James Pethokoukis

Politics and policy from inside Washington

The House GOP ‘Pledge to America’

September 23, 2010

Here is my Reuters Breakingviews columntorial (half column, half editorial)  on the agenda from House Republicans:

America’s so-called “party of no” has finally revealed what it will say “yes” to. Yet a new Republican manifesto offers little more than undoing President Barack Obama’s reforms to date, with vague talk of balanced budgets. Maybe that’s smart politics. But it’s a missed opportunity.

If you’re winning late in the game, it is reckless to pull the goalie and put him on the attack. So with congressional midterm elections just weeks away and polls going the Republicans’ way, the cautious nature of the ideas in the 21-page document from the party’s House leaders is perhaps unsurprising. As the saying goes, if you want to do policy, you have to first do politics. And the main objective of the GOP’s “Pledge to America” is to counter Democratic claims that Republicans are mere obstructionists.

The document does contain a smattering of worthwhile items, particularly on restraining government spending. Republicans want to cut non-defense spending, excluding mandatory social insurance spending, to where it was in 2008. That would save about $100 billion a year. Over ten years, adjusted for inflation, that would only knock off 10 percent or so from the $9.8 trillion in additional debt the United States will accumulate over that period, by Congressional Budget Office estimates. But it’s a start, as is the idea of hard caps on discretionary spending, though specifics are unfortunately lacking. And freezing the hiring of new federal workers would set a good austerity example for state and local governments.

But it’s difficult to take seriously any policy agenda that doesn’t lay out at least a broad plan for much deeper fiscal reform. Paul Ryan, the Republican who would head the House budget committee if the GOP retakes the lower chamber, has a detailed roadmap for restructuring entitlements. But party leaders chose to ignore it. And it’s odd that Republican leaders seem to want to extend all the Bush-era tax cuts even if it means keeping in place a clunky code than penalizes savings and rewards debt.

Sure, the Republicans don’t want to give Democrats fodder for negative advertising. But this manifesto could have begun making the public case for the GOP’s vision of the big budgetary changes America needs. That didn’t happen. America’s long-term economic and fiscal woes call for bolder leadership.

Comments

You are expecting too much from a leaderless congressional minority. A truly positive agenda for America will emerge in 2011-2012 as Republicans jockey for leadership in the Presidential race. Which party will take the necessary steps to get America back on track? The electorate is repudiating the Democrats. It is too soon for the Republicans to address long range issues except in a speculative and individual way. Once the Republicans have demonstrated their worthiness to lead the country through this recession, they can make a play to lead us through the impending entitlements crisis.

Posted by cwillia11 | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •