Merkel under pressure … but unbending
Some interesting events to ponder over the weekend, though not many of them came from the G8 summit which, as is customary, was strong on rhetoric but bare of any specific policy measures to tackle the euro zone crisis. However, markets seems to have tired of their panicky last few sessions. German Bund futures have opened lower as investors took profits rather than seizing on any positive news. European stocks have edged up.
It does appear that with the ascension of France’s Francois Hollande, the G8 firmament turned into G7 (or maybe 5 since we didn’t hear much from Japan and Russia) versus 1 (Germany) but as things stand we’re still heading for a fairly anaemic “growth strategy” unless euro zone leaders coalesce behind the notion of giving Spain and Greece longer to make the cuts demanded of them. Spain has moved the goalposts further in the wrong direction, revising its 2011 deficit up to 8.9 percent from 8.5 and blaming the overspending regions. That means its already loosened target of 5.3 percent for this year is now even harder to achieve.
Hollande is talking up the case for common euro zone bonds but that will not wash with Berlin for a long time yet. Sources said Monti used the G8 forum to promote a pan-European bank deposit guarantee fund. Good idea but that too will only be conceivable if the European financial sector is on the point of toppling. And who will underwrite it? There is talk too of allowing the EFSF to lend direct to banks to ease the Spanish government’s reluctance to ask for help. That may have a slightly better chance of success but Berlin doesn’t like this idea either. Look no further than the German Chancellor’s take on the summit – it was all a great success, she said. Everyone agreed that we need both growth and fiscal consolidation.
Angela Merkel is one the one with her hand on the purse strings and she knows the markets will only allow so much fiscal loosening. However, the hefty 4.3 percent pay rise secured by Germany’s most powerful union, IG Metall could be a sign that Berlin is starting to loosen the edges of its anti-inflation culture in order to foster a bit of domestic demand. Any profound return to euro zone growth is going to require some internal imbalancing – and that means Germany buying more from its partners to allow them to export more.
No one can accuse Merkel of being disengaged. Despite denials from Berlin, it seems she may have suggested to the Greek president that a referendum on euro membership should be held in parallel with the June 17 elections, a pretty astonishing intervention in another country’s democratic process.
It is certainly true that the mainstream, pro-bailout Greek parties’ only chance of doing better this time is to turn the election into a “euro in or out” poll by explaining why abandoning the bailout will open the exit door. But they have a lot of work to do to regain credibility. Of a series of opinion polls over the weekend, two put the anti-bailout SYRIZA ahead and another gave pro-bailout New Democracy the lead. Since the party who comes in first gets an extra 50 parliamentary seats, the tightness of the race is going to have markets on tenterhooks for the next four weeks. We had a nicely timed interview with SYRIZA leader Alexis Tsipras which ran overnight. He meets French leftist Melenchon today and is talking about building relationships and forging negotiations so Greece can stay in the euro. However, he will not be meeting government officials in France and said the terms of Greece’s 130 billion euros bailout were now a “dead letter” and noted what he saw as the changing dynamics at the G8.
In the meantime, Greeks continue to withdraw their money from the banks, a trend which if it reaches critical mass, could force a European policy response even before the election. If that starts taking root elsewhere, the whole system will be creaking. Spanish banks’ bad loans have hit their highest in 18 years and, with so much tied into a bankrupt property market, no one is quite sure how much worse it is going to get. Late on Friday, clearing house LCH.Clearnet raised the cost of using Spanish bonds to raise funds.
Fed’s Tarullo not making any promises
We’re pretty sure that Daniel Tarullo, the Federal Reserve’s point person on regulation, expects the United States will finally understand exactly what financial reforms are coming “some time next year.” But the Fed governor made doubly sure to qualify that statement lest anyone – especially any press “in the back” – take it as gospel.
