Romanticising the rebels

June 7, 2010

Everybody loves a good yarn about the little guys taking on the establishment despite the odds.

And Booker Prize-winning writer and self-styled activist Arundhati Roy believes there is romanticism in the armed struggle of the Maoists against the state.

Roy, who has spent some time with Maoist groups, has slammed the government’s policy toward the Maoists, who have been accused of targeting civilians in several recent incidents including a train derailment that killed more than 100 people and appears to be denting support amongst the intelligentsia for the rebels.

Roy, speaking recently in Mumbai, said while she does not condone the killing of civilians, she was on the side of the resistance, which in India comprises an entire gamut of movements of which the Maoists are the most militant.

Roy, wearing a crisp cotton saree, flowers in her salt-and-pepper hair and black-framed spectacles that give her the appearance of a stern school teacher rather than an award-winning writer, has been criticised for her stand, accused of romanticising a deadly issue.

She retorts that she is a romantic, that she believes in the romance of poor, little people standing up to the mighty state.

Writers, poets, artists and filmmakers pride themselves on their ability to approach issues differently, not just with cold logic and reasoning, but also creativity and sympathy.

But is this just about tiny Davids taking on mighty Goliaths? Is it as straightforward as Bush’s proclamation: “You are either with us or against us”?

With the government refusing to back down from its stance that the Maoists must lay down arms before any talks, and the Maoists showing no signs of relenting despite the threat of the use of the military, there are more questions and no easy answers.

Sadly, wars have not ended because of a stirring poem or heartfelt essay. No matter how romantic the notion.

No comments so far

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

[…] the government of the day and its Operation Green Hunt, she is the only one whose protests have a negative tone – protesting for the sake of protest rather than to mitigate the suffering of either the common man […]

Posted by Arundhati Roy: Aspiring to be the Goddess of Big Things « India Security Monitor | Report as abusive