Holder follows GOP lead in easing harsh drug laws

By Grover G. Norquist and Patrick Gleason
September 26, 2013

Attorney General Eric Holder issued a directive last week, instructing all U.S. Attorneys to revisit current drug cases involving low-level, non-violent offenders and waive harsh mandatory sentencing requirements where appropriate.

In doing so, the White House is turning its attention to one issue — criminal justice reform — where Democrats and Republicans have actually found common ground.

Though crime levels have been falling for the last 20 years, incarceration rates and prison costs have sharply increased. It is the states, particularly those under Republican control, that are leading the way here — enacting reforms that have cut incarceration rates and costs and led to significant taxpayer savings.

The United States, which has 5 percent of the global population, houses 25 percent of the world’s inmates. This high U.S. prison population has been primarily driven by non-violent drug offences.

Mandatory minimum sentencing requirements are responsible for much of the drastic growth in per capita inmate costs, which have increased more than 34 percent in just the last 12 years — from $21,603 to $29,027. By comparison, the U.S. economy grew by 24 percent and the population grew by 11.5 percent during that same period.

These unjust, even nonsensical, penalties now in place at the state and federal level disproportionately harm minority households and communities. Though Democratic pundits and officials push the narrative that Republicans are the party of rich white people, when it comes to finding solutions to fixing our broken criminal justice system, it has been Republicans in the states who are leading the way.

Consider Texas, where the smart-on-crime policy reform movement began in 2003, when the state’s Republican legislators passed a law mandating that all non-dealer drug offenders convicted for possession of less than a gram be sentenced to probation instead of jail time.

The Texas prison system, the nation’s largest, was then in a tough spot in 2007. That year, the Texas Legislative Budget Board had projected that the state would need more than 17,000 new prison beds by 2012. In response, state legislators passed a $241 million justice reinvestment package that expanded drug courts, intermediate sanctions and other alternatives to incarceration for non-violent offenders. These reforms allowed the state to avoid the projected expansion, saving Texas taxpayers $2 billion.

Since passing these cost-saving reforms, Texas has seen its incarceration and crime rates each decline more than 10 percent. The Lone Star State now has its lowest prison population in five years, and the lowest crime rate since 1968. Not only was the state able to avoid the new construction costs, it actually closed a prison in 2011 — the first prison closure in Texas history.

In fact, Right on Crime, a national campaign that seeks to take the Texas criminal justice reform model nationwide, is run out of Austin. Recognizing the success of smart-on-crime reforms in Texas, other states have now followed its lead.

South Carolina legislators, for example, passed a legislative package in 2010 that reduced the application of hefty prison terms to those convicted of low-level drug possession. These reforms are projected to save Palmetto State taxpayers up to $175 million over the next five years in avoided prison construction and operating costs.

Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett (R) and the GOP-controlled state legislature changed state law last year, so that non-violent, low-level misdemeanor offenders now face sanctions other than prison. The reduction in Pennsylvania’s prison population is projected to save Keystone State taxpayers approximately $253 million over the next five years.

Also in 2012, Georgia Governor Nathan Deal (R) and the GOP-controlled legislature confronted problems with the state prison system, where population had doubled over the last two decades and was projected to increase by another 8 percent in the next five years. Rather than accept that fate, Georgia lawmakers passed a new law that increases use of probation and accountability courts.

This reform package is expected to allow Georgia to avert all the anticipated prison population growth and even cut the daily population by an additional 1,000 offenders over the next five years. These reforms are projected to reduce recidivism and save Georgia taxpayers at least $264 million.

This is also the case in Louisiana. Governor Bobby Jindal (R) signed state sentencing reforms into law in 2012 that are projected to save Louisiana taxpayers $200 million over the next 10 years. This reform package expands parole eligibility for second-time offenders and permits a waiver of mandatory minimum sentences for non-violent offenders — if the prosecutor, defense counsel and judge all agree.

