Global recession has begun

November 4, 2008

John Kemp — John Kemp is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are his own —

LONDON (Reuters) – Yesterday’s bleak reports on the state of U.S and European manufacturing confirmed that a global recession has already begun.

The Institute of Supply Management (ISM)’s composite business activity indicator plunged for the second month to 38.9 – far below the 50-point threshold dividing expanding activity from a contraction, and the lowest level since September 1982 (see chart

The 11-point plunge in the index over the last three months (August-October) has been equaled on only four occasions since 1945 (1949-50, 1959-60, 1974 and 1980-81).

It dispels any remaining doubt that the United States has already entered recession – which the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) defines as “a significant decline in economic activity, spread across the economy, lasting more than a few months”.

The economy has been in trouble for more than a year. Manufacturing output peaked in July 2007 and had fallen 2.3 percent by August 2008 according to estimates published by the Federal Reserve. Private sector jobs peaked in November and were down 0.7 percent by August.

Repeat claims for unemployment insurance had risen almost 1 million over this period, and the number of people in desperate poverty receiving help under the federal government’s Aid to Families with Dependent Children (food stamp) program surged almost 2.5 million.

But until the last two months, problems had been largely confined to the motor manufacturing and construction sectors. While production of cars and light trucks declined 28 percent between July 2007 and August 2008, output of other durable items intended to last at three years or more actually rose, albeit by a marginal 0.4 percent.

Nonfarm businesses eliminated 815,000 positions on a net basis between November 2007 and August 2008. But most job losses were recorded in construction (-360,000) and motor manufacturing (-105,000) with fairly modest losses spread across the rest of the manufacturing and service industries (-349,000).


In the last two months, however, the downturn has widened to the rest of the economy as growing financial turmoil and a darkening outlook have caused households and businesses to prepare for a long and deep slump by retrenching.

Retail sales have fallen in each of the last three months (July-September). But the Census Bureau measures sales in cash terms rather than by volume, so the headline numbers tend to be distorted by changes in the price of gasoline, as well as financing programs and deep discounting designed to shift auto inventories.

A better guide to the underlying strength of the consumer sector is “core sales” of items other than autos and gasoline. Core sales fell in both August and September, the largest cumulative decline since the immediate aftermath of the attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon, the first consecutive monthly decline in more than a decade.

Core sales have risen on average just -0.12 percent in each of the last 12 months. Since even core inflation has been running faster than this, sales volumes have been flat or falling for a year. But the pace of decline has accelerated sharply in recent weeks.

Slowing consumer spending and business investment is now working through to falling output. Manufacturing production slumped in September (-2.7 percent) and for the first time losses were concentrated outside motor manufacturing (-3.0 percent) as producers responded to falling orders by slashing output to prevent a build up of unsold inventory.

ISM reports that 46 percent of survey respondents reduced production and 40 percent cut employment last month. Even so, 52 per cent of manufacturers reported a fall in new orders and 50 percent reported shrinking order books.

The pace of job losses picked up sharply in September, with private-sector employers eliminating 168,000 positions (net basis) and most of the job cuts coming from industries other than construction and autos (-115,000). The market is braced for a further big fall in nonfarm employment when data for October is published on Friday.

The downturn is now spreading internationally. Purchasing surveys show declines in output, orders and employment in all three of the major eurozone economies last month. The European Commission has already accepted that the eurozone economy is in recession.

In the United Kingdom, with its construction and financial-services dependent economy, real gross domestic product fell 0.5 percent during Q3. Japan’s economy was already shrinking in Q2 and the slide looks set to intensify during Q3, with the purchasing index falling further and further into negative territory.

The main bright spot in an otherwise gloomy picture is continued growth in China and some of the other emerging economies of Asia and the Middle East. But even here, there are signs that export-led economies are slowing as the recession hits their main customer-base in North America and Western Europe.


The other bright spot is a sharp reduction in inflationary pressure as the price of energy and other raw materials pulls back sharply from the summer’s highs. For the first time since October 2006, the ISM’s survey found more commodities declining in price (12) than rising (5) last month (see chart ISM reported widespread falls in the price of energy (diesel and natural gas), steel (stainless and cold-rolled coil), and base metals (aluminum, nickel, zinc and copper products).

Falling commodity prices will ease some upward pressure on manufacturing and transportation costs, and relieve the squeeze on margins. But it is unlikely to provide a substantial cushion for corporate cash flows amid a steep fall in demand, and further substantial reductions in output and employment appear inevitable in the next 3-6 months, intensifying the recessionary dynamic.

The swift turn in the business cycle has banished fears of inflation and enabled central banks to focus policy on supporting the banking system and restarting growth. The global rate cycle has clearly peaked, with rate reductions in the last month across the United States, Canada, Eurozone, United Kingdom, Japan, Switzerland, Australia, New Zealand and China.

But with the massive overhang of debt inherited from the boom years (especially in the United States and the Anglo-Saxon economies), bank balance sheets severely impaired, and extreme uncertainty about the outlook, demand for credit and lending activity looks set to remain weak, despite reductions in policy rates.

