‘Charlie Hebdo’ killings are a test for France and all Western Europe

January 9, 2015

A woman participates in a vigil to pay tribute to the victims of a shooting, by gunmen at the offices of weekly newspaper Charlie Hebdo, in downtown Lisbon

What follows the slaughter of the senior staff of the Parisian satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo will be a test of the depth of Europe’s liberal instincts. The weekly paper, run by journalists with the real courage of their convictions, has done more than its duty for freedom of the press. It falls to Europeans to display their attachment to other pillars of a free society: the rule of law, the observance of democratic norms, the display of tolerance and nondiscrimination.

The script put out by mainline political leaders was essentially the same. This was a heinous and cowardly act. In attacking Charlie Hebdo, the murderers attacked the values of free speech and freedom of the press, fundamental to a democratic society. Our response must be hard and swift, but we must not allow disgust to demonize the many for the actions of the few. French President Francois Hollande, in a brief TV address soon after the murders, set the tone: “nothing must separate us.”

Others — President Barack Obama, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, British Prime Minister David Cameron — added their agreement. The common theme — “nothing must separate us,” that is, no witch hunts, no bombings of mosques, no murders or beatings of Muslims, no passing over from centrist democratic politics to a dark side of counter-extremism fueled by the implicit or explicit identification of Muslims and Islam as the enemy within. Radical Islamists are the likely murderers, some of them possibly radicalized — as the main suspects in the case, brothers Said and Cherif Kouachi, may have been — by extremist groups fighting in Syria and Iraq.

The center must hold if the mainline parties are to continue to command the political terrain.

But another pillar of democracy is competition among differing political forces, and even if these forces are distasteful to centrist-liberal opinion, the field must be as level for them as everyone else. The media have been deluged with warnings against falling for the easy fury of the far right — and it will come.

The first signs emerged within hours of the murders. Marine Le Pen, leader of the National Front, released a video on her party’s website in which she struck a presidential pose. She, too, called for national unity and claimed that it was her responsibility to defend France “against the war that has been declared.” Avoiding an obvious and probably unpopular strategy of blaming other politicians at such a time, she said it was a time to end hypocrisy and look facts in the face, to ask who funds the terrorists and which countries supports them. Le Pen did say that she was not speaking of Muslims in France who are “attached to our values.” But among the facts that must be faced is that the action was within the ambit of an ideology “responsible for thousands of deaths in the world,” and that it was designed to produce “submission.”

“Submission” (Soumission) is the name of the new novel by French writer Michel Houellebecq. It is a dystopian fiction that sees France taken over by Islam by 2022, its secular institutions hollowed out and refilled with Islamic teaching and customs, its people, in the main, happy or at least willing to collaborate for the sake of a quiet life that for men offers the advantage of polygamy and submissive women. (“Collaboration” is still a loaded word in a France where wisps of guilt for submission to the Nazis still waft about).

The fact that the murders occurred as accusations of racism and Islamophobia were tossed at the reclusive author is itself like a piece of fiction employing a far-fetched coincidence. Houellebecq, with his customary “I couldn’t care less” attitude toward the media, disclaimed any desire to libel Islam. Instead, he said that it remained a living, expanding religion while enlightenment values were dead.

The far right may hasten that last forecast. For the UK Independence Party, normally a mild version of the far right, its leader Nigel Farage spoke of a “fifth column” in European societies, armed and dangerous. Geert Wilders of the Dutch Party for Freedom, never accused of mildness, blamed Islam itself. For the Italian Lega Nord, now drifting further to the right and gaining mightily in the polls thereby, Edoardo Rixi coupled the murders to the immigrants, many of them Muslim, pouring into Italy from North Africa. The secretary of the new and fast-growing Swedish Democrats, Bjorn Soder agreed, adding sarcastically “the religion of peace shows its true face.”

Germany has been the bulwark against extremism of the right. It had been assumed, including by many Germans, that they had inoculated themselves against its temptations. Brown shirts haven’t — and won’t — appear on the streets of Berlin, but a new group, Pegida, has over the past week (before the murders) organized anti-immigration, anti-Islamist demonstrations that were well attended, though countered by demonstrations that favored social harmony in cities across the country. It put out a statement saying that, though leading German politicians, including Merkel, had all condemned it, it had been proved right.

These are toxic fumes wafting across a frightened continent. The killers chose their targets well, and clearly with some planning. The rights to speak, read and watch freely, the right to mock — all are embedded in the European psyche. Indeed, the struggles to secure these rights were largely carried on the continent. And as a by-product, they have killed police officers, the protectors of citizens.

The test is a civilizational one. How far can the response be a measured one? How far can the majority of Muslims be brought into the fight against extremism as allies, not as suspects? How far will elections — this year, 2015, will see many of them at various democratic levels — reflect the desire of the citizenry to be protected by leaders like Le Pen and Farage? That’s what’s at stake — the depth of civilized society itself.

