Civil society points finger at PM in 2G scandal

June 24, 2011

By Annie Banerji

He can run, but he definitely cannot hide. The Central Information Commission (CIC) has ordered the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) to release information regarding correspondence between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and former telecom minister A Raja related to the 2G spectrum allocation scandal, which caused a loss of up to $39 billion to the national exchequer, in response to an applicant under the Right to Information (RTI) Act.

The prime minister has seen his popularity slump since he first came to power in 2004 with a downpour of high-profile corruption scandals, paralysed policymaking and a slow paced economy due to high inflation and interest rates. He finds himself under the scrutiny of not only opposition parties, but also civil society.

A civil society movement against corruption headed by popular Gandhian social activist Anna Hazare received nationwide support in April proving to the government that the masses do not treat corruption with nonchalance.

Now, the government is trying to avoid a repeat of April’s anti-graft protests by talking to a panel of civil society activists, including Hazare, who had forced it to fast-track a decades-old proposition for an independent ombudsman to investigate graft cases in high places. But the negotiations have seen divergent views emerge over the contents of the legislation, most importantly whether the prime minister should be investigated by the ombudsman.

Keeping this in view, the prime minister’s address to electronic media editors in February regarding his exchanges with A. Raja, the prime accused in the 2G scandal, comes to light.  With no threat of an authoritative body to investigate his suspected role in the spectrum situation, Manmohan Singh had timidly refuted all claims of being in the wrong of matters.

“Who got the licences… how first-come-first-served was implemented…this was never discussed with me nor was it brought to the Cabinet. This was exclusively telecom minister’s decision,” he was quoted as saying in the interaction with the editors.

It is a wonder how the prime minister has managed to disappear on the investigative radar with these assertions when Raja had specifically claimed he had received clearance from the PMO before the allocation of the 2G spectrum. Moreover, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) had told the special court that it had found evidence of “forgery” in changing of the first-come-first-serve policy to favour some companies to obtain 2G spectrum during A. Raja’s tenure.

It appears that the prime minister will have to dip his toes in icy water now that the CIC has laid the RTI applicant’s queries before the PMO and ordered it to make the documents public before July 10, an appeal the applicant claims that the PMO had denied before.

However, the question remains whether the government will wield its power and dodge this case as well since it is entitled to appeal in the Delhi High Court against the CIC order and seek a stay.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Unfortunately, the government has already wielded its power & dodged the case.Day by day, the CBI(controlled by the government in our flawed democratic system), is giving a clean chit to most of the beneficiaries in the 2g spectrum allocation.
Out of all the players, only Unitech & Swan, being the smaller sized & relatively newer players in this field have been charge sheeted. The government has made scapegoats of these 2 & is now keen to wrap up the investigations.See for more details.
The 3rd chargesheet will show what the intentions of the government are, which I fear are simply to prove to the country that they have dealt with the guilty in the 2g case & frame Unitech & Swan totally in the case, while giving the bigger & powerful players a clean chit (Tatas, Ruias, Ambanis, Birlas)!Whereas they are as much involved.

Posted by 2gscam-co-in | Report as abusive

As long as we don’t know how to elect good people to govern us no body can save us, No law or bills like Lokpal bill or RTI bill will help us. As any thing implemented is governed by people who matters.

We cannot expect a better Prime Minister when his working environment is managed by the right or wrong people elected by us.

Posted by ssnraju | Report as abusive