A broad-based recession has already begun across the advanced industrial economies which looks set to be the worst since 1980-81, if not 1945. Sharply falling demand for energy and other raw materials used in manufacturing and construction has already pushed most markets from oil and refined products to steel, copper, aluminum, nickel and ocean freight into surplus.

For the next 18 months, commodity markets will be shaped by an environment of weak demand and incipient surpluses.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

enough doom and gloom..we already know the us was in recession..defined as two quarters of negative growth even though mccain failed to recognize the facts.

lets review over 7 fed rate cuts with the current rate at 1%.all of the g7 nations cut rates.250 billion approved by congress and used to add to bank financial statements greenspan stated this was enough.the commercial paper mk thawing and rates are down.a new and ligimately elected president with a democratic congress.
all on the same page not like the republicans. housing prices falling 20% and now banks realize better to refi exisiting homeowners than take the homes away and let them sit on the mkt.
nationalized industries and banks cutting back on consumer credit so no more over borrowing.china,japan,the eu are all on the same page working in unison to propel their economies upward.the first month of real estate sales went up in september.the homebuilders and the gov moving towards the green economy…more energy efficiancy and creating 5 million green jobs.less than i million jobs lost in the year 2008.
with the current shake out americans will not spend like druken sailers americans will become more cautious with their money. women will start to expect less..smaller homes,less disposable income,less going out every friday and saturday,more sex to keep their husbands,,less spent on credit cards more spent on thrift more suvs smaller more energy efficiant more second cars
public transportant will become the norm.a contraction in the american lifestyle amercans consume 23% of the worlds energy with only 10% of the worlds people.this will become more balanced.

Posted by economic guy | Report as abusive

The idea that inflation is falling, is absurd, because the whole concept as it is generally understood in modern economics is poorly conceived. Prices falling does not necessarily equal lower inflation. It is more like deflation which is the serious aftermath of speculative bubbles. The fact is that energy prices are still up a huge amount over what they would have been if a steady rise in price of say 3% annually had been occurring.

These costs to the economy are a direct windfall to the petroleum industry and speculators who are in position to move markets.

What we are experiencing in this extremely volatile whipsawing economy is the last of the grand larceny against the hundreds of millions of ordinary citizens, municipalities and investors by financial criminals in league with their politician friends.

The many trillions of dollars that have been removed from all asset classes have simply switched from one pocket to another. Namely the guileless ordinary citizens losses are the gains of a few big-time insiders.

This is the lesson of not impeaching clearly criminal behavior in government. You get no end to the audacity of greed and criminality. If the leaders are crooks then their sycophants are crooks and it filters down through society.

This is why the founders of this nation made a clear path for removing leadership engaged in criminal activity, misfeasance and malfeasance. But our political system has been bought by the very forces they were supposed to protect us from. By not doing their duty to the constitution our “representatives” have consigned the entire nation to a long period of stress and suffering.

But in the end this is a government of the people. By not marching in the streets in the tens of millions we have allowed the bad guys to win. So will we learn from this or just stick our heads in the sand?

Posted by Jonathan Cole | Report as abusive

Inflation is coming – not going

Sure, commodity prices are down from their highs, but it can take up to two years for a commodity, such as iron ore or petroleum, to work its way through the economy. Its may well fall below its current 2.9%, but not thanks to commodity prices. It’s the dollar.

But at the same time as the dollar is rising, the US is pumping unprecedented volumes of cash into the economy. The problem right now is that that money is frozen up and non-inflationary. Once it unfreezes, inflation is going to roar in and send non-import prices through the roof and lead to a falling dollar. It won’t be an accident – this is exactly what the treasury is hoping for so that housing prices will rise and banks will look healthy again.

But for those of you with cash savings, say goodbye to a big chunk of them as they get inflated away.

Posted by Peter | Report as abusive

The legacy of the Bush Administration will be a doubling of the National debt, and a long period of malaise followed by the demise of the dollar in 2017 when the SS becomes an expense instead of a way to make the deficit not appear as huge as it really is. The current projection of a ^1 10/12 deficit for FY 09 will prove to be wrong as tax revenues will fall during the recession. This is shaping up to be the Big One and that’s what we’re going to get–The Big One! Thanks Mr. Bush
I hope the big oil executive position you’re going to get was worth it!

Posted by Lowell | Report as abusive

no, it is actually world experiment with paper currency which is now collapsing

Posted by Mark | Report as abusive

Well Repubs, The coming chaos will show that those of you who have benefitted from your ignorance and greed are more vulnerable to those harmed by it. The fall we be bigger for you.

Remember the old expression “Eat the Rich!”?

Best be paying your guards well.

Posted by Chuck | Report as abusive

My worry is where these trillions of dollars being pumped into the financial markets coming from? I’m sure it wasn’t just sat in the ‘rainy day’ box.

Posted by Vardis | Report as abusive