 

PHOTO: A woman participates in a vigil to pay tribute to the victims of a shooting, by gunmen at the offices of weekly newspaper “Charlie Hebdo,” in downtown Lisbon, Portugal, Jan. 8, 2015. REUTERS/Rafael Marchante

158 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Another excellent article by John Lloyd which perfectly outlines the problem that western society is facing at present. The freedom of the press is paramount in any civilised democracy as long as western governments do not dictate editorials in line with there foreign policy.

Posted by Moties001 | Report as abusive

I’m afraid these events were inevitable as too many Muslim immigrants fail to integrate into western society.

I think the governments (French and British) as well as most of our media are partly to blame through being overly cautious about challenging Islamist fundamentalism. One only has to look at how the BBC, Sky and the British newspapers have reported this matter over the last two days. Not one of them has sought to publish the original Danish cartoons – which would have been the strongest way to rebuff this attack on the freedom of speech.

Islamists have sought, very successfully, to place Islam beyond reproach. Accordingly, our politicians and media treat Islam with kid gloves. Christianity and Judaism receive scrutiny and satire on a routine basis, but nobody dares to challenge Islamic philosophy and ideas. Few journalists get this.

Appeasement didn’t work with Nazi Germany and it won’t work with Muslim fundamentalism either. It needs to be tackled head on.

We should all draw cartoons of the prophet and post them on social media and newspapers. Relgion must be a part of society, not separate from it. Once Muslims get used to seeing their views debated, then maybe they will start to integrate because they will see themselves as no different to Christians, Jews, and people of other faiths and none. Currently, many Muslims do regard themselves and their religion as separate / different from mainstream society – and therein lies the problem.

In centuries gone by, people had to fight for their views to be critical of Christianity too. Heretics were murdered in their thousands, just for holding a different view from the mainstream orthodoxy. It seems society has to revisit that struggle now with Islam. It cannot be allowed to stand unchallenged and unscrutinised.

Posted by Gilada | Report as abusive

“no passing over from centrist democratic politics to a dark side of counter-extremism fueled by the implicit or explicit identification of Muslims and Islam as the enemy”
Mission Accomplished! Oh wait did i forgot to quote “from within.”.

Posted by kinngrimm | Report as abusive

“Germany has been the bulwark against extremism of the right. It had been assumed, including by many Germans”
Also many germans still and even less americans know that, after WW2, the CIA sposnord a “Stay Behind” Network of Nazis and ultra right wing NAtionalist across europe, which can be seen as the foundation of nowadays well conencted european fashist network. When after teh cold war, the support and financing for those groups stoped, tehy didn’t just fanish, they looked for a new target. GO USA GO

Posted by kinngrimm | Report as abusive

I wonder if in an effort to stop these murderous terrorist attacks, all the governments of the world may have to hunt down any “radical” islamists and deal with them as they would deal with the rest of the world.

These people committing these attacks and using Islam as a justification are “bastardizing” their religion and both muslims and non-muslims need to deal with these “radicalized” murderers – for that is all they are.

Posted by Robert76 | Report as abusive

Islam needs to self-police better. The radical ugly elements are no longer atypical.

Posted by AlkalineState | Report as abusive

The author is correct about the depth of civilization being at stake; but is completely wrong about the major threat; which is Militant Islam, on one hand, and a general policy of appeasement as practiced by the author and other Politically Correct versions of Harold Chamberlain. Hitler perhaps should have called himself a religion. These appeasement views are the equivalent of HIV. Islam, as practiced by a large percentage of Muslims, is a virulent disease. But what is really the threat is your attitude of appeasement.

Posted by stevez3 | Report as abusive

In seeking to avoid extremism, Europe (or at least continental Western Europe) seems to have adopted a consensus-oriented politics that can itself be extremely intolerant. Nothing can be done if any established political bloc objects, and, as a result, the only things that can be done are the 2d, 3d, or 4th choices of the established political blocs.

It would be very surprising if center-left political parties in the northwestern part of Europe are not decimated over the next few years, but I suspect center-right Angela Merkel is on a downward trajectory, as well. The reason is that current policies in several areas appear to be inadequate, while, at the same time, a politics that requires consensus on every major decision is unlikely to be nimble enough to adapt in time. As a result, electorates become attracted to less consensus-oriented approaches, and I believe this explains the attraction of right-wing parties in Europe. Even if they are perceived as being wrong or extreme, they are in competition with parties that respond to challenges by burying their heads in the sand.

Posted by Bob9999 | Report as abusive

France has no choice but to accept that their country, now overrun by Muslims they allowed in, must try to stand together. They should know though, that as soon as the Muslims are the majority, like the Mexicans in CA, they will take over and completely ruin the country.

