Much depends on, gulp, German consumer
If the euro is going to survive without a Depression, German consumers are going to have to behave in ways that are, well, distinctly un-German.
While attention is focused on the suffering that the euro zone debt debacle is inflicting on the weak and the political anger the costs of bailouts are engendering among the strong, it is important to understand that the belt-tightening won’t just be a Gaelic and Mediterranean phenomenon.
German consumers will (rightly) regard events as likely to increase their taxes while doing precious little for their incomes and job prospects. If they react to this like Americans and spend like there is no tomorrow, well then, perhaps the euro zone can handle the local recessions in the Austerity Provinces. If, on the other hand, Germans behave anything like the way they have in the past, they will save more and only increase spending marginally, if at all.
“Over the four quarters to 2011 Q4 it is hard to see (German consumer spending) growth exceeding 1 percent, and easy to see it falling short, especially if budgetary rigour, rising food and energy prices, and the need for further Club Med subsidy provoke the normal reaction from German consumers,” Charles Dumas of Lombard Street Research in London wrote in a note to clients.
Against the wider backdrop this is not encouraging; U.S. demand will be weak, China is trying to stomp on inflation and the euro zone periphery will very likely be contracting. That really does leave German consumers as the engine of euro zone growth — a role that is, for them, unusual.
To put this in context, since the fourth quarter of 2001 German consumer spending is only up a bit more than 2 percent in real terms, a truly measly expansion. During the same period the household savings rate has risen from about 9 percent to just above 11 percent.
During this time, you will recall, the world experienced a go-go real estate bubble with seemingly free money, much of it German in origin, available to plough into collateralized debt obligations and the like.
If German consumers reacted soberly to the good times, imagine what they will do in coming years when confronted with the risks and costs of either staying in or exiting the euro.
Part of the reasons for German consumer reserve was a policy that constrained wage growth savagely, but again, to look for strong wage growth to emerge at this stage is wishful.
Much has been made of the fact that Germany’s economy grew strongly last year, rising 3.6 percent, the strongest showing since its east and west were reunified. While this is a fine start, Germany did shrink by 4.7 percent the year before and its economy is still 2 percent smaller in real terms than it was at its peak.
While European, including German, officialdom is absolutely opposed to a euro exit, repeatedly characterising it as disastrous and unthinkable, it might not actually be that bad for German consumers, at least after a while.
Dumas of Lombard Street argues that the hit to competitiveness from a newly risen new-deutschemark would be offset by gains in consumers real income and confidence.
“A higher exchange rate would probably cause a healthy redistribution of income from business to labour, ie, consumers — the lack of which is closely connected to undervaluation and excess savings and net export surpluses in Japan and China, as well as Germany.
“Since Germany is unlikely to follow China’s route of real exchange rate appreciation by means of wage inflation, giving some possibility of a shift to consumption from exports, a break-up of EMU may actually be the only hope for achieving an increase of welfare for ordinary Germans.”
Given the current alignment of opinions that is not the most likely outcome, to put it mildly.
What does seem likely is some combination of the following: a recession among the weak in the euro zone exacerbates and is exacerbated by a failure of German demand in the face of uncertainty and limited global demand.
That will raise the rhetoric of euro zone discord and will weaken the euro, causing a problem for the dollarized world, including China. China’s willingness to spend billions to prop up demand for euro zone debt is in no small part because of this.
Europe will remain a strongly deflationary force in the global economy and the biggest risk in the near term as a force to upset the giddiness that is now dominant in global markets.
(At the time of publication James Saft did not own any direct investments in securities mentioned in this article. He may be an owner indirectly as an investor in a fund. Email: email@example.com)