The Bundesbank isn’t mad

By Hugo Dixon
February 18, 2013

The Bundesbank isn’t mad. In a world where it is increasingly fashionable to call for central banks to print money, the German central bank is one of the last bastions of orthodoxy. Although its stance is extreme, it is a useful antidote to the theory that easy money is a cost-free cure to economic ills.

The Bundesbank is hostile to anything that smacks of monetary financing – printing money to finance governments’ deficits. It is worried that central bank independence is getting chipped away as recession drags on in much of the developed world; it thinks that the European Central Bank shouldn’t respond to the recent rise in the euro by loosening monetary policy further; it is always concerned about the potential for inflation; and it thinks that spraying cheap money around can allow governments to shirk their responsibilities.

To many people, these attitudes seem old-fashioned. Surely central banks should bend the rules to get the world economy out of its current rut? A few go even further and advocate “overt monetary financing”, as Adair Turner, chairman of the UK’s Financial Services Authority, did in a seminal speech earlier this month. Overt monetary financing involves governments deliberately running fiscal deficits and openly funding them by borrowing from central banks.

Turner made clear that this was a policy that should be reserved for the most intractable deflationary recessions – where monetary policy can’t work (because businesses and households are already so clogged up with debt that they don’t want to borrow) and fiscal policy can’t do the trick either (because governments are over-indebted too). While he advocated the medicine for Japan, he was wary about giving it to the United States, Britain or the euro zone.

The ECB, it should be added, is not engaging in overt monetary financing. That’s forbidden under the Maastricht Treaty. But it is arguably engaging in the covert variety. This is the source of most of the friction between Mario Draghi, president of the ECB, and Jens Weidmann, the Bundesbank boss – both of whom are based in Frankfurt, where I spent part of last week.

The biggest clash was over Draghi’s promise last year to buy potentially unlimited amounts of government bonds from peripheral euro zone countries. Weidmann unsuccessfully opposed the plan. Draghi was right. If he hadn’t pledged to do “whatever it takes” to save the euro, the single currency might well have collapsed. That said, all such operations have a cost. Draghi’s drug may have taken some of the pressure off governments to make their economies more competitive.

Weidmann and Draghi clashed again this month over Ireland’s “bailout” by its central bank. The extremely complex transaction involved the Irish central bank receiving 25 billion euros of extremely long-dated Irish government bonds after IBRC, a bust nationalised bank was liquidated. Dublin did not itself have the cash to fill the hole in IBRC’s balance sheet. It has effectively borrowed the money – equivalent to 15 percent of GDP – cheaply from its central bank.

Weidmann would have preferred the euro zone governments to lend Dublin the money via their bailout fund, the European Stability Mechanism (ESM). But the other governments weren’t rushing to provide the cash and Dublin wasn’t keen either, as the interest rate would have been higher than issuing bonds to its central bank.

Although the Irish bailout was a deal between Dublin and its central bank, the ECB could have blocked it. But to do so, two-thirds of its governing council would have had to vote against the operation – and Weidmann didn’t have enough support.

Draghi, meanwhile, didn’t actually back the deal. He merely “noted” it. The ECB concluded that the new arrangements for supporting IBRC were preferable to the previous scheme – which many observers also thought amounted to monetary financing.

As with Draghi’s bond-purchasing promise, the impact has been hugely positive. Irish 10-year government bond yields are now only 3.7 percent. Investors now view the country as on the road to recovery.

But the Bundesbank is, understandably, worried about precedents. The next time a bank gets into trouble in the euro zone, what is to stop a government from bailing it out the Irish way – by getting its central bank or the ECB itself to print the necessary money?

The pressure to engage in such monetary financing may be particularly strong given that the ECB is about to take over responsibility for supervising lenders. That means that, if and when there are future banking blow-ups, the ECB will be criticised for having failed to monitor them properly and could then be browbeaten to prop them up. The Irish, Spanish and Dutch central banks have all been lambasted for alleged lapses in supervision during the crisis – as, indeed, has Draghi himself following the recent troubles at Italy’s Monte dei Paschi.

A further difficulty is that the euro zone doesn’t yet have a fund for bailing out banks. The nearest thing it has is the ESM, whose decisions require unanimity. Just one government can veto a bailout. This means that, if there is a stand-off between the ECB and governments over who should prop up an ailing bank, the ECB may blink first.

Covert monetary financing may sometimes be the least of several evils. But if it becomes too common and transparent, there is a risk of debauching the currency. The Bundesbank’s constant warnings are a healthy counterpoint to that temptation.

8 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Yes it is… it’s suicidal, but you need to drive your car around the empty parking lot for a while, then boldly enter shopping mall (outside Germany) and listen to your own footsteps to get it.

Posted by satori23 | Report as abusive

Governments act responsibly? What fallacious nonsense is this!?

What those Germans need is a little dose of 1984 style doublespeak!

RED IS BLACK
PAPER IS WEALTH
DEBT IS FREEDOM

Posted by ShiroiKarasu | Report as abusive

How strong is the Bundesbank SPRING? If pulled too hare, too many times, the spring will break…..poingggg..