Posted by Factoidz | Report as abusive

Most of the Islamic countries have an authoritarian regime. At best, a hybrid regime (Turkey) or flawed democracy (Indonesia & Malaysia). Whether these people know about democracy or not, there’s no guarantee they understand it or, more importantly, adhere to it. In fact, most of them settling in western countries carry on with their practices and beliefs, in a non-democratic way. They fail to integrate.

Yet it’s still us, Europeans, which must hold on to this mantra of tolerance and strive not to discriminate and to naively assume that they will observe our democratic norms, too. Are we really in our right minds? How many more deaths, before we understand that “the rule of law, the observance of democratic norms, the display of tolerance and non-discrimination” make a free society only if ALL individuals adhere to these principles.

The amount of cries from the media and politicians calling our societies to stay united is frankly sickening and it shows the level of ignorance of western leaders and population which fail to understand that these people are fundamentally different and while multiculturalism is a wonderful thing, law and democracy must prevail in a democratic country, over certain sentiments of tolerance.

Posted by we_europeans | Report as abusive

The US press has successfully suppressed the images that so riled the shooters. I am one of a few people that have seen the pictures, but without them the story becomes one sided, which is the aim of the US press thereby enraging the public and further fanning hatred and massive reprisals. The US already has been on a 13 year killing spree that will continue. The US has killed more people in this century than all other countries combined and these crude pictures have been suppressed skewing the story and making their anger seem irrational. Look at the pictures before you make up your mind.

Posted by psgreene | Report as abusive

Very nice words. But it still doesn’t address the question: Why are Muslims at the epicenter of much of the world’s violence, be it internecine terrorism or terrorism against others? Although the vast majority of Muslims are not terrorists, it seems that the vast majority of terrorists are Muslim. The Muslim community needs to do some serious introspection as this problem cannot be solved by outsiders.

Posted by CharlesParisFR | Report as abusive

It is the responsibility of a free press to tell the whole story and by not showing your readers the offensive pictures that enraged these Muslims you have misled your readers. It is fascinating that no US news source has printed the pictures in question so the censorship has been complete. The pictures are horrible and are calculated to incite which they did.

Posted by psgreene | Report as abusive

One of al Qaeda’s primary goals in committing atrocities is to drive a hard wedge between Muslims generally and the rest of the world. Their intention is to promote such an intense backlash and oppression of Muslims that more and more Muslims will become embittered and radicalized. In that light, an intense worldwide campaign to publish cartoons that degrade the Prophet Mohammed is exactly what al Qaeda hopes we will do.

The same strategy was behind the 9/11 attacks, and with the GW Bush government in power, the attacks succeeded beyond the terrorists’ wildest dreams.

It’s time we began responding intelligently, and avoiding inflaming anti-Muslim resentment any further. It may seem counter-intuitive, but that’s how to defeat the terrorists’ game.

Posted by Nickcw | Report as abusive

I am sure the leaders of the west would like to thank the terrorists for giving them the justification for decreasing the freedoms of all and for justifying their useless existence. There is nothing better for an inept leader under the control of corporate influence than a frightened and less powerful electorate. Combine these events and their affect on the general populous (at least the willing slaves) and the propensity for leaders to covet power and we have the perfect situation for allowing them to drive us deeper into a government controlled existence. The few voices that say we need more freedom, not less, will be drowned out by the cries of “save us oh great wonderful leaders from the enemy at the gate” , screamed by those that cannot think rationally about risk and whether these incidences really pose an existential threat. The US media on these topics has been at best silent and most often complicit in allowing for the “fearing” of the people. Perhaps now, with this event, some of them may see or understand the consequences of their silence and complicity. But, probably not most unfortunately. On the other hand, FOX, CNN, MSNBC etc. (it’s a long list) are not really about “NEWS” as much as manipulation for the corporate masters, so maybe my hope is a stupid one. I am sure they will hate on the muslims more, and estimate that we must be strong and give more power to the executive branch, and they will advise massive military operations that also happen to be very profitable for the weapons manufacturers, and they will do all this in the guise of preserving our freedoms even as they work to support the politicians who destroy them. But they will never admit that we are less free because we have been convinced by them that we are under a true existential threat by what I would describe as a gorilla operation, and have given essential totalitarian power to the leaders and have abdicated our responsibility as citizens in electing politicians as we demonstrate by our continued support of the demagogues on both sides of the aisle in Washington. So, a free press is good, and wouldn’t it be nice if we had one. I guess they let the cartoons tell the truth but never what is presented as real news, that has to be corporate fascist message.

Posted by brotherkenny4 | Report as abusive

Gilada, I have to say that yours is one of the most astute and eloquent statement of the main issues surrounding the Charlie Hebdo massacre that I’ve read anywhere. In many ways you state the problem far more accurately and persuasively than John Lloyd and other journalists. I wish the editors at the BBC, CNN, SKY, Al Jazeera, and other news networks could read your letter!

Posted by dlmfanon | Report as abusive

the hard lesson to the west is:speech is not free.