At a conference in New York Wednesday morning, Tarullo was asked how long it would take for the various regulatory agencies to give final details on the raft of financial crisis-inspired reforms, everything from Basel III capital standards to the Volcker ban on proprietary trading. Here’s what he said:
“I know it’s frustrating for people not to have the proposed rules out. On the other hand, doing them simultaneously does allow us to see whether something in one of the proposed capital rules will affect something in another proposed capital rule, so that we end up, when we publish the final rules, with fewer anomalies, questions and the like, which will undermine the ability of a firm or academic or just anyone in the public to see and understand how these things are going to function. I hesitate to give a time line on exactly when we’ll get there. But I think…it seems to be reasonable to expect that some time next year the basic outlines – and I don’t just mean the ideas, I mean the details associated with the major reform elements – should be reasonably clear to people even though questions will inevitably rise in implementation. (You) don’t want to take that as a promise. But as I think about these various streams, that is my expectation… To have gotten it done this year would have meant the sheer magnitude of the task would have lead to a lot of inconsistencies or open questions, which then would have just produced another round of change. So you’ve got me on the record saying some time next year, but I tried to qualify it as much as possible – that’s for all you people in the back…”
Austerity light? Maybe a shade lighter
There is a groundswell building in the euro zone that austerity drives should be tempered.
France’s Francois Hollande, favourite to take the presidency next month, said last night that leaders across Europe were awaiting his election to back away from German-led austerity, and even ECB President Mario Draghi called yesterday for a growth pact.
He was rather opaque on how – although he was clear the European Central Bank would not be doing anything more — but his colleague Joerg Asmussen was a little more forthcoming, saying some EU structural funds could be funneled to countries in crisis to boost employment. These sort of ideas are actively part of the mix and could well be enacted at the June EU summit.
Thay also tally with some of Hollande’s policy slate. He is promoting joint European bonds to finance infrastructure projects, greater investment by the European Investment Bank more efficient deployment of EU regional development resources and a financial transaction tax levied help fund youth and education projects. Some of those options are quite likely to happen. Others much less so.
Reality check: The EU’s German paymasters and the ever-present bond market will only tolerate a marginal shift in direction – you need look no further than at what has happened to Spain and its borrowing costs since it upped its deficit target in March — so there will be not much let-up on the debt-cutting front. Nonetheless, there has been a distinct shift in the rhetoric. Even Angela Merkel is pushing for a more broadly-based minimum wage in Germany, which could be construed as a growth tactic.
Dutch finance minister De Jager says multi-party talks about the 2013 budget have been constructive. They will continue today.
The Netherlands is supposed to hand Brussels its budget deficit target next week – the government was targeting 3 percent of GDP but lost its coalition partners, who demanded a softer goal, and collapsed earlier in the week. With elections not due until September, a failure to cobble together a budget deal by the main parties would lead to a dangerous period of uncertainty.
For insatiable markets, Spanish steps fall short
So much for the lasting power of the ECB’s 1 trillion euros in cheap bank loans. Spain is again looking like a basket-case, more because of market dynamics rather than any particular policy misteps.
Many observers have praised Spain for its willingness to implement reforms. And yet the markets have another idea. The cost of insuring debt issued by Spanish banks against default has risen sharply over the past month, as a tough budget this week did little to soothe concerns over the country’s deteriorating fiscal situation.
Default insurance for Santander is up 52 percent since March 1 to 393 basis points and the equivalent for BBVA jumped 54 percent over the same period. Both Spanish banks underperformed the Markit iTraxx senior financials index – which measures Europe’s financial institutions’ insurance, or credit default swap prices. It rose by 20 percent over the same period.
Markit analyst Gavan Nolan said a lot of the move was caused by the European Central Bank’s low-interest, three-year loan programmes, or LTROs, that have pumped money into the banking system.
They’ve actually tightened the relationship between the banks and the sovereign. So the banks have been buying sovereign debt and that has made their fortunes even more intertwined than they have previously.
Pressure on Spanish government debt has had a knock-on effect on banks. Yields on 10-year Spanish bonds this week rose to their highest since December 2011 at 5.8 percent after the Spanish Treasury had to pay more dearly to borrow in an auction.
The cost of insuring Spanish sovereign debt against default meanwhile has jumped 111 basis points to 467 bps over the past month, according to Markit data. This means it costs $467,000 annually to buy $10 million of protection against a Spanish default using a five-year CDS contract.
