Pawlenty’s 5 percent solution

June 8, 2011

Tim Pawlenty should be praised for decisively rejecting the declinism that has infected much of the Washington and New York elite. His speech Tuesday at the University of Chicago was a robust reminder of all that once was good in America and could be again.

We settled the west and went to the moon. We liberated billions of good people from communism, fascism, and jihadism. We’ve lit the lamp of freedom for the entire world to see. The strength of our country is our people, not our government. Americans believe our country is exceptional. And they deserve a President who does too. We can fix our economy. Our people are ready to get back to work. We just need to give them to tools to get there. And get the government out of the way.

In his call for a national goal of 5 percent GDP growth for a decade (and, presumably, between 3 and 4 percent thereafter), Pawlenty seems to be echoing JFK rather than Ronald Reagan. But both presidents recognized that deep tax cuts were critical to unleashing the private sector and reinvigorating a flaccid economy.

Is 5 percent GDP growth a realistic goal? It’s certainly a great aspirational one, but many mainstream economists would say it’s not doable. Here’s the challenge: The U.S economy hasn’t grown so fast for so long since the late 1800s. More recently, the economy expanded at a pace just shy of 6 percent from 1962-1966. And as Pawlenty mentioned in his speech, “Between 1983 and 1987, the Reagan recovery grew at 4.9%. Between 1996 and 1999 – under President Bill Clinton and a Republican Congress– the economy grew at more than 4.7%.”

Overall, U.S. GDP growth has averaged 3.3 percent over the past 50 years, with roughly half coming from a growing labor force (1.6 percent) and half coming from higher productivity (1.7 percent). But with America aging, annual labor force growth is expected to slow dramatically to just 0.5 percent. The McKinsey Global Institute thinks a higher retirement age and smarter immigration policy could boost that rate to 1 percent or so. But even then, productivity growth would have to increase to 2.3 percent long term just to maintain that historic growth rate.

The good news is that McKinsey thinks that’s possible, too. One move it recommends is enhancing the U.S regulatory environment. Another is reducing marginal tax rates. Both actions are in line with the Pawlenty agenda. Pawlenty’s proposal to eliminate capital gains taxes would create a de facto consumption tax, which many economist think good for growth. He would also lower the top individual tax rate to 25 percent and the top corporate rate to 15 percent. And like McKinsey, Pawlenty thinks the federal government and healthcare sectors can made be much more efficient and productive. He also wants to sunset federal regulations.

The better news is that GDP growth of, say, 3.5 percent would take a huge chunk out of America’s long-term debt problem since the government’s long-range forecast assumes growth of just 2 percent. So Pawlenty is squarely on the right track. Higher growth is key to avoiding a debt crisis, not to mention improving the American standard of living. With the right policies, America can grow a lot faster than what the pessimists in the Congressional Budget Office and center-left think tanks believe.

But is 5 percent possible, or even 4 percent? That really depends on the pace of innovation. Advances in genetics, robotics, artificial intelligence and nanotechnology could bring about another Industrial Revolution. Innovation expert and computer scientist Irving Wladawsky-Berger think the simultaneous advance of information technology and globalization and entrepreneurial capitalism worldwide is ushering in a “golden age of innovation.” And the faster the world grows, the faster American will grow. And vice versa.

And government’s role is all about creating a fertile environment for growth and innovation through smart tax, regulation and (limited) spending policies. Pawlenty’s “Better Deal” would do that.



We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

[…] Pawlenty's Economic Plan Seeks 5 Pct Annual Growth WTOV Steubenville Washington Times -Reuters Blogs (blog) all 672 news articles » Tags: English, Top StoriesPosted in World | No Comments […]

Posted by Pawlenty Calls for Greater Tax and Spending Cuts Than GOP Rivals – New York Times « Contacto Latino News | Report as abusive

[…] Science MonitorPawlenty proposes deep cuts in federal spending, tax ratesWashington TimesReuters Blogs (blog) -ABC News -CNNall 686 news […]

Posted by Pawlenty Calls for Greater Tax and Spending Cuts Than GOP Rivals – New York Times | Relevant News | Report as abusive

[…] always-insightful James Pethokoukis says as much in a fantastic review of the Pawlenty address: Tim Pawlenty should be praised for decisively rejecting the declinism that […]

Posted by Reaganomics, Pawlenty Style | Race 4 2012 | Report as abusive

Pawlenty is not only boring he’s unrealistic and a lapdog to the millionaires and corporations. Businesses don’t need their taxes reduced by 50%: businesses need their taxes RAISED by 30% and businesses that pay no net income tax should be taxed based on their revenues. For example GE should pay several billion dollars a year in taxes. It’s time to make the millionaires and businesses responsible for all the advantages they are bleeding out of our country. Right now the republican owned businesses in this country are sabotaging the economic recovery in an attempt to unseat Barack Obama in 2012. They are deliberately refusing to hire new employees and they are living off the profits they squeezed out of our citizens in past years. The republicans are un-American. Mark Montgomery NYC, NY

Posted by LegalizeDrugs | Report as abusive

[…] Pethokoukis examines whether Tim Pawlenty's 5 percent growth target is […]

Posted by The American Spectator : AmSpecBlog : Pawlenty’s 5 Percent Growth | Report as abusive

Wow. What an incredibly uninformed comment. The Republican’s are unAmerican? You want to drive most small business out of business with your 30% tax hike. Why do you think some businesses pay no net income tax? Currently the millionaires and businesses are paying by far the lions share of taxes and you feel they are the one’s destroying the country? You think businesses are not hiring because they think that will cost Obmaba the election? I got to think this is a parody of a brain dead progressive, as it is too over the top to be real. Even if you don’t own a business, surely you know SOMEONE who does.

Posted by parrotone1 | Report as abusive

Dear LeagalizeDrugs,

I think we could easily close the budget gap by taxing weed at $2,000 a pound and raising the cost of everything you buy. Maybe by not quite so much. But something. It has got to hurt.

Posted by MSimon | Report as abusive

Mr. P: This ‘declinism’ you mention has infected Chrystia Freeland, among others, on the Reuters website. See her article about the ‘abandoned’ middle class. This whole overarching negativity echoes the 1970s and brings to mind Jimmy Carter’s speech about the American ‘malaise’. Times were perilous back then too – not that most readers of this site under 45 would know that, or care – but America tossed out Mr. Carter and the Democrats, embraced Ronald Reagan and did what needed to be done. Is Tim Pawlenty another another RR? The sentiments and ideas are right, but can he sell them?

Posted by Elektrobahn | Report as abusive

[…] still like the 5 percent target, even though I think 3.5 -4.0 percent is more realistic.  And Pawlenty’s basic path for getting there — tax policy that rewards saving, […]

Posted by James Pethokoukis | Analysis & Opinion | | Report as abusive

[…] Presidential candidate Pawlenty is calling for a target of 5% GDP growth […]

Posted by McKinsey on how to Increase Economic Growth in the United States | Report as abusive

[…] Presidential candidate Pawlenty is calling for a target of 5% GDP growth […]

Posted by McKinsey on how to Increase Economic Growth in the United States « Feeds « Green News-Tweets | Report as abusive