Posted by joeching | Report as abusive

It has been a very long time since human sacrifice was required in Judaism or Christianity or any other political faction when religion ruled lands. Some ultra-conservatives in Israel want to return to the “old ways” but those people need to be put out of our misery. Islam needs to be red-inked for all the stupid stuff that has been attached to it, red-inked for mayhem and murder in such pathetically stupid nonsense as this thing about how Muslims think Mohammed is God and Mohammed cannot be portrayed because Mohammed is God; if they had brains they need to be removed. There just isn’t any honesty about the stupidity of Islam, “Murder your daughter because she was fondled by someone else, it is an act of honor.” “Murder your Christian neighbor by burning them to death because they used one of your water glasses.” Come on people this nonsense is not religion it is a bigger lie to enhance personal ego that has absolutely no value to the world. Arabs are fine, they are Arabs they are not Muslim but like the Thuggee, Islam needs to be outlawed from the face of the earth.

Posted by SixthRomeo | Report as abusive

Boko Haram = Islam.

Posted by AlkalineState | Report as abusive

I just want to tell you that I’m newbie to blogs and truly savored this page. More than likely I’m want to bookmark your blog . You certainly have good article content. Regards for revealing your web-site.

Posted by try here | Report as abusive

It can be nearly impossible to find well-advised people on this niche, although you come across as like you realize which you’re posting on! Many Thanks

Posted by Natalia Feria | Report as abusive

It’s actually almost extremely difficult to encounter well-qualified users on this issue, in addition you seem like you know the things that you’re preaching about! Gratitude

Posted by Enoch Schoderbek | Report as abusive

Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research about this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I am very glad to see such great information being shared freely out there.

Posted by Sztachety Plastikowe | Report as abusive

Terrific work! This is the type of info that should be shared around the internet. Shame on Google for not positioning this post higher! Come on over and visit my site . Thanks =)

Posted by ogrodzenia PCV | Report as abusive

It is actually practically unattainable to find well-advised viewers on this theme, but you appear like you fully grasp what exactly you’re preaching about! Appreciate It

Posted by Filiberto Turinetti | Report as abusive

It is actually almost extremely difficult to see well-qualified women and men on this theme, however, you appear like you be aware of what you’re indicating! With Thanks

Posted by Andrea Mccamant | Report as abusive

It truly is nearly close to impossible to find well-educated men and women on this content, still you look like you realize the things that you’re indicating! Thanks

Posted by Ferdinand Seigle | Report as abusive

I just added this blog site to my google reader, excellent stuff. Can’t get enough!

Posted by ogrodzenia PCV | Report as abusive

I’d have to check with you here. Which is not something I normally do! I get pleasure from reading a put up that may make individuals think. Also, thanks for permitting me to remark!

Posted by Ogrodzenia | Report as abusive

I keep listening to the news broadcast speak about getting boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the finest site to get one. Could you tell me please, where could i acquire some?

Posted by Ogrodzenia Plastikowe | Report as abusive

I believe this website holds very excellent written content material posts .

Posted by Ogrodzenia Plastikowe | Report as abusive

It’s practically close to impossible to come across well-qualified visitors on this niche, still you look like you are familiar with whatever you’re posting on! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Elwood Seanger | Report as abusive

Might be mostly impossible to see well-updated readers on this theme, yet somehow you seem like you know what exactly you’re raving about! Many Thanks

Posted by Gina Unkn | Report as abusive

Might be practically not possible to find well-updated individuals on this area, although you come across as like you fully grasp the things that you’re talking about! Many Thanks

Posted by Wilfred Friedenberg | Report as abusive

It can be mostly impossible to find well-updated people on this theme, nonetheless you look like you fully grasp the things that you’re writing about! Cheers

Posted by Danette Bane | Report as abusive

It’s practically impossible to come across well-informed individual on this area, still, you appear like you understand which you’re writing about! Cheers

Posted by Jewell Aronhalt | Report as abusive

Might be mostly extremely difficult to find well-updated readers on this issue, nonetheless you seem like you understand whatever you’re posting on! With Thanks

Posted by Elijah Nutting | Report as abusive

It can be almost impossible to encounter well-updated visitors on this niche, fortunately you look like you fully understand the things you’re covering! Many Thanks

Posted by Suzette Lucear | Report as abusive

Very clear website , thanks for this post.

Posted by Ogrodzenia | Report as abusive

It truly is nearly not possible to find well-advised men and women on this theme, even though you come across as like you comprehend what exactly you’re preaching about! Excellent

Posted by Lucina Wojtanik | Report as abusive

It can be almost not possible to come across well-informed visitors on this niche, nonetheless you come across as like you be aware of the things that you’re raving about! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Lane Gautier | Report as abusive

Hiya very cool web site!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your site and take the feeds additionally…I’m satisfied to search out a lot of helpful information right here in the put up, we want develop more techniques on this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .

