The Catch-22 of Google Books

March 28, 2011

booksIt’s almost a Zen Koan: How many books does a library make?

For Google the answer is: “All of them.”

As of last August that particular number was about 129 million, and since then probably tens of thousands have been added to the world’s shelves, even if you exclude Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi’s A Shore Thing.

Some tiny fraction of that immense number is good enough for nearly every library in the world, be it the Library of Congress, the world’s largest, or modest locations which are no less devoted to the preservation and dispensation of the world’s collected knowledge.

For Google, though, it’s all or nothing: The Google Books Project — “one company’s audacious attempt to create the largest and most comprehensive library in the history of the world” as wired.com correspondent Ryan Singel put it — began nearly a decade ago.

The initiative has seen its up and downs over the years. But it hit a serious roadblock last week when a judge ruled that a difficultly-forged agreement among Google, authors and publishers was simply unfair to a particular class of writers: those who cannot not be located to be given the opportunity to choose to allow their copyrighted works be included in the project.

As luck would have it, these so-called orphan works represent a significant portion of the world’s collected knowledge. Google hasn’t said how many it thinks there are, but one academic believes it might total 70 percent — some 90 million works.

The remaining 40 million or so may be plenty for your friendly, neighborhood library, but not for the Google of them all.

Judge Denny Chin raised a number of concerns. But chief among them is one which strikes at the project’s core enabling compromise: the creation of a class which speaks for everyone and allows Google to scan all books and eventually sell them in digital form — including those by elusive authors who have not specifically opted in.

In so doing Judge Chin created something of a Catch-22: The opt-out system he struck down would seem fair enough if you knew how to find every author of every work. But to ask the question you have to be able to find the author.

Clearly copyright law hasn’t kept up with the pace of innovation — even if the Google Books project was limited only to works in the United States, which it is not.

Chances are that significant numbers of authors would opt in to a program that offers found revenue from out of print books. But even a system which requires an owner to opt out might rankle: If you didn’t want to sell your car, should you have to lift a finger to prevent someone from giving you some money and driving it away? Shouldn’t an owner always have total control?

Still, if the public good is overarching, the rights of individuals can be deemed secondary. In Kelo v City of New London the Supreme Court ruled, in essence, that a town could kick people out of their homes to increase tax revenues.

Google is a private company, of course, and stands with the Books project to make money from things other people own even as it provides the world with an everywhere, always open library of everything. But the Utilitarian principle could apply, if harm to the individual is greatly outweighed by a greater good.

This is the crux of the eminent domain finding in Kelo — in which, by the way, a government ran interference for a business in a self-aggrandizing way. If the U.S. government got involved in the Google Books Project, it wouldn’t even have any vested interest. It would only be making a Solomonic decision about the relative rights of citizen intellectual property owners.

It looks like the U.S. Congress might be the next battleground for a long-overdue look at not only the limits to copyright protection but the dizzying array of copyright terms.

It’s not much of an argument, but it would be a shame if Google Books was derailed. The search giant is (at least at the moment) uniquely placed to do it and strongly motivated. It has found common ground with former adversaries who now even take the lead in advocating for it.

Among the fantastic possibilities is the discovery of knowledge hidden in plain site. Atlantic senior editor Alexis Madrigal says his book, Powering the Dream: The History and Promise of Green Technology, could not have been written without Google Books.

“My book puts a topic front and center that has been hidden in the footnotes of the American energy story,” Madrigal wrote as a Wired staff writer. “And without Google Books, I’m not sure it would have been possible to write it.”

Don’t get me wrong: My livelihood depends on the protection of intellectual property rights (even if in reference to myself I use the phrase loosely). Anarchy isn’t an option, and neither is the untoward seizure of property.

Somewhere in that vast middle is common ground. Wouldn’t it be ironic if the answer was hidden away in a book we all forgot existed?

Photo: John C Abell

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

coach…

Put an end to Protesting and complaining And Begin your private men Marketing strategy Instead…