Citi solicits staff donations for its political lobby
Citigroup, the third largest U.S. bank, is actively soliciting donations from its employees for its political action committee (PAC) or fundraising group. In a letter to staff obtained by Reuters, the bank stressed the importance of the upcoming presidential and Congressional elections, urging staff to give to Citi’s PAC. From the letter:
Our Government Affairs team already does a great job promoting our positions on important issues to lawmakers, but there is one thing that each of us can do to enhance their efforts: contribute to Citi’s Political Action Committee (PAC).
Citi PAC is one of the most effective tools we have to amplify the voice of the company in Washington and enhance our profile with lawmakers. The PAC provides the resources to help suport government officials who share our views on key policy objectives and who understand the impact various policy decisions may have on overall economic investment and growth.
Said a Citi spokesperson:
Citi PAC is funded by the voluntary, personal contributions of its employees. The PAC contributes to candidates on both sides of the aisle that support a strong private sector and promote entrepreneurship.
The firm, which was forced to alter its plans to raise dividend payments following weak results from the Federal Reserve’s bank stress tests earlier this month, is also offering some professional incentives for those employees who are willing to open their wallets.
Over the coming weeks and months, we will host a series of briefings, calls and receptions for Citi PAC supporters. For examples(sic.), contributors to Citi PAC will be invited to attend a closed-door, high-level election year briefing with senior Citi executives and nationally renowned political analyst Charlie Cook. Additional details will soon be circulated.
Who’d be a central banker?
The focus is already on the euro zone finance ministers meeting in Copenhagen, starting on Friday, which is likely to agree to some form of extra funds for the currency bloc’s future bailout fund. What they come up with will go a long way to determining whether markets scent any faltering commitment on the part of Europe’s leaders.
In the meantime, top billing goes to Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann speaking in London later. He is heading an increasingly vocal group within the European Central bank who are fretting about the future inflationary and other consequences of the creation of more than a trillion euros of three-year money. There is no chance of the ECB hitting the policy reverse button yet but the debate looks set to intensify. A combination of German inflation and euro zone money supply numbers today (which include a breakdown on bank lending) will give some guide to the pressures on the ECB.
Central bankers face a very mixed picture with U.S. recovery and high oil vying with the unresolved euro zone debt crisis and signs of slowdown in China.
Bank of England Governor Mervyn King was sitting firmly on the fence yesterday, saying he did not know whether more QE would be required in Britain or not. Tellingly, he also did not know whether euro zone policymakers will take advantage of the window of opportunity offered them by the ECB or not. King illuminated a common theme coming from central bankers, saying the onus was firmly on the politicians now, while his colleague Adam Posen noted that the reason Britain’s recovery has lagged America’s is because of the former’s tough austerity measures. That’s another debate that is echoing around the euro zone. In the States, Bernanke said it is too soon to declare victory in the U.S. economic recovery.
Back to the euro zone and Spanish media was alive with reports that the EU was pressing Madrid to take a bailout to recapitalize its wobbly banks. The denials from both centres were so emphatic that it seems not to be true. It seems EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia spelled out three options to clean up Spain’s banking sector: using Spanish public funds, finding private investment or applying for European aid. Journalists present leapt on the latter. That may well become true in the end … but not yet.
Spain faces a general strike on Thursday while Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy is promising Friday’s 2012 budget will deliver eye-watering austerity for a country already sinking back into recession.
When 500 billion euros no longer pops eyes
There was a time when 500 billion euros in cash was truly spectacular.
But investors and speculators hoping for an even more eye-popping cash injection at the European Central Bank’s second and most likely last three-year money operation on Wednesday are likely to be disappointed, based on past Reuters polls of expectations.
Ever since the ECB started offering cheap, long-term loans to keep cash flowing through banks during the financial crisis, a clear pattern has emerged in the forecasts of money market traders attempting to gauge their size.
They have consistently underestimated the size of a given new loan tender the first time it is offered, only to overshoot on subsequent operations of the same maturity.
It is already widely understood on many trading desks that Wednesday’s sale, which the ECB is not likely to repeat, is an offer that is too good to refuse rather than a vital lifeline to keep the financial system afloat.
