Paathshala: Punished for three hours

April 16, 2010

paathshaalaIf any real-life kids went to the school shown in Milind Ukey’s “Paathshaala”, you can be sure they would hardly get any studying done. Instead they would be busy dancing, singing, ogling at teachers, romancing and participating in reality TV shows.

The teachers in this school aren’t any better — they also sing, dance, wear inappropriate clothes and generally do everything but the things you are expected to do in a school.

Director Ukey may have wanted to make a film on the ills of the education system (like “3 Idiots”, “Taare Zameen Par”) but instead manages to make a manual on “how not to make a film”.

“Paathshaala” starts off with the principal of a boarding school, Aditya Sahai (Nana Patekar), calling his staff and telling them the school would be undergoing some changes in order to “progress”.

These changes include the students giving up studies and participating in reality TV shows so that the school gets publicity (Yes, really).

They also involve the kids being made to participate in auditions for TV ads and cruel directors who want the kids to get hurt and cry so that they will get higher TRPs. Where do they come up with such things?

As you can imagine, “Paathshaala” is an incoherent mess of a film which takes a serious issue and manages to run it to the ground.

Why someone like Shahid Kapur would want to do a film like this is beyond me — of course, he doesn’t have that much to do, except smile and strum the guitar.

There is no script to speak of, the dialogues are so bad they are good (“these kids maybe the best players but they are not the best payers”, says one character) and the actors all appear to want to run ten miles away from the set.

I would recommend the same, run ten miles away from any place showing this film.

2 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

“run ten miles away from any place showing this film”… lolz, poor Shahid Kapoor, brace-up for another flop..

Posted by Nauman | Report as abusive

I haven’t watched the film but if Shilpa has written so then I would appreciate the total outcome of the film-”Paathshala”. I mean why we all study?? to earn our livelihoods in a better way so what if the Principal of such school is preparing children from the beginning and the aspiring truth about Indian Studies in general is you mug up all and puke some in the Exam-Hall. Remember some and forget all. Look around and you will find MBA’s everywhere but what they do? MNC’s in the name of aspiring career give them targets, HR guys has the target of recruitment/finding right guys/interviews besides daily routine operations within, Finance guys are now not left as they are part of Global Marketing Department and not much difference has been left between Sales & Marketing and Finance guys. Journalists- scoop, scoop, scoop and more scoop….
So, its all about boasting yourselves, be a part of recognizable society, being in the news, being one of the known personality.

So you have to decide whether to be like me commenting some blogs or “Shilpa Jamkhandikar”- a journalist writing some Masala Blogs or “Shahid Kapur”- hearthrob of India. No Offense Shilpa

Posted by sumit.wadhwa | Report as abusive