Reuters Blogs

India Masala

Bollywood and culture in an emerging India

October 25th, 2008

Roadside Romeo — Doggy tale gone wrong

Posted by: Shilpa Jamkhandikar

When you find the villain of the film more endearing than the hero and even 90 minutes seem like a lifetime, there has to be something wrong with the film. 

That’s right. Charlie Anna, the heavy, farting and bespectacled bulldog with a south Indian accent, who throws a spanner in Romeo’s plans, is way more entertaining and funny than the protagonist of Roadside Romeo

Romeo, the actual hero, comes across as a somewhat cowardly, smooth-talking snob. And the Jugal Hansraj-directed Walt Disney co-produced “Roadside Romeo” seems like an incredibly long, boring film merely because the script is quite shoddy.

In fact, I felt everyone associated with the film sat down one day, decided they were going to make an animation film about a dog, realised at the last minute they actually needed a script, and threw together the most clichéd plot line, hoping this would be masked by some good animation.

Ultimately though, a good film is about a good story, even if it is a simple one. The film starts off with Romeo (voiced by Saif Ali Khan), a pampered dog, being forced to live on the streets because the people he belonged to go abroad.

Unused to the ways of the real world, he is flustered at first, but soon finds friends in the form of Interval, Mini, Guru and Hero English, a group of strays who take him into their fold. Romeo teaches them to be “cool”, gives them haircuts and they all start a doggy salon together. Romeo even falls in love, with the mysterious Laila (Kareena Kapoor).

Enter Charlie Anna, the neighbourhood goonda, who has his sights set on Laila. Romeo, in a somewhat cowardly attempt to save his skin, promises Charlie Anna he will convince Laila to be his “girlfriend”, all the while romancing her on his own. 

Laila finds out, pouts, and dumps Romeo. Charlie Anna finds out too, and come baying for Romeo’s blood. At this point, you are supposed to feel sympathetic. I just felt that Romeo kind of had this coming.

I wasn’t hoping for a “Ratatouille” or a “WALL-E”, but I wasn’t expecting a half-baked Bollywood film either. This was supposed to be Walt Disney’s entry into India. Yes, the animation is good. Not world class, but good enough. But whatever happened to the good old story?

Animation films have a children’s audience in mind, and the plot shouldn’t be too complicated. But who said simple couldn’t mean good? This plot is filled with characters mouthing old Yashraj film dialogues, item numbers, and even a full-on kissing scene, all of which I am not sure are entirely appropriate for kids.

Of the performances, Jaaved Jaafrey as Charlie Anna is undoubtedly superb, bringing little nuances to the role that make you laugh out loud. Tanaaz Currim as Mini is also very effective, but the real standout performance for me was Chainoo, Charlie Anna’s scruffy sidekick, voiced brilliantly by Sanjay Mishra.

Saif Ali Khan is staid and a little boring as Romeo, while Kareena Kapoor hardly has any lines as Laila. 

In the end, I was disappointed in the film, merely because with the skill and resources at hand, there could have been a much better product on display.

 

September 12th, 2008

The Last Lear: Not Bachchan’s best but watch it for the performances

Posted by: Shilpa Jamkhandikar

There has been so much controversy about the release of “The Last Lear” that it’s easy to overlook this is a film that has been well received in the international festival circuit, has some of India’s best known actors and has even been touted as Amitabh Bachchan’s finest work yet.

Honestly, I don’t agree with that last statement — but then people are entitled to their own opinion.

Amitabh BachchanUndoubtedly, Bachchan plays the role of Harish Mishra, an ageing but passionate Shakespearean actor to the T, with dexterity and skill.

But this is not his best. In fact, I would even say his is not the best performance in the film.

But I am getting ahead of myself. “The Last Lear” is a film in a film and it starts off the way most movies do. With a premiere. It’s Diwali night and also the premiere of Siddharth’s (Arjun Rampal) first film.

The mood though is anything but celebratory. The film’s lead actor is seriously ill and actress Shabnam (Preity Zinta) decides to visit him rather than attend the premiere. Even Siddharth is not as happy as a director making his debut should be.

Film maker Rituparno Ghosh tells the whole story in flashback, interspersed with the events of the night. We learn that Siddharth, a young, enthusiastic director convinces ageing theatre actor Mishra to play a role in his film about an out of work circus clown. Mishra agrees and the entire film unit moves to a hill station for the shoot.

Actress Shabnam, who feels trapped in her marriage, is also part of the cast. The story of how Mishra gets hurt during the shooting is revealed almost at the end and so is the interplay of relationships. To reveal any more would be to spoil the plot.

Ghosh explores the ruthlessness of an artist when it comes to perfecting his art through Siddharth, played brilliantly by Arjun Rampal. Zinta, playing an actress who deals with her own demons is also wonderful, especially in her scenes with Shefali Shah and Divya Dutta.

Which brings us to Shefali Shah. Hers is easily the most power-packed and passionate performance in the film. Her character and her relationship with Mishra is not revealed till the end. Yet, instead of treating this as a handicap, Shah uses it to the best of her ability.

Divya Dutta as the nurse is also good. The scenes in which the three women discuss their lives, matter of factly, yet with so much underlying pain are some of the most powerful in the film.

The pace is quite good and the flashback scenes don’t hinder the film much. Again, this is not a film for everyone, but if your movie palate can handle a different cuisine, go watch “The Last Lear” — if not for anything else, the performances.