Where has India’s hawkish stance on China gone?

January 15, 2011

India’s complex diplomacy with China became further muddled on Friday as the chief of the Indian army categorically denied any troop build-up on either side of the Asian giants’ shared border in response to recent reports of Chinese military incursions into Indian territory.

India’s civil government and army officials strike a delicate balancing act in their position on the country’s powerful neighbour, with a hawkish military stance traditionally tempered by more reserved – but domestically unpopular – rhetoric from New Delhi.

A soldier of the Indian army stands guard in Medo village, an insurgency affected area, on the road to India-China border in the northeastern state of Arunachal Pradesh September 6, 2007. Picture taken September 6, 2007. REUTERS/Parth Sanyal

However that appeared to be out of date on Friday as General V.K. Singh, Chief of Army staff said neither side was bolstering its border troops, four days after trashing media reports of potential acts of Chinese aggression on Indian soil last September.

“Force deployment on both the sides of the Sino-Indian border has not increased. The force deployment is exactly the same as has been there for a large number of years,” Singh told reporters.

“In this region, the Chinese patrols go up to their perceived region and our patrols go up to our perceived region.”

“When our patrols go to our perceived region, you do not report because they are our patrols. But, when their patrols come, you report that an incursion or transgression has taken place,” he added.

Almost 40 years after a war between the two countries, the economic rivals remain suspicious of each other’s diplomatic and militaristic intentions, especially as Beijing and New Delhi pursue programs of rapid military improvement.

Border issues, including the India territories of Arunachal Pradesh, which China claims, and Jammu and Kashmir, which Chinese ally Pakistan claims, are one of the biggest sticking points in Sino-Indian relations, and India appears keen to avoid direct confrontation.

The media reports emerged over 3 months after the alleged incursions took place, attracted the complete attention of a fiercely nationalistic media, but have been dismissed out of hand by both the civilian government and the Army.

Has the Indian media been earmarked by New Delhi to be the hawkish player in the complicated game of Indo-Chinese geopolitics?


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

The UPA Government’s willingness to avoid confrontation with China over the border regions extends even to violating long-recognized provisions of international humanitarian law that require all governments to return the remains of war dead to their home countries. Indian BJP opposition leader Sushma Swaraj is reported by several major Indian publications to have said, after meeting with President Obama, that the US canceled joint US-Indian exercises in Arunachal Pradesh to placate the Chinese. It is highly likely that these canceled exercises were the recovery operations planned to recover the remains of my uncle and the rest of the crew of the American World War II aircraft “Hot as Hell”, found by American Clayton Kuhles and Indian Oken Tayeng in 2006. The Obama Administration should be ashamed of this act of kowtowing to Chinese intimidation. If the UPA coalition had any part in persuading the Obama Administration to make this cowardly decision, which also seems likely, then Mrs. Sonia Gandhi and her government share in this shame. Thanks go to Ms. Swaraj and the BJP for bringing these embarrassing facts to light.

Gary Zaetz
Nephew of USAAF 1st Lt. Irwin Zaetz, missing in action in Arunachal Pradesh since January 1944
Project Homecoming

Posted by GaryZaetz | Report as abusive

indian politicians&generals r just scared of china. U just cant medle with chinese. Remember 1962 they justwalked through indian deffences only due to American interference they stoped. Atleast by then Indian Sychophant Generals & Politicians should have made some long term strategy to takle china!! But no we r focused only towords Pak its easy to bully a weak enemy now that also is over,Pak holding nuke i one hand already the fuse is lit & nation is on a suside mission. Stop promoting boot licking generals.Promote real generals who speak truth. Who will buy real weapons without comission.Who will modernise the deffence. Practically India stands no chance at all infront of chinese forces its a NAKED TRUTH.

Posted by rajanravi | Report as abusive

Indians only know how to bark and never to bite. Congress govt (read Sonia Gandhi) would not hesitate to even sell the nation and amass the income in her swiss accounts. As Indians we need to throw these fools out of parliament.

Posted by 007XXX | Report as abusive

India may think China has forgotten the issue due to extending the hand of friendship to India and in turn swiftly took the hand and kissed it not knowing that the claws of the dragon is more dangerous than the cyanide poison.

Why because during the recent visit of the china’s President Hu Jintao made it clear to the American that China would request US not to interfere with the internal affairs of China as China considers Twain and Tibet as their internal affairs. This is enough to drive China’s point home that It will retaliate if any one interfere in China’s internal affairs and that also drives home the point directing to India Thus asking US and India both to keep off from it

After US visit of the China’s President when he is back home, things will take shape with Tibet and India and later with Twain. It seems India’s defense pacts with countries may end up in fiasco. It is becoming clear that India sooner or later is going for a big high jump and when it returns to earth its shape and size may have to be redrawn afresh.

It is because of these new developments India may be is in deep tension and thinking hard as what can be done to confront. It is supremacy over Pakistan seems to be taking a dive down to earth.

In addition it is reported that the eastern states and the countries are all anti-INDIA even yesterdays friendly people of Bangladesh is fast turning anti-India today, because of its border Atrocities. BSF killing Bangladeshi’s like birds, and the government is mum to protests by opposition of the country.

In the west is Pakistan, needs no elaboration, so no neighbor to help. This is what happens when people think it can walk alone in this world of uncertainty.

We well wishers of the west pray for India to learn to walk with friends instead of making enemies. It is known that out side enemies can be taken care of but home borne enemies are more ferocious and catastrophic in all respect. Now India is amidst the most ferocious and catastrophic self-created enemies. Only God alone can help it.

Think after having gone through the above why ‘India’s hawkish stance on China is gone with the wind?’

Posted by KINGFISHER | Report as abusive