Posted by Sztachety Plastikowe | Report as abusive

It truly is mostly not possible to find well-aware men and women on this area, still you appear like you realize the things you’re revealing! Appreciation

Posted by Shan Wears | Report as abusive

It’s practically impossible to come across well-educated men and women on this niche, then again you appear like you are familiar with the things that you’re writing on! Regards

Posted by Georgiana Schweickert | Report as abusive

It can be nearly not possible to encounter well-informed visitors on this matter, nonetheless you appear like you be aware of exactly what you’re talking about! Excellent

Posted by Dalton Budnik | Report as abusive

It’s actually nearly not possible to see well-advised individual on this niche, even though you appear like you know the things you’re covering! With Thanks

Posted by Williemae Leeks | Report as abusive

It truly is nearly unattainable to encounter well-updated viewers on this theme, nevertheless you come across as like you comprehend the things you’re posting on! Excellent

Posted by Emerita Yang | Report as abusive

It certainly is practically unattainable to see well-aware viewers on this area, nonetheless you come across as like you be aware of the things that you’re raving about! Thanks

Posted by Bernardo Sirna | Report as abusive

cos innego a jak! http://szpachlowanie-poznan.pev.pl/ nie ma co!

Posted by sprawdz | Report as abusive

It truly is near impossible to come across well-updated visitors on this matter, however , you appear like you be aware of what you’re indicating! Regards

Posted by Carman Sgro | Report as abusive

It is actually nearly impossible to see well-aware visitors on this niche, unfortunately you seem like you fully understand exactly what you’re writing about! With Thanks

Posted by Hoyt Zalwsky | Report as abusive

It is actually practically unthinkable to find well-updated viewers on this matter, fortunately you come across as like you know the things that you’re posting on! Excellent

Posted by Brittaney Penaflor | Report as abusive

It can be mostly not possible to see well-qualified individuals on this content, however, you seem like you comprehend exactly what you’re writing about! Cheers

Posted by Lily Servidio | Report as abusive

It certainly is practically unthinkable to come across well-qualified americans on this content, however, you appear like you fully grasp exactly what you’re indicating! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Heath Harten | Report as abusive

It’s practically not possible to come across well-educated viewers on this content, yet somehow you seem like you are familiar with what you’re indicating! Thank You

Posted by Rene Plues | Report as abusive

It’s almost unattainable to come across well-qualified americans on this matter, unfortunately you appear like you realize whatever you’re raving about! Cheers

Posted by Rory Schlanger | Report as abusive

difficult time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and

Posted by Collene Cappetta | Report as abusive

I’d should check with you here. Which is not one thing I normally do! I get pleasure from reading a put up that will make individuals think. Additionally, thanks for permitting me to remark!

Posted by Sztachety Plastikowe | Report as abusive

Might be nearly extremely difficult to see well-qualified men and women on this theme, regrettably you seem like you fully understand those things you’re talking about! Appreciate It

Posted by Ursula Cabugos | Report as abusive

It is actually mostly not possible to encounter well-informed individuals on this content, nonetheless you look like you fully understand what exactly you’re posting on! Thanks

Posted by Preston Tieu | Report as abusive

Might be near unthinkable to come across well-updated women and men on this niche, fortunately you look like you be aware of the things you’re writing about! Many Thanks

Posted by Abraham Leta | Report as abusive

It really is nearly unattainable to encounter well-qualified women and men on this issue, then again you come across as like you realize the things you’re revealing! Excellent

Posted by Latonia Osaki | Report as abusive

It truly is mostly not possible to come across well-advised visitors on this area, but you look like you fully grasp what you’re talking about! Appreciation

Posted by Tyler Simoens | Report as abusive

It truly is practically unthinkable to come across well-advised americans on this issue, and yet you look like you be aware of the things that you’re revealing! Thank You

Posted by Ike Vanderhoof | Report as abusive

It certainly is mostly extremely difficult to find well-educated men or women on this issue, then again you appear like you know what you’re revealing! Appreciate It

Posted by Alec Odear | Report as abusive

I was examining some of your articles on this website and I believe this website is rattling instructive! Keep posting.

Posted by Morris Schreurs | Report as abusive

Might be mostly impossible to encounter well-advised readers on this issue, even though you come across as like you comprehend what exactly you’re talking about! Gratitude

Posted by Jacinta Tape | Report as abusive

It certainly is practically not possible to encounter well-educated individuals on this area, nevertheless you come across as like you be aware of what exactly you’re covering! Appreciation

Posted by Reinaldo Beute | Report as abusive

It truly is nearly close to impossible to come across well-educated readers on this area, yet somehow you seem like you comprehend which you’re talking about! Many Thanks

Posted by Henry Budzinski | Report as abusive

It truly is near not possible to find well-educated individuals on this content, unfortunately you come across as like you fully understand exactly what you’re posting on! Thank You

