Reuters Blogs

India Masala

Bollywood and culture in an emerging India

02:03 September 26th, 2008

Hari Puttar - Home Alone desi style?

Posted by: Shilpa Jamkhandikar
Tags: India Masala, , , , ,

Warner Brothers did get one thing right.

‘Hari Puttar - A Comedy of Terrors’ does have similarities to a children’s film - not ‘Harry Potter’, but ‘Home Alone’.

1280x1024_01.jpgA child alone at home, two bumbling goons out to get him and whole scenes lifted from Chris Columbus’s very popular Home Alone.

Unfortunately, neither does child actor Zain Khan come close to matching Macaulay Culkin’s infectious charm, nor does director Lucky Kohli come close to making his film as tight and watchable as ‘Home Alone’ was.

There is hardly any need to narrate the plot - it is exactly the same as ‘Home Alone’ with some minor changes.

Hari’s father is scientist who, we are told, is developing an ultra secret chip that will help the Indian Army fight terrorism (yes, don’t expect any originality from the filmmakers here.)

His mother, played by Sarika, punishes him in front of his cousins and bossy elder 1280x1024_02.jpgbrother for spilling “chicken tikka” all over the dining table. (The “chicken tikka” is pizza in the original film).

He sleeps in the attic and next morning his family forgets to take him along on a holiday. Hari is left all alone at home with his cousin Tuk Tuk for company (played by Swini Khara).

Enter two goons, who want to steal that all important chip from the house. Of course, you know how this one ends.

Kohli doesn’t even attempt to come up with new tricks in this film. Even the pranks Zain plays on the goons to stop them from entering the house are straight lifts from HA.

Maybe I am harping a bit too much on the similarities between the two films, but that is because they are so obvious. And the worst part is, even with such a good source of inspiration Hari Puttar doesn’t turn out to be half as entertaining as it should be.1280x1024_05.jpg

None of the performances are up to the mark, the pranks all look contrived and there is hardly any sense that this film is actually going somewhere.

1280x1024_04.jpgAnother problem I had was that for a kid’s film, there are some pretty non kiddie moments.

Like the scene where Vijay Raaz and Saurabh Shukla (the two goons) indulge in a long round of swearing at each other (all beeped out, of course). Or the one where Tuk Tuk puckers up before Hari, saying kissing is no big deal.

As I left the theatre, the overwhelming feeling was that of embarrassment - not for the fact that Bollywood can’t stop aping the west, but because we cant even do that with some panache!

7 comments so far

Well a large number of Indian movies copy or rather plagiarize the entire western movie or parts of it.

Some times it make me wonder how famous actors end up acting in movies like these. Maybe they don’t have time to watch western movies but at least they should have capable managers.

One of the worst was Kyon ki Main Jhoot Nahin Bolta by Govinda. He tried to imitate Jim Carry. It was sick.

- Posted by Imtiaz

i think it will be better if you could post your reviews on Sundays.

- Posted by Swarup

“As I left the theatre, the overwhelming feeling was that of embarrassment”
Aren’t you ashamed to go for such movies and then blog about it here that you were embarrassed… in real time…

What else did u expect to happen?

- Posted by arun

I can’t believe I spent INR 800 on this movie. I took my kids to this movie last night and was disgusted. I can’t believe Bollywood can’t even copy a Holywood movie.

Hari Puttar is worse than any average Hindi movie. Even my kids did not like the movie. Allowing a kids movie to have a ton of bleeps ??????? What was the censor board doing !!!!!!!

- Posted by SP

good, the reviews and comments saved me some money but is always better not to read a review for those movies we are really waiting for.

- Posted by Sofi

A sad state of affairs for Indian Cinema!!

http://vikramsjourney.blogspot.com/

- Posted by VN

That is one reason why I stopped watching bollywood two years ago.I now go straight for Western movies.

- Posted by Naiyer

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.