Women and New Delhi: the views of travellers

By Reuters Staff
September 8, 2013

By Aditya Kalra and Anuja Jaiman

Assurances from the police and a new anti-rape law have done little to make the streets of New Delhi safer for women, especially for those using public transport, interviews conducted by the India Insight team show.

The India Insight team travelled in Delhi Transport Corporation (DTC) buses and Delhi Metro trains and spoke to commuters.

Here are edited excerpts from conversations:

Farhana Ahmed, 22, student; travelling in a bus
I only feel safe travelling by bus in the day time because it’s crowded and there are less chances of being in trouble. I prefer not to board a bus after five in the evening. Whenever we go out after 9 p.m., we have experienced eve-teasing. I think it’s better not to wear dresses at night.

Thoudam Regina, 30, analyst; waiting at a bus stand
In foreign countries, even if you wear shorts, nothing happens. I wear sports shoes so that (if) something happens, I could run. I never wear chappals (slippers) nowadays.

Sania Hashmi, 21, student; waiting at Munirka bus stop
I don’t think anything has changed per se. As long as we have a patriarchal society, this thing is not going to change, it’s a social problem. I don’t think there is any girl in our country at large, who hasn’t experienced molestation. My only dream is to see an India where you see gender parity.A bus stop in Munirka New Delhi. Reuters India Insight

Vaishali Sharma, executive in a real estate company; travelling in a bus
We don’t consider ourselves safe anywhere … we fear that something might happen, especially when we leave at night or after office at 7 p.m. I generally keep chilli powder in my purse. Even girls are at fault, they leave at night and dressing sense is not right.

Roopali Jawa, 26, chartered accountant; in the Delhi Metro
Nothing has improved and I don’t even think it is going to improve. My parents are worried about me, I just replied to an SMS from (my) parents who were asking if I have boarded the metro. I carry a dress in my bag if I am going to party after work. I did not do this until last year.

Mohammad Atif, 27, student; waiting at Munirka bus stop
I believe that punishment for crimes such as rapes should be so stringent that they induce fear in people. How can a juvenile rape? Rape has a direct correlation to being an adult. Law and regulations have loopholes. Mentality change will take 50-100 years … in this time how many girls will fall prey you cannot imagine. Why should girls wear proper clothes, why not boys? Boys wear whatever they want, don’t girls have feelings?

Sakshi Sharma, 28, teacher in Delhi University; in the Delhi Metro
I don’t really feel safe. Let’s say somebody is mischievous, I can’t tell him, “give me your I-card because I travel alone and what if someone follows me.” You can’t be really strict with male students. In a crowded metro compartment, given a chance, men will try to touch you. It doesn’t matter how many rape cases happen. My parents have told me, don’t take up any job in an evening college.

Sudhir, 58, villager; in the Delhi Metro
I am from a village, but I think 70 percent of the mistake is of girls. The dressing style is so dirty. Just yesterday I saw girls wearing skimpy clothes, there was one boy with them. Even boys are at fault.

Chandra Mohan, 56, government employee; travelling in a bus
Nothing has changed, instead it has become worse now. We are always worried when our daughters go out. The law and order situation is not right.

Suman, advocate; in the Delhi Metro
There has not been much change, but I know the reason. There is so much freedom to girls … dressing sense is one of the main issues. We might have many laws, but it doesn’t matter if you walk openly … I have even rebuked girls at times.  Even girls are at fault. I have not felt unsafe, but I try to reach home by 6.30 in the evening.

Devi Ram, 40, bus driver
I will not get my daughter and wife to the city from the village. Costs are higher here, safety is an issue too. There are more cases of eve-teasing here. If there is a problem in my bus, I will call on 100  and hand over to police, we will fight.

Biraj Swain, 37, economist; waiting at Munirka bus stop
I actually feel quite safe. I come from a city (in Odisha) which has no public transport and have worked in Africa which has no public transport. I think the discourse has just become too much, and too much in your face … in a way it’s a good thing, but I also feel there’s a huge amount of peer pressure to continue to stick to that narrative … There’s a lot more offering of the seat now. There are a lot more proactive steps from the conductor to get the ladies’ seat vacated.