Posted by Chuck Szoc | Report as abusive

It’s really a great and helpful piece of info. I am satisfied that you simply shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Posted by Ogrodzenia Plastikowe | Report as abusive

It’s actually practically unattainable to find well-advised individuals on this area, yet somehow you seem like you be aware of those things you’re raving about! Appreciate It

Posted by Hipolito Mad | Report as abusive

It’s almost close to impossible to see well-informed readers on this niche, nevertheless you look like you are familiar with what you’re covering! Regards

Posted by Denver Burgs | Report as abusive

It is actually almost unattainable to encounter well-advised individual on this niche, unfortunately you come across as like you fully understand which you’re revealing! Gratitude

Posted by Gerri Klena | Report as abusive

It can be almost impossible to encounter well-updated parties on this content, yet somehow you come across as like you comprehend what you’re writing on! Appreciate It

Posted by Brendon Bueno | Report as abusive

It’s practically extremely difficult to see well-qualified men and women on this matter, nevertheless you look like you realize what you’re indicating! With Thanks

Posted by Dante Prevatt | Report as abusive

It truly is almost extremely difficult to come across well-advised individuals on this area, still, you look like you fully understand what exactly you’re raving about! Appreciate It

Posted by Odell Gojcaj | Report as abusive

It certainly is near impossible to see well-informed readers on this theme, nevertheless you seem like you be aware of the things that you’re covering! Appreciate It

Posted by Debbra Schemmer | Report as abusive

It’s actually near extremely difficult to encounter well-updated men or women on this issue, although you come across as like you comprehend what you’re writing on! Gratitude

Posted by Luna Molinere | Report as abusive

Might be mostly impossible to see well-advised men and women on this theme, then again you seem like you understand the things that you’re writing on! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Irving Oganyan | Report as abusive

Do you have a spam problem on this website; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; we have developed some nice practices and we are looking to swap strategies with others, be sure to shoot me an email if interested.|

Posted by Kelli Aparicio | Report as abusive

It’s actually mostly close to impossible to see well-educated men and women on this content, however, you come across as like you are familiar with the things you’re preaching about! Appreciation

Posted by Cordia Rogness | Report as abusive

It really is practically close to impossible to come across well-educated visitors on this niche, however, you seem like you fully grasp the things you’re revealing! Thank You

Posted by Magen Spragg | Report as abusive

It is actually almost unattainable to encounter well-informed viewers on this subject, but you look like you comprehend exactly what you’re posting on! Bless You

Posted by Bruno Bohn | Report as abusive

It certainly is mostly impossible to come across well-educated readers on this issue, nevertheless you appear like you are familiar with what you’re covering! Thanks

Posted by Micah Unavailable | Report as abusive

It is actually mostly not possible to find well-educated visitors on this matter, yet somehow you come across as like you comprehend what exactly you’re indicating! Thanks

Posted by Imogene Luedke | Report as abusive

It really is nearly close to impossible to encounter well-advised individuals on this theme, although you look like you fully grasp those things you’re writing about! Cheers

Posted by Hilton Gillilan | Report as abusive

It is actually practically not possible to see well-educated men and women on this content, in addition you seem like you understand the things that you’re talking about! Gratitude

Posted by Bret Cieslak | Report as abusive

It can be practically not possible to encounter well-updated visitors on this content, fortunately you come across as like you be aware of exactly what you’re preaching about! Appreciate It

Posted by Santiago Mertens | Report as abusive

I like this blog very much, Its a real nice position to read and obtain information. “Anger is a signal, and one worth listening to.” by Harriet Lerner.

Posted by Markus Latsko | Report as abusive

Excellent blog you have got here.. It’s hard to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!|

Posted by Drew Fetrow | Report as abusive

It is actually practically extremely difficult to encounter well-advised parties on this matter, however you look like you fully grasp which you’re writing on! Gratitude

Posted by Dannie Pring | Report as abusive

It can be almost impossible to see well-informed visitors on this matter, regrettably you seem like you fully understand what you’re writing about! Excellent

Posted by Colby Bertelson | Report as abusive

It’s almost unthinkable to come across well-informed readers on this issue, although you appear like you fully understand what you’re indicating! Appreciation

Posted by Rosalina Farve | Report as abusive

It certainly is mostly not possible to encounter well-updated americans on this subject, still you come across as like you are familiar with whatever you’re talking about! Regards

Posted by Belva Dellamonica | Report as abusive

It certainly is practically unattainable to come across well-informed men and women on this content, but you seem like you comprehend what exactly you’re writing about! Excellent

Posted by Carrol Burkle | Report as abusive

It’s actually near unattainable to encounter well-aware readers on this area, regrettably you seem like you fully grasp what you’re writing on! Thanks

Posted by Benton Benward | Report as abusive

It truly is near unattainable to see well-qualified americans on this matter, however you come across as like you fully grasp what exactly you’re revealing! Appreciation

