John McCain, maverick survivor

November 2, 2010

In 2009, if you had asked the Tea Party movement regulars who their most hated Republican was the answer would have been John McCain in a landslide. For years, McCain has been the man much of the Republican conservative base loved to hate, thanks to his 2000 presidential run and his apostasy on campaign finance and other issues. Movement conservatives discussed a primary campaign in 2004. McCain’s losing the presidential race to Obama didn’t help his popularity one bit.

And yet, in this anti-incumbent tidal wave, where Republican incumbents and party regular front-runners (such as in Delaware, Nevada, Colorado) were taken down in record number, John McCain survived. Why?

Maybe because he knew he would be a target, or perhaps because he is more attuned to the danger, McCain acted differently than the other officials. He tacked hard to the right, ignoring a torrent of criticisms from his what he use to call his “base” – the media. He immediately took the fight to his opponent, going very negative, very fast. He called in chits – including an endorsement from Sarah Palin. The result was a crushing victory over a very well-known conservative. What’s surprising is not that McCain succeeded, it’s that others like Murkowski and Castle didn’t take notes.

Joshua Spivak is a PR executive and senior fellow at the Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform at Wagner College.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

I don’t know people are surprised that McCain has survived through it all. He is the right man for the job. Everyone talk how poorly Obama has done since taking office…Mccain would have done it differently, and better. Getting us out of this slump that we are in.

You can say what you want about John McCain, but he has been in politics a long time. I guess if everyone had listened to him in 2008, we may be feeling a little differently going to the polls today.

Posted by tammers23 | Report as abusive

Well said tammers

Posted by TommySherpa | Report as abusive

How does he do it? Uh, have you seen the types of policies Arizona enacts? Have you seen the type of politicians they elect?

It’s not surprising at all.

Posted by shawngrggs | Report as abusive