Devender Kumar, 33, bus conductor
Women are still not safe in Delhi, law and order situation is the problem. Everyone is worried seeing the environment.

Seema Singh, 26, housewife; waiting at Munirka bus stop
I escort my daughter to school each day as I am fearful of her travelling in a school van. I am so scared. How will I bring her up, educate her … I feel like crying. Clothes also make an impact. Girls are also at fault, they don’t wear proper clothes. We ourselves feel ashamed.

Shabnam Abbasi, 26, teacher; travelling in a bus
There have been little changes after the December case. The only solution is that girls become self-dependent. I try to reach home at the earliest. The young boys do not trouble much, the problem is with the age group 30-50. They irritate us so much at times in buses that I feel like slapping them.

Deepa Pant, 36, hotelier; waiting at a bus stop
There has been some change in attitude; men are vacating the seats for ladies. People are more concerned. The solution is to educate people. Men aged above 35 cause most of the trouble.

Vineeta Sachdev, 38, government employee; waiting at a bus stop
You can change yourself, but you cannot change the mentality. Girls should avoid wearing short clothes.

MORE ON THIS STORY:

Women still feel unsafe in India’s rape capital

Timeline of events: The Delhi gang rape case

(Disclaimer: This article is website-exclusive and cannot be reproduced in any form without permission. You can follow Aditya on Twitter @adityayk and Anuja @AnujaJaiman)

6 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Did farhana really say that she wants to go out naked at nite?

Posted by AbRam. | Report as abusive

I would love to read similar stories from UK, USA and what happens . I have witnessed passes made at the girls at the bus stops . During the matches in the stadium , boys openly applaud leering and sex appeal of the girls . There are news of rape cases in the queue. At the night bars all men come around to circle a girl . How is it different .

Posted by mdbiyani | Report as abusive

Despite so much public anguish and agitations, media highlighting,ministers assuring and the police commissioner’s promising,the safety of women in Delhi has become worse,so much worse that just in front of four police pickets ,thirteen video cameras and within two kilometres of the residences of the national leaders,dacoits on a bike are able to attack a woman with sharp weapons and snatch away her ornaments,in the busiest and most monitored locality of Janpath in Connaught Place.

The police is provided with infrastructure,vehicles,computers,cctv’s  ,walkie-talkies,intelligence and informers network and trained personnel at the expense of the taxpayer but they do not care to use any of them to prevent crime or catch the criminals.It is only because the higher level officers are not monitoring the performance and not motivating the personnel to do their duty.This must be condemned as anti-social attitude of the police and they must be made to do their minimum duty at least.People are losing hope on Government and they question the need for any Government at all.

Posted by ushacpjp | Report as abusive

New Delhi is as safe for women as it is for men. Which is to say it’s safe, most of the time. More specifically, though, there is more crime here due to demographics and geography, and women are sometimes targeted due to cultural reasons. But i do not agree that makes it more unsafe for women; only different from them as far as the nature or/and methodology of the crime is concerned. Many believe, and rightly, i may add, that these particular crimes stem from a mindset problem. But it is for women to change their mindsets as much as the men: in fact, they should change their mindsets first if they are really serious about not being or becoming VICTIMS of these crimes. (Yeah, victim is a loaded word but only to this extent. Bcos here, too, often the honourable are victimized precisely on that ground. But that takes place in random or extreme circumstances.)

Posted by g_cHet | Report as abusive

There are some private cabs in Delhi which are connected with gprs and you can book using app also. There control room track this cabs movement. Drivers are also appoint after big verification due to the safety. So this cabs are only way of safe traveling in Delhi.

Posted by Suchitra01 | Report as abusive

After the success of aman 2 jp launching aman 3 at Yamuna expressway. Aman 3 offering 2/3 bhk apartments.
website url: http://jaypeeaman3noida.co.in/
youtub url http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFxODaejA CI&feature=youtu.be&noredirect=1

Posted by devlin1 | Report as abusive