With the highest incarceration rate in the country, Louisiana is a top prospect for further reform in 2014. The Pelican Institute for Public Policy, a New Orleans-based free market think tank, and the Reason Foundation will soon be releasing a comprehensive report on ways in which Louisiana can further reform its criminal justice system in a manner that promotes alternatives to incarceration, cuts down on taxpayer costs, reduces recidivism, and improves safety.

It’s nice that the Obama administration now recognizes the value of smart-on-crime reforms implemented by Republican governors and state legislators in recent years. Yet, at the same time that the White House cites Texas and Louisiana as models for criminal justice reform, however, it has been harassing Austin with an unjustified Environmental Protection Agency takeover of its air quality permitting system and a Justice Department challenge to Texas’s voter ID law, while also challenging Louisiana’s education voucher program that allows children to escape failing schools.

When it comes to fixing America’s broken criminal justice system, as with so many other policy challenges facing the U.S., the innovative solutions are coming from the states, those 50 laboratories of democracy, and not from Washington. It’s good news that the Obama administration and lawmakers on Capitol Hill have begun to take notice.


PHOTO (Top): Texas Governor Rick Perry speaks during the 2011 Republican Leadership Conference in New Orleans, Louisiana June 18, 2011. REUTERS/Lee Celano

PHOTO (Insert 1): Attorney General Eric Holder addresses the 2013 National Urban League conference in Philadelphia, July 25, 2013.  REUTERS/Mark Makela
PHOTO (Insert 2): The jury box (L) in a courtroom inside the Federal Courthouse, in Houston, Texas, January 11, 2006. REUTERS/Brett Coomer/Houston Chronicle/Pool

PHOTO: Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal speaks at the 2010 Southern Republican Leadership Conference in New Orleans, Louisiana, April 9, 2010. REUTERS/Sean Gardner



We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Don’t the GOP-run states cited here lead the US in percent incarcerated in the top five? I suppose these efforts might ease the financial strain, but how much? It’s only fitting to include the efforts of NJ’s Christie, who is now pushing reduced sentences for drug offenses – except he scrapped the state’s existing non-violent offender law (that reduced sentences for all non-violent crime) in his first year in office – because it was passed by his opponents’ party.

Posted by auger | Report as abusive

Norquist and Gleason claim “unjustified harassment” of Texas by the EPA.

The Huffington post reports…

EPA officials indicated they reluctantly were taking over Clean Air Act Permits for greenhouse gas emissions because “officials in Texas have made clear . . . they have no intention of implementing this portion of the federal air permitting program.”

I am of the view that Norquist and Gleason are just a tad bit “economical with the truth”.

Posted by gking | Report as abusive

Norquist has quite an imagination. That’s better than accusing him of being a liar and deceiver. His assertions that the GOP is in the forefront of reducing the prison population are nothing but ridiculous and contrary to the facts. Then, “facts” are not Norquist’s forte.

Posted by ptiffany | Report as abusive

Grover Norquist his law and order Republican cronies gave us the “War on Drugs” and “Three Strikes You’re Out!” laws that put 20 million Americans in jail for non-violent drug crimes.

Now that Americans have rejected the notion of putting people in jail for possession of Marijuanna, he want to take credit for it.

Grover thinks Americans are stupid.

Posted by Lord_Cavendish | Report as abusive

“The United States, which has 5 percent of the global population, houses 25 percent of the world’s inmates.”

Pretty much says it all. What with the advent of private prisons on the rise, expect the incarceration numbers to go even higher.

Posted by AlkalineState | Report as abusive

Interesting that Democrats have heartburn about reducing non-violent drug penalties when Republicans do the loosening. How about decriminalizing marijuana and freeing all existing prisoners held for a root cause of marijuana possession? That would cut huge numbers of inmates loose and empty the criminal training schools our prisons have become.

Our current political class needs to simply be kicked out of power. It is rarely responsive to public needs.

Posted by usagadfly | Report as abusive

Are these gentlemen paying for this commercial ? This should at least bear a meaningful disclaimer like ‘sponsored content’.

Posted by brianpforbes | Report as abusive

[…] signatory Grover Norquist co-authors this Reuters op-ed with Patrick Gleason, in which they further discuss how U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder is late […]