“Free lunch” is a common phrase that money market traders contacted by Reuters have used over the past month when providing views on how big Wednesday’s long-term refinancing offer (LTRO), currently expected to be 500 billion euros, is likely to be.
As early as the first one-year tender the ECB offered in 2009 when the credit crisis was gripping the financial system by the jugular and threatening to bring it crashing down, traders were overwhelmed by the wall of cash that hit them.
Europe’s wobbly economy
Things are looking a bit unsteady in the euro zone’s economy. Just ask Olli Rehn, the EU’s top economic official, who warned this week of “risky imbalances” in 12 of the European Union’s 27 members. And that’s doesn’t include Greece, which is too wobbly for words.
Rehn is looking longer term, trying to prevent the next crisis. But the here-and-now is just as wobbly. The euro zone’s economy, which generates 16 percent of world output, shrunk at the end of 2011 and most economists expect the 17-nation currency area to wallow in recession this year and contract around 0.4 percent overall. Few would have been able to see it coming at the start of last year, when Europe’s factories were driving a recovery from the 2008-2009 Great Recession. And it shows just how poisonous the sovereign debt saga has become.
Not everyone thinks things are so shaky. Unicredit’s chief euro zone economist, Marco Valli, is among the few who believe the euro zone will skirt a recession — defined by two consecutive quarters of contraction — in 2012. This year is “bound to witness a gradual but steady improvement in underlying growth momentum,” Valli said, saying the fourth quarter was the low point in the euro zone business cycle.
That could still happen. Business surveys support the idea that the worst is behind us, while European Central Bank President Mario Draghi agrees that last year’s collapse in confidence has now steadied, albeit at low levels. So far, the ECB has not given a strong signal on whether it will take interest rates below the 1 percent level for the first time, but the bigger risk is whether a disorderly Greek default or the threat of a severe credit freeze — which the ECB’s nearly 500 billion euros in loans has so far helped avoid – come back to crush the green shoots of growth.
The ECB’s latest lending survey showed for the last three months of 2011 reinforces the concerns of a credit crunch, as banks are still not passing the money on to the real economy. Thirty-five percent of banks reported they had tightened the standards they apply to loans to businesses, compared to only 16 percent in the third quarter. The ECB is set to make its second offer of three-year loans at the end of the month and that could ease credit risks, but may also discourage banks with bad loans on their books to reform.
So, in economist-speak, the risks are still on the downside and uncertainty remains high. Basically, things are still looking wobbly.
from Global Investing:
January in the rearview mirror
As January 2012 drifts into the rearview mirror as a bumper month for world markets, one way to capture the year so far is in pictures - thanks to Scott Barber and our graphics team.
The driving force behind the market surge was clearly the latest liquidity/monetary stimuli from the world's central banks.
The ECB's near half trillion euros of 3-year loans has stabilised Europe's ailing banks by flooding them with cheap cash for much lower quality collateral. In the process, it's also opened up critical funding windows for the banks and allowed some reinvestment of the ECB loans into cash-strapped euro zone goverments. That in turn has seen most euro government borrowing rates fall. It's also allowed other corporates to come to the capital markets and JP Morgan estimates that euro zone corporate bond sales in January totalled 46 billion euros, the same last year and split equally between financials and non-financials..
But to the extent that the ECB move was aimed primarily at preventing a seizure of the banks, then one measure of success can be seen in the degree to which it steepened government yield curves in Spain and Italy. A positive yield curve, which measures the gap between short-term and long-term interest rates, is effectively commercial banks' ATM -- they make money by simply borrowing short-term and lending long. This chart then shows some normality returning to the benchmark interest structure.
