Higher growth can help lower deficit

November 7, 2012

(The views expressed in this column are the author’s own and do not represent those of Reuters)

India’s bloating budget deficit has been a matter of concern. It means more borrowing by the government which results in overcrowding of the debt market and consequently, a higher rate of interest for the private sector. It also raises the rate on borrowings from abroad due to the downgrading by rating agencies which is bound to follow.

Finance Minister P. Chidambaram had therefore asked all ministries in May to cut non-Plan expenditure by 10 percent and has now banned new recruitment in order to reduce the deficit.

Government expenditure has certainly been getting out of hand, more due to subsidies on food, fertiliser and petroleum products. In the absence of these subsidies, the budget deficit would have been less than 3 percent. But subsidies are politically sensitive and can at best be reduced only gradually. Even a 7 percent cut in subsidies on diesel last September forced a change in the UPA government. Most other expenditures have become sticky and cannot be reduced without comprehensive administrative reforms.

But then there is the other side to the budget deficit. If expenditure cannot be cut, it is possible to increase income. It is precisely in the years in which growth has been high that budget deficits have been low. But to enhance its populist image, the government allowed expenditure to rise faster, resulting in lower growth and higher deficit.

Growth was high for three years till 2008. It exceeded 9.5 percent in each of these three years and brought in a flood of tax revenue. Corporate tax revenue increased the fastest, making corporate tax the single largest source of revenue. It is often overlooked that it is in the interest of the government to ensure that the corporate sector is offered facilities to grow faster and generate more income.

Till 2008, the tax revenues of the central government increased an average of 21 percent per year while expenditure rose 16 percent. Consequently, the budget deficit was down to 2.5 percent in 2007-08. The average deficit was 3.3 percent when growth was 9.5 percent.

But growth faltered in subsequent years and the deficit jumped once again. Last year, GDP growth was 7 percent and industrial growth lower at 2.9 percent. Naturally, the corporate sector failed to generate adequate revenue for the government from taxation. In the last four years, tax revenues dropped from 11.9 to 10.2 percent of GDP.

The finance minister is only too aware of the need to foster growth. Apart from initiating reforms to attract FDI, he has been prodding the ministries to expeditiously clear projects and the Reserve Bank of India to reduce the interest rate.

There appears to be a bounce in the economy. But it takes time for growth to pick up. There is little chance that it will be high enough to generate revenues enough to reduce deficit significantly. A visible change is only possible only in 2013-14.

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

This is Simple house hold maths. That’s Why many Muslims believe and pray that ‘ Allha ! Kharcha Badha ” i.e. God Increase my Expenses! So I shall need to earn more and My income will Increase. Possibly, that is why poverty in Muslim Population is high. Sadly, Dr Singh followed this tweet and advisers like Dr Basu justified that Inflation is Good. This inflationary policies have put Indian Growth Cart into the sticky mess of Stagflation. Indian government stimulated economy with Slogan of ‘ Inclusive Growth’ raised MSP for Farm products every season, thereafter NAREGA scheme saw major distribution and raising of rural income from time and again. This ever raising intravenous injection of inflation and stimulated growth path has now put Indian currency and growth engine into peril. The bloated and leveraged oversized economy is on ever search of new legs to carry. The falling currency, FII money, foreign money is now falling short.
As World economy de-leverage miscarriage of Lucky Indian Growth story slowly mowing down.
But, its only 2 days ago Indian government raised wages and MSP’s of Farm Prices

Posted by androtul | Report as abusive