Posted by Shanice Baugess | Report as abusive

It’s actually mostly unthinkable to see well-educated women and men on this niche, even though you come across as like you comprehend what exactly you’re preaching about! Excellent

Posted by Henry Boane | Report as abusive

It really is practically unattainable to see well-educated people on this matter, nonetheless you look like you be aware of which you’re posting on! Bless You

Posted by Lawana Terrence | Report as abusive

It really is near impossible to come across well-informed people on this niche, however, you appear like you realize which you’re preaching about! With Thanks

Posted by Dennis Bodda | Report as abusive

It really is mostly close to impossible to come across well-qualified individual on this area, fortunately you seem like you know which you’re posting on! With Thanks

Posted by Nickie Ling | Report as abusive

I am very happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the accidental misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc.

Posted by sztachety PCV | Report as abusive

It’s nearly close to impossible to find well-educated americans on this niche, nevertheless you appear like you fully grasp whatever you’re talking about! With Thanks

Posted by Marleen Dolecek | Report as abusive

It can be nearly close to impossible to come across well-advised people on this issue, nonetheless you come across as like you fully grasp what exactly you’re talking about! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Sydney Wellnitz | Report as abusive

It is actually near unattainable to come across well-informed people on this niche, yet somehow you look like you fully understand the things that you’re preaching about! Thanks

Posted by Waldo Easker | Report as abusive

I have been absent for a while, but now I remember why I used to love this site. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your site?

Posted by Eliseo Petton | Report as abusive

It truly is almost not possible to see well-updated women and men on this matter, and yet you seem like you understand what you’re writing about! Excellent

Posted by Angelia Boning | Report as abusive

It can be nearly extremely difficult to come across well-informed individuals on this area, even though you appear like you are familiar with the things you’re talking about! Bless You

Posted by Kayce Veltin | Report as abusive

Might be nearly unthinkable to find well-educated men and women on this niche, however you look like you realize which you’re indicating! Bless You

Posted by Pennie Simonin | Report as abusive

Good post. I be taught one thing more challenging on completely different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to learn content from other writers and observe slightly one thing from their store. I’d favor to make use of some with the content on my weblog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll offer you a link on your net blog. Thanks for sharing.

Posted by Sztachety | Report as abusive

It’s practically unthinkable to come across well-qualified readers on this content, even though you come across as like you be aware of those things you’re writing about! Appreciate It

Posted by Yee Caughell | Report as abusive

It certainly is near not possible to find well-aware individuals on this area, regrettably you look like you comprehend what you’re covering! Gratitude

Posted by Blossom Zaffuto | Report as abusive

It certainly is nearly extremely difficult to see well-qualified individuals on this matter, still you appear like you fully understand whatever you’re covering! With Thanks

Posted by Fausto Siggers | Report as abusive

Might be almost unthinkable to encounter well-educated people on this issue, however you come across as like you be aware of exactly what you’re talking about! Appreciation

Posted by Dwain Wodskow | Report as abusive

It really is practically unattainable to come across well-advised people on this niche, fortunately you seem like you realize what exactly you’re writing about! Appreciation

Posted by Eve Mongon | Report as abusive

Wow that was odd. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say wonderful blog!

Posted by Ogrodzenia Plastikowe | Report as abusive

It certainly is mostly unthinkable to see well-updated users on this area, however , you seem like you comprehend whatever you’re writing on! Appreciation

Posted by Zelma Nashe | Report as abusive

You completed several good points there. I did a search on the topic and found mainly people will go along with with your blog.

Posted by ogrodzenia PCV | Report as abusive

Aw, this was a really nice post. In thought I want to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make an excellent article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means appear to get something done.

Posted by sztachety PCV | Report as abusive

It’s actually almost extremely difficult to come across well-advised parties on this area, regrettably you appear like you understand the things you’re writing about! Excellent

Posted by Santiago Us | Report as abusive

I think you have remarked some very interesting points , thanks for the post.

Posted by Johnny Theriault | Report as abusive

Perfectly indited subject material, thank you for selective information. “The earth was made round so we would not see too far down the road.” by Karen Blixen.

Posted by Sztachety | Report as abusive

Might be mostly unattainable to see well-aware users on this matter, although you seem like you understand those things you’re posting on! Appreciation

Posted by Renda Steinacker | Report as abusive

You have brought up a very wonderful points , thankyou for the post.

Posted by Sztachety Plastikowe | Report as abusive

It is actually near extremely difficult to encounter well-educated people on this issue, yet somehow you seem like you are familiar with what exactly you’re writing on! With Thanks

Posted by Roderick Shomer | Report as abusive

Some really fantastic information, Gladiola I found this. “We must learn our limits. We are all something, but none of us are everything.” by Blaise Pascal.

