Mr Pranab Mukherjee, did we hear ‘austerity’?

May 21, 2012

India is going through a rough patch. The common man knows it, foreign investors know it and so does our government.

Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, who is also one of the contenders for the post of president, has been trying his best to clear the air and restore the confidence to get the economy back on track.

In his recent Parliament speech, after he delayed the controversial GAAR norms, Mukherjee said new ‘austerity measures’ will be announced to aid the fiscal consolidation process.

The government, however, still doesn’t seem to be frugal when it comes to spending.

On Monday, newspapers in New Delhi were flooded with ads, some of them full page, on the 21st death anniversary of India’s former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. Hindustan Times alone had 11 of them. The Times of India had nine while The Indian Express had eight, all paying tribute to Gandhi.

And it’s a collective effort of various ministries. From the Delhi government to the ministries of power, steel, environment, information & broadcasting, women & child development, commerce & industry — all have space reserved in national dailies to pay tribute in their own way.

Over the weekend, Mamata Banerjee, a key ally of the Congress-led government, had a centre spread in The Times of India as her government completed a year in office. The ad, titled ‘One year towards a ray of hope’ explained the recent initiatives of her state government in West Bengal.

And this is not restricted to the government. Last week, J.Jayalalithaa, whose party sits in opposition in parliament, celebrated a year in office as chief minister of Tamil Nadu with ads on the front page of many English dailies.

One wonders where the money for these ads comes from? Can it be used in a better manner? Are these ads really needed?

Several million rupees are spent on print media ads on the birth and death anniversaries of national leaders. It is tough to understand how India can afford to spend taxpayers’ money this way when there is dire need of reforms as growth languishes near 3-year lows, current account deficit rises and the rupee sinks.

When it comes to austerity, even Pratibha Patil, the President of India, has been under fire. She has been criticised for costing the public exchequer more than 2 billion rupees on her foreign trips, a record for any Indian president.

A few days after his Parliament speech, Mukherjee announced a ban on government employees buying new vehicles and imposed curbs on holding workshops/meetings by government officials at five-star hotels.

It is clear that reducing such expenses might not do much to solve India’s growing fiscal troubles. But perhaps, doing this and cutting back on needless expenditure such as advertisements in newspapers can be a good way to start.

(Follow Aditya on Twitter at @adityayk)

5 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

According to some reports, the ads by Jayalalithaa cost over 25 crore rupees(4.5 million U.S. dollars) of public money! And media did not cover that at all, because they were getting business out of it.

Posted by MashGeek | Report as abusive

add to this the fact that there is often an in your face campaign launched outdoors, which goes ballistic especially when election have been held and won. this is an all India phenomenon, even if money from private players, enthusiasts and supporters it does cost a pretty penny.

in case this money is to be channelized in other ways, a sensible way should be thought of, as the last thing needed is the same money going to buy votes or grease palms.

Posted by uncommonsense1 | Report as abusive

additionally self aggrandizement is a way of being in India, as we are SOOOOO busy awarding everyone and anyone on all our so called achievements…wonder if razzies or turkey awards can also be instituted for the useless spenders of the year category to begin with and can well be extended to include MANY such categories.

Posted by uncommonsense1 | Report as abusive

Austerity as an old saying goes, ‘starts at home’.

During my recent visit to India I have seen people using automobiles for going to as little distance as corner shops from their homes.

Mushrooming of taxis, auto-rickshaws, cars, two-wheeler on the road and the flaunting of wealth in IPL matches speak no more of India as a humble and frugal nation.

Gone are the days when everyone believed non-resident Indians were better off than resident Indians.

Posted by maGiK | Report as abusive

Average Indian practices Austerity….tht is how we have been brought up…….It is the Politicians who lack any accountability lack Austerity……….

Posted by RiskyBalaji | Report as abusive