Staving off the search war apocalypse

March 7, 2011

search_apocalypse

Think the search engine wars are over? They’ve only just begun.

The fight isn’t over who’s the most popular anymore. Google has that sown up for now with a nearly 90 percent share, according to what StatCounter published last week. Microsoft’s Bing Yahoo account for an anemic 8 percent worldwide.

The battle isn’t for the hearts and minds of the public; It is for the heart and soul of the internet — a battle to put “content farms” in their place and suffocate sites which, due to creative SEO, somehow manage to appear higher in search results than the original sites whose content they are re-blogging or flat-out stealing.

The sanctity of search is critical because search is the entry point for the internet, the gateway to everything you haven’t bookmarked or that hasn’t been recommended to you. And since it is the 800-pound gorilla, if Google’s results are compromised, everyone loses.

“You’re not on the web if you’re not on Google,” according to my former boss Leander Kahney — whose own Cult of Mac site was caught up in the content farm wars: “Google is the web — who uses anything else to find stuff?”

So when Google takes aim at content farms, as they did last week by releasing a change to their secret algorithm which put them on top by showing the most relevant results to a query, you are witnessing a shot heard round the world.

With Project Panda, Google attempted to weed out what Matt Cutts, the company’s top search-spam fighter, calls “shallow content sites.” The changes affected almost 12 percent of all search results, and instantly brought a big drop off in traffic for some sites, including some “good” sites caught up in the major change.

Still Cutts told Wired’s Steven Levy that the changes seemed to be working as intended.

“I got an e-mail from someone who wrote out of the blue and said, ‘Hey, a couple months ago, I was worried that my daughter had pediatric multiple sclerosis, and the content farms were ranking above government sites’,’’ Cutts said. “‘Now,’ she said, ‘the government sites are ranking higher. So I just wanted to write and say thank you.’”

It will take a while for the dust to to settle before for we can fairly judge whether Google’s algorithm change has had the desire effect. But the cat and mouse game continues.

Caught in the middle are us. Search is so much part of living and breathing that we take it for granted. We reflexively assume that the “best” results are at the top.

If this truism ends … well, that apocalypse is too scary to imagine.

No comments so far

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

[...] already started trying to weed out the content farms from search rankings, in a move described by Reuters as aiming to fend-off the New Search [...]

Posted by Gaming Google: The frustrating rise of content farms « OnPR | Report as abusive

[...] Reuters Blogs (blog) [...]

Posted by Google’s code change shifts billions from losers to winners – CNNMoney | DC2NET Links | Report as abusive

[...] Reuters Blogs (blog) [...]

Posted by Blogging From The Beginning » Blog Archive » Titan SEO Explains Google's Move to Increase Relevancy – PR Newswire (press release) | Report as abusive

[...] Reuters Blogs (blog) [...]

Posted by The Farmer Panda Impact Nobody Is Talking About – Search Engine Land : SEO Blogger Tips | Free SEO Tips and Resources | | Report as abusive

[...] Reuters Blogs (blog) [...]

Posted by SEO Internet Marketing Tips For The Google Panda Algorithm Update – Jazzou | DC2NET Links | Report as abusive

[...] Source:http://blogs.reuters.com/mediafil e/2011/03/07/staving-off-the-search-war- apocalypse/ This entry was posted in Technology and tagged heart and soul, hearts and minds, search engine wars. Bookmark the permalink. ← 5 Reasons to Upgrade to the iPad 2 [...]

Posted by The search war apocalypse is among us | Pixelbean | Report as abusive

[...] I was pretty happy to see my version of the Google logo lumped in with a small collection of other ones on the first page that comes up on Google’s recent code switch. This story can be found on Reuters here. [...]

Posted by My Google Logo Made the Big time | Tyler Jordan | Report as abusive

[...] but also in general public media, such as The Atlantic, Slate, International Business Times, and Reuters. The change was announced on Google’s blog in a post by Google’s Amit Singhal and Matt [...]

Posted by Google’s Panda Update | Report as abusive

[...] I was pretty happy to see my version of the Google logo lumped in with a small collection of other ones on the first page that comes up on Google’s recent code switch. This story can be found on Reuters here. [...]

Posted by My Google Logo Made the Big time | dev | Report as abusive