Posted by coach | Report as abusive

YyjmWzAN…

John C. Abell | Analysis & Opinion | Reuters.com…

Posted by YyjmWzAN | Report as abusive

seo tools…

seo tools…

Posted by seo tools | Report as abusive

Cheap Louis Vuitton Shoes…

Cheap Louis Vuitton Shoes…

Posted by Cheap Louis Vuitton Shoes | Report as abusive

Chanel Sale…

Chanel Sale…

Posted by Chanel Sale | Report as abusive

cheap oakley sunglasses…

cheap oakley sunglasses…

Posted by cheap oakley sunglasses | Report as abusive

louis vuitton…

louis vuitton…

Posted by louis vuitton | Report as abusive

gucci bags on sale…

gucci bags on sale…

Posted by gucci bags on sale | Report as abusive

Firefall…

http://www.ufirefall.com…

Posted by Firefall | Report as abusive

diablo 3 gold…

diablo 3 gold…

Posted by diablo 3 gold | Report as abusive

hermes handbags…

hermes handbags…

Posted by hermes handbags | Report as abusive

chanel bags…

chanel bags…

Posted by chanel bags | Report as abusive

chanel outlet…

chanel outlet…

Posted by chanel outlet | Report as abusive

Fake Oakley Sunglasses…

Fake Oakley Sunglasses…

Posted by Fake Oakley Sunglasses | Report as abusive

Toms Kids Shoes…

Toms Kids Shoes…

Posted by Toms Kids Shoes | Report as abusive

gucci wallet…

gucci wallet…

Posted by gucci wallet | Report as abusive

Wow Gold…

Wow Gold…

Posted by Wow Gold | Report as abusive

louis vuitton outlet…

louis vuitton outlet…

Posted by louis vuitton outlet | Report as abusive

Chanel Handbags…

Chanel Handbags…

Posted by Chanel Handbags | Report as abusive

オークリー メガネ…

オークリー メガネ…

Posted by オークリー メガネ | Report as abusive

ISABEL MARANT SNEAKERS PAS CHER…

ISABEL MARANT SNEAKERS PAS CHER…

Posted by ISABEL MARANT SNEAKERS PAS CHER | Report as abusive

cheap cell phone unlocked…

cheap cell phone unlocked…

Posted by cheap cell phone unlocked | Report as abusive

gucci handbags…

gucci handbags…

Posted by gucci handbags | Report as abusive

rs goldrs 3 gold…

rs goldrs 3 gold…

Posted by rs goldrs 3 gold | Report as abusive

LOUIS VUITTON FOR SALE…

LOUIS VUITTON FOR SALE…

Posted by LOUIS VUITTON FOR SALE | Report as abusive

prada…

http://prada.6pnn.com/…

Posted by prada | Report as abusive

Louis Vuitton Online…

Louis Vuitton Online…

Posted by Louis Vuitton Online | Report as abusive

Burberry Outlet Online…

Burberry Outlet Online…

Posted by Burberry Outlet Online | Report as abusive

Mulberry Outlet…

Mulberry Outlet…

Posted by Mulberry Outlet | Report as abusive

Chanel Outlet Handbags…

Chanel Outlet Handbags…

Posted by Chanel Outlet Handbags | Report as abusive

Fake Oakleys…

Fake Oakleys…

Posted by Fake Oakleys | Report as abusive

chanel outlet online…

chanel outlet online…

Posted by chanel outlet online | Report as abusive

Cabas Vanessa Bruno…

Cabas Vanessa Bruno…

Posted by Cabas Vanessa Bruno | Report as abusive

Cheap Neverwinter Astral Diamonds…

Cheap Neverwinter Astral Diamonds…

Posted by Cheap Neverwinter Astral Diamonds | Report as abusive

gucci handbags outlet…

gucci handbags outlet…

Posted by gucci handbags outlet | Report as abusive

ルイヴィトン 財布…

ルイヴィトン 財布…

Posted by ルイヴィトン 財布 | Report as abusive

レイバン メガネ…

レイバン メガネ…

Posted by レイバン メガネ | Report as abusive

cheap oakleys…

cheap oakleys…

Posted by cheap oakleys | Report as abusive

louis vuitton sale…

louis vuitton sale…

Posted by louis vuitton sale | Report as abusive

cheap oakley sungasses…

cheap oakley sungasses…

Posted by cheap oakley sungasses | Report as abusive

WOMENS RAY BAN SUNGLASSES…

WOMENS RAY BAN SUNGLASSES…

Posted by WOMENS RAY BAN SUNGLASSES | Report as abusive

Mulberry Alexa Handbags…

Mulberry Alexa Handbags…

Posted by Mulberry Alexa Handbags | Report as abusive

gucci outlet…

gucci outlet…

Posted by gucci outlet | Report as abusive

chanel handbags for cheap…

chanel handbags for cheap…

Posted by chanel handbags for cheap | Report as abusive

hermes bag…

hermes bag…

Posted by hermes bag | Report as abusive

Hermes Birkin…

Hermes Birkin…

Posted by Hermes Birkin | Report as abusive

iphone 5 price…

iphone 5 price…

Posted by iphone 5 price | Report as abusive

GUCCI BAGS…

GUCCI BAGS…

Posted by GUCCI BAGS | Report as abusive

prada shoes…

prada shoes…

Posted by prada shoes | Report as abusive

gucci outlet store…

gucci outlet store…

Posted by gucci outlet store | Report as abusive

Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags…

Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags…

Posted by Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags | Report as abusive

Prada Outlet…

Prada Outlet…

Posted by Prada Outlet | Report as abusive

BURBERRY BAGS…

BURBERRY BAGS…

Posted by BURBERRY BAGS | Report as abusive

コーチ 財布…

コーチ 財布…

Posted by コーチ 財布 | Report as abusive

gucci bags outlet…

gucci bags outlet…

Posted by gucci bags outlet | Report as abusive

Neverwinter Astral Diamonds…

Neverwinter Astral Diamonds…

Posted by Neverwinter Astral Diamonds | Report as abusive

Replica Oakley Sunglasses…

Replica Oakley Sunglasses…

Posted by Replica Oakley Sunglasses | Report as abusive

gucci shoes…

gucci shoes…

Posted by gucci shoes | Report as abusive

GUCCI OUTLET HANDBAGS…

GUCCI OUTLET HANDBAGS…

Posted by GUCCI OUTLET HANDBAGS | Report as abusive

herve leger dress…

herve leger dress…

Posted by herve leger dress | Report as abusive

Authentic Louis Vuitton…

Authentic Louis Vuitton…

Posted by Authentic Louis Vuitton | Report as abusive

gucci belt…

gucci belt…

Posted by gucci belt | Report as abusive

LOUIS VUITTON BAGS…

LOUIS VUITTON BAGS…

Posted by LOUIS VUITTON BAGS | Report as abusive

Louis Vuitton Wallet…

Louis Vuitton Wallet…

Posted by Louis Vuitton Wallet | Report as abusive

gucci handbags replica…

gucci handbags replica…

Posted by gucci handbags replica | Report as abusive

Vanessa Bruno…

Vanessa Bruno…

Posted by Vanessa Bruno | Report as abusive

You need to get involved in a tournament for example of the best information sites online. I am going to propose this great site!

Posted by Juanita Royse | Report as abusive