Joan's Feed
Mar 28, 2013

Analysis: Supreme Court energizes gay rights even as it resists

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – After two days of Supreme Court arguments over same-sex marriage, the United States may be left with this irony: While the high court is not likely to alter the constitutional landscape for gays, the justices nevertheless have provided a rallying point for the gay-rights cause.

Three major legal outcomes appeared likely as the justices on Wednesday ended the second dramatic day of arguments in the most closely watched dispute of their current term:

Mar 28, 2013

Analysis – U.S. top court energizes gay rights even as it resists

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – After two days of Supreme Court arguments over same-sex marriage, the United States may be left with this irony: While the high court is not likely to alter the constitutional landscape for gays, the justices nevertheless have provided a rallying point for the gay-rights cause.

Three major legal outcomes appeared likely as the justices on Wednesday ended the second dramatic day of arguments in the most closely watched dispute of their current term:

Mar 26, 2013

Analysis: Supreme Court seems poised to avoid same-sex marriage tide

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – For nearly four years, proponents of same-sex marriage have been strategically building a test case aimed at convincing the conservative-leaning Supreme Court to declare that gay marriage is a constitutional right. The advocates felt they were ready.

But on Tuesday, after an intense, wide-ranging hearing, it appeared the justices were not.

Mar 26, 2013

Analysis – U.S. top court seems poised to avoid same-sex marriage tide

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – For nearly four years, proponents of same-sex marriage have been strategically building a test case aimed at convincing the conservative-leaning U.S. Supreme Court to declare that gay marriage is a constitutional right. The advocates felt they were ready.

But on Tuesday, after an intense, wide-ranging hearing, it appeared the justices were not.

Mar 26, 2013

Major U.S. Supreme Court decisions on gay rights

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The two gay marriage cases the U.S. Supreme Court will hear this week begin a new chapter in its review of discrimination based on sexual orientation.

It has been a decade since the court last took up a gay-rights dispute. That 2003 case from Texas and the court’s two earlier gay-rights decisions were closely fought and produced strong dissenting opinions.

Mar 26, 2013

Factbox – Major U.S. Supreme Court decisions on gay rights

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The two gay marriage cases the U.S. Supreme Court will hear this week begin a new chapter in its review of discrimination based on sexual orientation.

It has been a decade since the court last took up a gay-rights dispute. That 2003 case from Texas and the court’s two earlier gay-rights decisions were closely fought and produced strong dissenting opinions.

Mar 26, 2013

Factbox: Major Supreme Court decisions on gay rights

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The two gay marriage cases the U.S. Supreme Court will hear this week begin a new chapter in its review of discrimination based on sexual orientation.

It has been a decade since the court last took up a gay-rights dispute. That 2003 case from Texas and the court’s two earlier gay-rights decisions were closely fought and produced strong dissenting opinions.

Mar 22, 2013

Gay-marriage cases to define Supreme Court legacy

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – When the U.S. Supreme Court considers the constitutionality of marriage for gay men and lesbians in the coming week, the justices will be taking a major step toward defining their own legacy.

In their first-ever review of same-sex marriage laws, the nine justices on the country’s highest court are hearing arguments on Monday and Tuesday on one of the most politically charged dilemmas of the day, bound with themes of religion, sexuality and social custom.

Mar 20, 2013

Majority supports U.S. benefits for same-sex couples: Reuters/Ipsos poll

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – As the Supreme Court prepares to decide whether the federal government may deny benefits to same-sex married couples that it allows their heterosexual counterparts, Americans seem already to have made up their minds.

Fifty-five percent of those surveyed said married gay and lesbian couples should be able to qualify for Social Security survivor payments and other benefits provided to married heterosexual couples, according to Reuters/Ipsos polling of 2,886 people between March 5 and March 14.

Feb 28, 2013

Analysis – In U.S. voting-rights case, liberal justices pitch to Kennedy

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Barely a minute into a U.S. Supreme Court hearing, liberal justices began a strategic barrage of questions that came down to this: Why should a time-honoured plank of the 1965 Voting Rights Act be invalidated in a case from Alabama with its history of racial discrimination?

What followed constituted a classic example of how justices can try to use oral arguments to dramatic effect and influence a swing vote justice. Key players were Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor, appointees of President Barack Obama and the newest members of the bench. The likely target of their remarks: Anthony Kennedy, a conservative who is often the decisive fifth vote on racial dilemmas.

    • About Joan

      "Joan Biskupic is editor in charge, Legal Affairs, for Reuters. She has reported on the Supreme Court since 1989. Her new book is "Breaking In: The Rise of Sonia Sotomayor and the Politics of Justice.""
    • Follow Joan