from Global Investing:
Phew! Emerging from euro fog
Holding your breath for instant and comprehensive European Union policies solutions has never been terribly wise. And, as the past three months of summit-ology around the euro sovereign debt crisis attests, you'd be just a little blue in the face waiting for the 'big bazooka'. And, no doubt, there will still be elements of this latest plan knocking around a year or more from now. Yet, the history of euro decision making also shows that Europe tends to deliver some sort of solution eventually and it typically has the firepower if not the automatic will to prevent systemic collapse. And here's where most global investors stand following the "framework" euro stabilisation agreement reached late on Wednesday. It had the basic ingredients, even if the precise recipe still needs to be nailed down. The headline, box-ticking numbers -- a 50% Greek debt writedown, agreement to leverage the euro rescue fund to more than a trillion euros and provisions for bank recapitalisation of more than 100 billion euros -- were broadly what was called for, if not the "shock and awe" some demanded. Financial markets, who had fretted about the "tail risk" of a dysfunctional euro zone meltdown by yearend, have breathed a sigh of relief and equity and risk markets rose on Thursday. European bank stocks gained almost 6%, world equity indices and euro climbed to their highest in almost two months in an audible "Phew!".
Credit Suisse economists gave a qualified but positive spin to the deal in a note to clients this morning:
It would be clearly premature to declare the euro crisis as fully resolved. Nevertheless, it is our impression that EU leaders have made significant progress on all fronts. This suggests that the rebound in risk assets that has been underway in recent days may well continue for some time.
So what exactly have investors and been doing while waiting for the fog to clear in Brussels? The truth on most benchmark prices and indices is "not very much" -- at least not since world markets got the collywobbles in early August about US downgrades and debt ceilings, euro sovereign debt angst and double dip recession. Yet, since the European stocks nadir in late September prodded the Franco-German alliance into more serious action, there has been some impressive market gains of between 10 and 20% across most equity sectors and national indices. More broadly, after a year of intense political and financial turmoil across the globe, developed market equities are only down about 4% year-to-date -- a 10 point outperformance on emerging markets, for example.
And the clearing of the euro fog now allows investors to start looking beyond the Brussels cauldron and review how the rest of the world is shaping up. What they find, surprisingly for those drowning in disaster commentaries, is‘not all that bad – especially, but not exclusively in the United States. There's been a string of more positive economic data releases throughout October and these have continued through the back end of last week and early this week. The bellwether Philadelphia Fed industrial index rose to its highest in six months; U.S. durable goods orders (excluding volatile aircraft orders) rose at their fastest pace in six months in September; U.S. new home sales rose at their fastest in five months; business surveys show Chinese manufacturing is back expanding again in October for the first time in three months; U.S. power firms are reporting a pickup in industrial activity in H2, Ford has increased fourth quarter forecast for North American vehicle production. The U.S. Q3 earnings season hasn’t been half bad either – with a third of the S&P500 reported, some 70 percent beat forecasts and the main strength was in the industrial world. What’s more for markets, seasonal equity flows are typically in an updraft for the rest of the year, all things being equal. Fund managers already started rebuilding equity positions in September.
European business and consumer sentiment surveys have continued to push lower through the policy logjam, unsurprisingly, even if real data contradicts some of that anecdotal ‘evidence’. And this may well translate into the wider investment theme as the euro crisis ebbs. Europe may agree to adapt grudgingly to solve its immediate problem but tyhen pay the price in economic growth because it’s less worse than the alternative of financial chaos.
On the more immediate horizon, there may be groans from those hoping to escape summit mania as G20 leaders are set to meet in Cannes next Thursday and Friday -- with a hoped-for endorsement of the euro plan and a specific interest in the EFSF/IMF/SPV idea that seems to be courting sovereign wealth funds from China and other emerging giants from the BRICs to use a special conduit to buy euro sovereign bonds. ECB rate cuts too may be firmly back in the frame on Thursday as Mario Draghi takes the helm of the central bank for the first time. The Federal Reserve's Open Market Committee gives us its latest decision on Wednesday. US payrolls looms large on Friday, with a heavy European earnings sked including Barclays, BMW, ING, BNPP, Unilever, CS, ArcelorMittal, RBS, Commerzbank, and many more.
Good analysis, but one observation…..
Merkel suggests a referendum to the Greeks on membership and its “astonishing intervention.” Obama (head of a country not even in the EU) takes an official position on Greece’s membership in the Eurozone and pressures for more European borrowing for his own political gain and it’s a non-issue. Fascinating.