Saying ‘buh-bye’ to Obamacare

February 3, 2011

The always insightful Keith Hennessey show the path to repeal:

The path to repeal is straightforward and, while difficult, achievable. … In 2012 win the White House, hold the House majority, and pick up a net 3 Republican Senate seats to retake the majority there. … In 2013, use reconciliation to repeal ObamaCare, requiring only a simple majority in the Senate. … Repeal of the subsidies, the individual mandate, the insurance provisions, and the Medicaid expansions would, in each case, directly affect spending and revenues, so it would be a straight-up-the-middle use of reconciliation for deficit reduction. Democrats who argued in 2009 that it was OK to use reconciliation to create these provisions would find those same rulings working against them in 2013.

At the moment Democrats are hanging their hat on the CBO-scored deficit reduction associated with the two laws. This CBO score means that a straight repeal amendment faces a Budget Act point of order and therefore needs 60 votes to succeed. If Republicans were in 2013 to try to repeal the laws as-is, CBO would score them with increasing the deficit. That’s not impossible to do through reconciliation, but it’s a trickier path.

Still, this is a solvable problem. The best policy way to address this would be to leave some (most?) of the Medicare savings in place, and not repeal them. I’d also favor leaving the “Cadillac tax” on high cost health plans in place.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Truly facinating to see the GOP turn its back on humanity out of sheer greed. There really is no common good anymore nor is there any “America” in any real sense. We are all just idividuals competing against each other for scarce resources. If you are sick and without enough money to pay for care, you should just suffer. I hope you never get old and need help from your neighbors.

Posted by silliness | Report as abusive

Can we please get back to jobs…Pretty-pretty please. Symbolism is sticking a knife in the back of America the beautiful.

Posted by allenr | Report as abusive

[…] to repeal ObamaCare failed in the Senate by a 51-47 vote. That vote was along party lines. …Saying 'buh-bye' to ObamacareReuters Blogs (blog)James Capretta: Skies darken over ObamacareOCRegisterDems nix GOP ObamaCare […]

Posted by Losing a repeal vote, but winning the war against ObamaCare – Washington Post (blog) | Inflation Policy | Report as abusive

[…] repeal of …Losing a repeal vote, but winning the war against ObamaCareWashington Post (blog)Saying 'buh-bye' to ObamacareReuters Blogs (blog)James Capretta: Skies darken over ObamacareOCRegisterNew York Post -Human […]

Posted by Senate Repeals Obamacare’s 1099 Mandate — OTC Drug Rules Should be Next – | Midterm Vote | Report as abusive