Posted by Willvp | Report as abusive

@ShiroiKarasu

AUSTERITY IS PROSPERITY

Posted by satori23 | Report as abusive

You have conveniently omitted to lump the Bundesbank with the other European central banks who have failed to properly monitor the reckless behaviour of their banks.
You have also made the point that monetary financing buys time for governments to restore competitiveness to their economies. Given the straightjacket of the Euro, monetary financing is the ONLY policy that could possibly help in improving competitiveness.

That the Bundesbank has decided to get on its moral high horse at this stage of the game is hypocritical
and self-serving. The Euro as well as the Euro Zone have benefitted Germany and, while the going was good, the Bundesbank stayed mum. Now that the bills are due, all of a sudden retrenchment and responsibe conduct have become imperative.

The Bundesbank knows that the common currency experiment in Europe has failed and that the Euro Zone’s economic woes will not go away until the Euro is scrapped.It will be refreshing if the Bundesbank steps forward and admits the failure.

Posted by Biscayne | Report as abusive

Biscayne, I think along your lines but how did the Irish central bank managed to print the money necessary to finance the Irish government? I thought not being able to print money was all the straitjacket of the Euro was all about? tx

Posted by lisandro | Report as abusive

Louis Vuitton Speedy 35FOLouis Vuitton OutletDOLouis Vuitton PursesETLouis Vuitton BagsBOLouis Vuitton Outlet OnlineFPLouis Vuitton OutletDTLouis Vuitton BagsASLouis Vuitton Outlet OnlineGPLouis Vuitton HandbagsDQLouis Vuitton OutletDOMichael Kors OutletGTMichael Kors Outlet OnlineFRMichael Kors BagEPMichael Kors Handbags OutletAUMichael Kors CouponGTMichael Kors BagsEOMichael Kors Outlet StoreDQMichael Kors BagsCQMichael Kors Outlet StoreCUMichael Kors BagsARbabyliss pro nano titaniumGTBabyliss ProEQbabyliss hair dryerAQBabyliss Pro Nano TitaniumBPBabyliss ProEOBabylissATBabyliss ProFPbabyliss miracurlEUbabyliss flat ironEQBabyliss Flat IronAOKate Spade HandbagsEQKate Spade BagsFTKate Spade OutletCRKate Spade PursesAUKate Spade HandbagsCTKate Spade New YorkGUKate Spade OutletCTKate Spade OutletFUKate Spade OutletBPKate Spade saleCQOakley OutletCTCheap Oakley SunglassesBSOakley Prescription SunglassesCSOakley SunglassesCTOakley Sunglasses CheapAOOakley SunglassesCSCheap Oakley SunglassesBRCheap OakleysBTOakley OutletAOCheap Oakley SunglassesGOJordan 11 Space JamDRSpace Jam 11sBRSpace Jam Low 11sGUJordan Retro 11DOSpace Jam 11sATSpace Jam Low 11sFOSpace Jam Low 11sAOJordan 11 Low Space JamGPJordan Retro 11ESJordan 11 Low Space JamFTKate Spade HandbagsERKate Spade OutletFSKate Spade New YorkBTkate spade pursesASKate Spade New YorkEOKate Spade OutletCPKate Spade Outlet OnlineCOKate Spade New YorkASKate Spade saleFPKate Spade Diaper BagERoakley outletBPoakley sunglasses cheapCQcheap oakley sunglassesFPoakley sunglasses cheapAOoakley sunglasses cheapCToakley outletDPoakley outletDUoakley outletFUcheap oakley sunglassesEPoakley outletDTray ban wayfarerFUcheap ray ban sunglassesDTray ban sunglassesGUray ban sunglassesDRray ban sunglasses saleFOray ban sunglasses saleGTray ban outletFTray ban sunglasses saleATcheap ray bansEOray ban sunglassesCOray ban sunglasses saleAScheap ray ban sunglassesFUray ban sunglassesCUray ban sunglasses saleDOray ban sunglasses saleFQray ban prescription sunglassesAOray ban sunglassesBPJordan Retro 9 BaronsDOJordan Retro 9 BaronsBOJordan Retro 9 BaronsBRBarons 9sBSJordan Retro 9 BaronsETJordan Retro 9 BaronsDOBarons 9sCPJordan 9 BaronsBTJordan Barons 9sBPJordan 9 Barons 2014CRSac a main Michael KorsFTSac Michael KorsCPMichael Kors FranceCQSac Michael KorsDQMichael Kors SacARSac Michael KorsERMichael Kors SacGSMichael Kors SacFS

As well as in this little existing tablet, Brevicon 1/35 for more than each year. I started my best past frequent period at The spring of 4, 2010, in the future very early just as my best 21 years of age time lively medicine stop over the Wednesday and i also begun blood loss over the Wednesday. My very own period of time has been regular. Following Chintan Shivir, any Jaipur commitment of any bash said, “the Indian State Institutions the first will always put together the capability of girls Personal growth Communities (SHGs). Indira Gandhi possessed started NABARD 30 years ago to help you induce farming along with country improvement. “The Institutions the first thinks that the next step is to ascertain a fanatical State Bank or investment company for women to deliver economical products and services to help you most women generally and women SHGs for example.Ins PTI AMR RAI.