James Pethokoukis

Politics and policy from inside Washington

Obama fails ‘Nixon to China’ budget moment

March 29, 2011

President Barack Obama should get in a New York state of mind. Over the weekend, Andrew Cuomo, the Democratic governor of the Empire State, struck a deal to balance the budget without major tax increases – and five days ahead of deadline. It’s the latest example of how left-of-center politicians, often considered profligate, are better sometimes placed than conservatives to cut spending. Obama is missing a “Nixon to China” moment on dealing with America’s dangerous budget deficit. Consider the following:

1) During the rare times when lawmakers attempt a measure of fiscal responsibility, liberals, generally speaking, prefer to close deficits by raising taxes while conservatives favor reducing spending. But when the spenders do the trimming, it can provide greater confidence to interest groups and voters that the cuts are rational and reasonable. And budget-minded liberal leaders can keep their free-spending legislative allies in check.

2) The phenomenon is global. Starting in 1984, New Zealand’s Labour party slashed the government’s share of GDP by 40 percent over the course of a decade. From the mid-1990s through the mid-2000s, Canada’s Liberals cut federal spending by a third, helping reduce the nation’s debt load from 68 percent of output to 39 percent. Around the same time, Bill Clinton, a Democrat, reached an agreement with congressional Republicans to balance the U.S budget for the first time since 1969.

3) Cuomo could have followed his party’s playbook. In Illinois, Governor Pat Quinn, a Democrat, rammed through dramatic increases in individual and corporate tax rates. Instead, Cuomo opted to eliminate a $10 billion shortfall with a 2 percent spending cut. He may have been worried about his chances for 2016 presidential nomination, but the state’s competitiveness also will have been a consideration.

4) Obama’s decisive moment was last December when his debt commission released its austerity recommendations. But the president has neither embraced that agenda nor given support to a bipartisan group of senators pushing the panel’s plan. Without Obama’s explicit backing, Capitol Hill Democrats will almost certainly kill the effort because it slashes entitlement spending.

When House Republicans come out with their 2012 budget in the coming days, the president may have his final chance to push a comprehensive fiscal reform plan. If Obama’s not careful, it could pass him by in a New York minute.

Comments

I don’t see much hope for changes by this president. He is mired in the liberal marxist/socialist nonsense from his college years.

Posted by zotdoc | Report as abusive
 

Conservatives have not been pushing for reducing deficits, but slashing programs such as education whilst more than spending the ‘savings’ in tax cuts for the wealthy. In the Wisconsin hotbed, for instance, overall the conservative majority and governor have increased spending (despite cutting critical programs such as education) by 1%.

Similarly, conservatives at the federal level show no real intention of making reasonable cuts to things such as subsidizing the already uber-profitable oil industry. Billions of dollars subsidizing the most profitable business in the U.S. seems like a quick and easy budget fix before cutting funding for education or Medicare but conservatives have refused.

The fact you completely ignore this obscene pork and propose to cut entitlement programs to those who actually need it (which study after study shows brings a return on investment into the economy — unemployment compensation, for instance, injects $1.65 into the economy for every $1.00 of unemployment compensation paid out) first show you have no real interest in real budget solutions either, and this article does not begin to approach real news.

Posted by Chibiabos | Report as abusive
 

…which study after study shows brings a return on investment into the economy — unemployment compensation, for instance, injects $1.65 into the economy for every $1.00 of unemployment compensation paid out…

Well now there’s a sure-fire cure for the US economy! Fire EVERYBODY and put ‘em on unemployment – that’ll grow the economy 65%. Just like that!

Posted by Elektrobahn | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •