India Insight

Are Indian institutes casting a negative light on minority groups?

By Reuters Staff
June 30, 2011

By Annie Banerji

Just when you thought the reputation of India’s higher education sector couldn’t get worse, two recent developments regarding scheduled castes and scheduled tribes (SC/ST) cast doubt on the approach of a few of New Delhi’s academic institutions.

In one case, two Delhi University officials have been arrested for supplying fake caste/tribe certificates to students for admission to colleges. In another case, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Delhi, a branch of one of the most prestigious engineering and technology oriented institutes of higher education in India, has proposed to dish out “etiquette lessons” for its freshman SC/ST students.

The arrest of two permanent employees of Delhi University’s Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) cell came after a 26-year-old man allegedly managed to secure admissions for a dozen students in eight colleges this admission season.

His “educational consultancy firm” guaranteed admission to renowned colleges in the university by providing forged caste certificates for which he charged exorbitant amounts.

Delhi University reserves 22.5 percent seats for candidates who belong to the SC/ST category, recognised as minority groups by the Constitution of India. This reserved provision allows the relaxation of 5 percent on the minimum required qualifying marks.

In another embarrassing development, IIT Delhi, which eases 10 percent in the admission criteria for SC/ST category students, has devised a ‘self-enrichment programme’ for its SC/ST freshman batch, a move that suggests a distinction between two sets of students on the sole basis of caste.

“A campus is a symbol of assimilation of many minds and several lives. To carve out a group on the basis of their origins and put them through a training programme — I would term it nothing short of apartheid,” a faculty member of the institute was quoted as saying.

Conversely, the IIT Delhi director told an English daily that the notice was worded inaptly. “There is something amiss in the notice. The classes are meant for all students from rural backgrounds – and not just for SC/ST students – and were conducted last year too,” Surendra Prasad clarified.

These fiascos have not only helped in tainting the reputation of these premier academies, but have also placed scheduled castes and scheduled tribes on the line for no fault of their own.

The reserved seats in higher education are gibed by many general category aspirants as they feel they miss out on opportunities because of these conditions. Such instances may have widened a chasm that has always been sensitive to begin with.

Comments
3 comments so far | RSS Comments RSS

What bullsh*t this is….u r ready to get benefits for caste and at the time of getting admission u dont say ohhh “i am being distinguished on basis of caste” and when IIT says lets bring these chaps at par with others and lets have programme for that at NO extra cost then SC/ST people scrib about it. What rubbish this is…

Posted by 007XXX | Report as abusive
 

If quotas keep cut offs high and the number of seats in Open category get reduced to just 10-12% (visit – http://tinyurl.com/69j7tvc) , there will be people who will want to break the rules and forge caste certificates. Yes, what they did is wrong but would you blame them fully for doing that? Why blame IIT which is trying to help students catch up in name of distinction between students when it begins very early in everyone’s life and they are getting advantage over many others for no fault of theirs.

Posted by vbhatt | Report as abusive
 

Quota has not made a difference in 60+ years. It is widely misused.
Unless quota is reduced progressively it is unjustified.
Quota is meaningless if we cannot provide equal sholl education for all.
India is a starnge country indeed. We read in the news that most families spend a lot on education, even more than food. We have RTE because a lot of yougsters do not get education. Government is able to spend a lot on almost all other items but not education.

Posted by NoBorder | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •