Electronic waste rules: In letter, but without spirit

May 17, 2012

Ever wondered what happens to your old mobile phones, computers, television sets and refrigerators the moment you discard them? They are most likely to land in an unauthorised scrap yard waiting to be recycled in a hazardous and unscientific manner — causing great damage to the environment. The rapid growth of the information technology sector in India has only contributed to this problem of accumulating e-waste or electronic waste.

The government finally woke up to this growing problem a couple of years ago when studies by its information technology department estimated the e-waste burden on the country to touch 800,000 metric tonnes by December. It responded by framing the e-waste (management and handling) rules – 2011 which came into effect this month. While the rules seem impressive on paper, environmental groups have expressed concerns about its ability to bring about change due to the sheer oversight of the ground situation.

To begin with, the rules put India along with a select club of nations like the United States and many in Europe to have legislation to regulate and manage electronic waste. Not just that, the rules also propose several ambitious measures to regulate waste.

For instance, according to government data, close to 95 percent of all the electronic waste is currently recycled by the unauthorised sector — scrap dealers. They usually resort to recycling methods that cause great damage to environment and human health, according to various studies conducted by environmental agencies including the Central Pollution Control Board. Printed circuit boards and electronic parts are usually immersed in chemical solutions or burnt to extract small amounts of metals.

The newly framed rules aim to change this situation by entrusting the responsibility of collection and safe disposal of waste with the manufacturers of electronic goods. It mandates manufacturers to collect electronic scrap directly from consumers and route them to authorised recycling centres across the country. The rules also try to address other issues such as restricting the usage of hazardous substances such as lead, cadmium, mercury, PCB, PVR and BFR in electronics.

But all these promising measures in the paper seem far from changing the ground scenario. Here is why.

The environment ministry proposed the electronic waste rules about a year ago, providing companies and other groups affected by the rules enough time to put systems in place for effective compliance before they come into effect this month.

If observations made by environmental NGOs are anything to go by, efforts over the past year to improve disposal mechanisms have been negligible. For instance, information on electronic scrap collection centres for consumers has not been made available in many major cities.

The rules also do not mention the number of collection points, number of authorised recyclers required in cities or the amount of waste to be collected and disposed. Environmentalists believe that this might result in manufacturers setting up a few symbolic collection centres across the country which might not be able to deal with the quantity of waste produced.

For instance, the second largest electronic waste-producing state in the country — Tamil Nadu (responsible for 13 percent of the total waste produced in India) — has only one recycler for the entire state. Other states face similar problems.

Even if the manufacturers and policymakers decide to open more collection centres, bigger problems remain, including persuading people to deliver their old computers and other products to collection centres instead of going to scrap dealers.

But when the local dealer pays handsomely for the scrap, it is doubtful that many would choose to return the waste to the manufacturer for free. Ever since the rules were being made, environmentalists have been negotiating with the government to provide some incentive to people who use electronics so they volunteer to turn in their devices to the companies to get them recycled. But this has not featured in the rules.

Furthermore, according to the study by the Department of Information Technology, there are more than 3,000 scrap dealers across the country. Unless these scrap dealers are given a chance to participate in an authorised recycling system, they will only fight harder to stay in business.

The rules are also completely oblivious to the electronic waste that is imported into the country. A study by the Centre for Science and Environment estimates that close to 50,000 metric tonnes of electronic scrap is imported into the country every year. But the rules have no provisions to control imports.

Though the trans-boundary movement of hazardous waste is banned under an international treaty called the Basel Convention, dealers sneak in consignments of electronic scrap as they are not properly classified. According to environmental activists, most electronic scrap that comes into the country is classified as plastic scrap or mixed waste.

The biggest impediment of all for safely disposing electronics products is India’s record of municipal waste management. Twelve years after the municipal solid waste rules were framed, major metro cities like Chennai have not even got the basics right in terms of segregating waste at source and preventing the environmentally harmful burning of waste. With a track record like that, and the number of Indians using computers and mobile devices only rising, there seems to be little hope that rules will succeed in the marketplace.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Framing the rule might have been honest attempt to be in the ‘select club of countries’ but that a waste of time, leave about the ‘waste’ (topic) which is under discussion of this article.

As a nation and living healthy society, a waste management system is needed. Only time will compel us to have a better e-waste management like to one which is there was normal-waste management. An intellectual and educated society can expedite its framing and smooth implementation, which India lacks at this point of time – may blame it on election gaga, political wins, name-sack frame it, priorities elsewhere, society unaware of grave dangers (like plastic waste), importance to electronic developmental rather to include e-waste management, and also to say fruitful business opportunities with clarify on most operational issues.

Need of the hour, be it for beginning, will be
a. clarity on rules / policy, with actionable procedures – who, when, what, why, how, etc. and also required penalty clauses.
b. engage all stakeholders starting with education and ending with deterrent actions for users as well as the products – like information being published in various media, preparing all vendors / suppliers / producers of electronic to have implement the collection and recycle policy.
c. Including current stakeholders of e-waste framework like scrap dealers, petty waste collector, etc. so they are encouraged to adhere the new e-waste management system.
d. regularly review the progress of policy implementation as well as amount of waste collection from producers / vendors and making those available to general public through websites.
e. finally crystallizing the progress into smart reports and progress summary, so as to evaluate cost-benefit of the system.

I like it can be done; only essence of time and urgency will take it forward.

Posted by ManishShukla | Report as abusive

It is important to make a point here that even the Water Act,1974 and Air Act,1981 are still not implemented properly at the grass root level in India…leave alone the rules under the EPA,1986(Municipal Solid Waste rules,Bio Medical Waste Rules,plastic rules,battery rules etc…) and now comes the e-waste rules…until there is proper implementation of the earlier said rules be there by the SPCBs…there wouldn’t be much change….

Posted by rsingla003 | Report as abusive

But the powers ruling India virtually have no time for this problem, as they mostly remain busy in safeguarding their ruling position in the present era of alliance politics in the country … !

Posted by Zirakpuria | Report as abusive

Can’t believe! The rubbish piled into a heap once was a fast-selling computer shop in India.

Posted by maGiK | Report as abusive

[…] case puts Volcker Rule and SIFIs back in the spotlight Electronic waste rules: In letter, but without spirit China […]

Posted by Chinese WTO suit strikes back at U.S. duties | Try2connect News Blog | Report as abusive

[…] Electronic waste rules: In letter, but without spirit Samsung investors should worry less about Apple Stocks » M&A » Markets » Cyclical Consumer Goods » Industrials » Technology » […]

Posted by UPDATE 1-Renesas aims to sell chip plant, shed 12,000 jobs -source | Try2connect News Blog | Report as abusive