Posted by telefonia VoIP | Report as abusive

It can be practically unthinkable to find well-advised visitors on this subject, although you appear like you be aware of what you’re posting on! Many Thanks

Posted by Peggy Paragas | Report as abusive

It is actually near extremely difficult to find well-informed women and men on this subject, although you look like you realize the things you’re raving about! Regards

Posted by Ryan Forlivio | Report as abusive

Greetings from Coloradolotopyeer! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to browse your blog on my iphone during lunch break. I love the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how quick your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, good site!

Posted by server minecraft | Report as abusive

It can be near close to impossible to find well-educated visitors on this subject, then again you look like you comprehend the things you’re writing on! Thank You

Posted by Phylicia Deets | Report as abusive

It really is nearly extremely difficult to come across well-informed users on this content, nevertheless you appear like you know exactly what you’re revealing! Appreciate It

Posted by Rosanne Reissig | Report as abusive

It is actually mostly unthinkable to encounter well-informed americans on this matter, but you look like you are familiar with which you’re writing on! Thank You

Posted by Micha Payenda | Report as abusive

It can be almost not possible to come across well-informed individuals on this theme, although you appear like you know those things you’re raving about! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Jonna Tremblay | Report as abusive

Nice weblog right here! Also your web site a lot up very fast! What host are you the use of? Can I get your affiliate hyperlink in your host? I want my website loaded up as fast as yours lol|

Posted by Twanda Light | Report as abusive

I love carpets and tiles, and this site is really interesting for me. You help the carpet community!

Posted by carpeta roaming | Report as abusive

It can be near not possible to come across well-qualified users on this content, then again you come across as like you understand the things that you’re writing about! Cheers

Posted by Delicia Kranwinkle | Report as abusive

It’s actually almost not possible to find well-informed women and men on this area, nevertheless you look like you understand those things you’re writing about! Regards

Posted by Vicky Barck | Report as abusive

It’s actually almost impossible to find well-advised men and women on this area, yet somehow you come across as like you are familiar with the things that you’re writing on! Cheers

Posted by Sidney Redhage | Report as abusive

I always used to read piece of writing in news papers but now as I am a user of internet therefore from now I am using net for posts, thanks to web.|

Posted by Danette Bramhall | Report as abusive

I was recommended this web site by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my difficulty. You are incredible! Thanks!

Posted by Daron Mikell | Report as abusive

It can be practically unattainable to encounter well-updated people on this matter, unfortunately you seem like you be aware of the things that you’re indicating! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Tyrone Paysen | Report as abusive

It is actually nearly not possible to find well-updated individuals on this niche, unfortunately you look like you realize which you’re writing on! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Dortha Galle | Report as abusive

It is actually nearly unthinkable to find well-informed men and women on this issue, even though you appear like you fully grasp which you’re writing about! Bless You

Posted by Brock Srsen | Report as abusive

It certainly is mostly extremely difficult to encounter well-advised people on this subject, then again you look like you fully grasp exactly what you’re indicating! Many Thanks

Posted by Roman Huges | Report as abusive

It is actually mostly not possible to see well-advised readers on this content, although you appear like you realize what exactly you’re revealing! Gratitude

Posted by Lynwood Brink | Report as abusive

Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do a little research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such excellent information being shared freely out there.

Posted by Norah Pauli | Report as abusive

It can be almost impossible to come across well-updated individuals on this matter, then again you seem like you fully understand what exactly you’re writing on! Thank You

Posted by Vernia Shufford | Report as abusive

It is actually mostly extremely difficult to come across well-educated people on this niche, nevertheless you appear like you understand exactly what you’re posting on! Gratitude

Posted by Aleisha Dezalia | Report as abusive

It’s nearly unthinkable to see well-qualified individual on this subject, however, you look like you know those things you’re indicating! Cheers

Posted by Ivan Ribb | Report as abusive

It’s arduous to seek out educated folks on this subject, but you sound like you realize what you’re talking about! Thanks

Posted by Lacy Kreitler | Report as abusive

It’s nearly impossible to encounter well-aware individuals on this theme, yet somehow you seem like you know exactly what you’re raving about! Thanks A Lot

Posted by Rheba Czarkowski | Report as abusive

It’s mostly unattainable to encounter well-educated women and men on this theme, however you come across as like you understand what exactly you’re writing about! Appreciation

Posted by Hayden Stead | Report as abusive

It can be practically not possible to encounter well-educated individuals on this subject, however you seem like you comprehend whatever you’re talking about! Thank You

Posted by Douglas Navarrette | Report as abusive

Really wanted to state I am happy I came onto your website.|

Posted by telescopic banner stand | Report as abusive

I like this post, enjoyed this one thanks for putting up.

Posted by Emerita Hazekamp | Report as abusive

Many thanks very practical. Will certainly share site with my buddies.|

Posted by literature racks wall mount | Report as abusive

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all folks you actually recognize what you’re talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly additionally discuss with my website =). We will have a hyperlink alternate arrangement among us!

Posted by Mabel Guenison | Report as abusive