The latest on states declaring bankruptcy

January 27, 2011

Some Republicans are against the idea, but a couple of heavy hitters — Jeb Bush and Newt Gingrich — continue to be for it. Here is a bit from their LA Times op-ed:

First, as with municipal bankruptcy, it would have to be completely voluntary.

Second, as with municipal bankruptcy, a new bankruptcy law would allow states in default or in danger of default to reorganize their finances free from their union contractual obligations. In such a reorganization, a state could propose to terminate some, all or none of its government employee union contracts and establish new compensation rates, work rules, etc.

Third, the new law should allow for the restructuring of a state’s debt and other contractual obligations.

When California refused to bail out Orange County, the county entered bankruptcy and emerged within 18 months. Within three years, the county returned to an investment grade rating, and it repaid 100% of the principal of the vast majority of its investors by 2000 without raising taxes.

Fourth, the federal judge reviewing the state’s reorganization plan would have the power only to accept the plan as permissible under the federal bankruptcy law, or reject it as inconsistent with that law.

Fifth, the new law should provide for triggering mechanisms to initiate the bankruptcy process that respect the sovereignty of the people of a state.

An additional benefit of a new voluntary bankruptcy law for states is that its mere existence may deter any state from ever availing itself of its provisions. If government employee union bosses know that they could have all their contracts annulled under federal bankruptcy law, either through a plan of reorganization voluntarily entered into by state leaders or by the voters through proposition, they may be far more accommodating with state governments to restructure government employee union workforces, pensions and work rules.

Also, Moody’s has begun to take a closer look at state pension obligations, creating new metrics that combine debt and pension liabilities:

statesmoodys

5 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

It is hard to understand what bankruptcy would accomplish. The states are sovereign. They can abolish public sector unions and nullify contracts. They can default on their bonds. The only recourse would be the states’ courts and the jurisdiction of the courts is a matter of state law or the constitution. Conversely, how could a state legislature or governor get a bankruptcy court to agree to a restructuring that violates a state’s constitution.

Posted by cwillia11 | Report as abusive

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by DS Standard, The Survival Wire. The Survival Wire said: http://ow.ly/3LTqL OH BOY, Here it comes now! [...]

‘An additional benefit of a new voluntary bankruptcy law for states is that its mere existence may deter any state from ever availing itself of its provisions.’

Precisely. After reading much of Mr. P’s writings on the subject and Felix Salmon’s shocked rejoinders, it occurred to me that this proposed state bankruptcy legislation would likely NEVER be used, much like nuclear weapons during the cold war. Their mere existence was enough to keep the other side in check or, in this case, keeping rapacious public sector union bosses and their followers from looting the state treasury.

Posted by Gotthardbahn | Report as abusive

The latest on states declaring bankruptcy | Analysis & Opinion |…

Here at World Spinner we are debating the same thing……

[...] rest is here: The latest on states declaring bankruptcy | Analysis & Opinion | Comments [...]

I’m very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc.

Battle required similar to 8 hours and she or he brought about many of them. Consequently your girlfriend push hit a brick wall and she or he simply had to go to nearly every creek to fight more normal water. Your sweetheart didn succeed, however , your sweetheart produced daylights of your showing. Throughout sleep of which night time, Odn seen that an analogous approach could be helpful to create small children caught up in the tummy all through childbirth. It is really not obvious out of the post how come Odn ended up being pondering troublesome births, however , they sought the reasoning with the support involving his lady as well as obstetrician. Skip forward so that you can at present, and also a polished type of the look ready designed for really serious observations..

7 louis vuitton outlet EcU Louis Vuitton Bags TyS Louis Vuitton Handbags BiX Louis Vuitton Outlet TwU Louis Vuitton Bags EuX Louis Vuitton Handbags WdE Louis Vuitton Neverfull GfS Louis Vuitton Outlet DkB Michael Kors Outlet Xio Michael Kors Outlet BtB Michael Kors Hamiton XqE Michael Kors Handbags ElE Michael Kors Sale TqS Coach Factory Outlet ByX Coach USA Eto Coach Factory Outlet DiB Coach Factory Outlet Online RlX Coach Factory Outlet Online Eyo White Infrared 6s For Sale RiS Louis Vuitton Outlet Online XwB Louis Vuitton Handbags DyB Louis Vuitton Purses XtX Louis Vuitton Handbags YdS Louis Vuitton Outlet Store EqE Michael Kors Sale GuX Michael Kors Handbags BlS Michael Kors Wallet WwX Michael Kors Outlet WcX Michael Kors Factory Outlet RlX