’s price of 29.30 pounds.

Unfortunately, if their board gets its way, they won’t get the chance, since the bonds are all being bought by the state-owned Aluminium Corporation of China (Chinalco).