A rally that is both rational and crazy
(James Saft is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are his own)
Stocks and other risky assets are rallying around the world this week because the Group of 20 nations said on the weekend they would keep the economic stimulus flowing, a state of events which illustrates where we are and what a very strange place it is.
The G20, the only group of big hitters that matters because it is the only group which includes the Chinese, met in Scotland over the weekend and, as is the way of these things, did very little with immediate consequences for anybody.
In the communique they issued, the Group of 20 finance ministers, after congratulating themselves on the recovery, more or less admitted that the measures we once thought of as heroic are in the process of becoming commonplace.
“However, the recovery is uneven and remains dependent on policy support, and high unemployment is a major concern,” the statement said. “To restore the global economy and financial system to health, we agreed to maintain support for the recovery until it is assured.”
Let me put that in human terms for you:
“We’ve spent untold trillions saving the economy, but, er, we’ve really only saved the financial system and that only to the extent that we keep on saving it. Jobs, well, not so much. We therefore pledge to continue doing this thing that may or may not be working until we are sure that it is.”
Property taxes, utility bills (you call them rates I think) haven’t changed and the towns and cities haven’t noticed that the bubble burst. In fact the property taxes and utility bills still creep upward due to their own COLA logic. This does not help the consumer who is supposed to be stimulating the economy through big consumer spending. None of this local taxation does anything to stimulate economic activity. It just sucks up income on more or less unproductive efforts. All town projects are really on hold. But it must be nice to work for the local schools or town hall. Talks with my dear old Dad remind me that this is what the Depression was like. You were well off if you worked for the Town or State government – but those days almost sound humane because town or state employees didn’t have contractual cost of living adjustments.
All the towns and cities may be doing is waiting until the dollar has inflated to levels where the assessments seem like they match and make sense again. Our houses won’t be more valuable, they will only sound like they are. But nothing much is selling so I can’t understand how that will ever work. Since the property in towns and cities has dropped appreciably in price and still aren’t selling, how can it ever get back, even with inflation, to the levels before the prices collapsed? There is some increase in the employment here but the wages haven’t risen. A very few more people can now pay their bills but those bills are getting larger. They have invisibly risen dramatically actually, because they are being based on assessments made at the peak of the bubble. But in visible terms they are still also rising.
It’s a little like living in an expanding universe and actually feeling the phenomenon.