Arthur Andersen. Anthony Weiner. News Corp?

July 13, 2011

Arthur Andersen. Anthony Weiner. News Corp?

Sure, it’s too early to “go there.” News Corp is an immense, diversified multi-national media conglomerate that has been widely reviled by many for more than a generation. For all of his detractors there are plenty of readers, viewers and shareholders who are just fine with Rupert Murdoch’s tabloidization and opinionization of the news business.

The New York Post may chronically lose money but such things are hardly news in the newspaper business. Yet the Post is a metaphor for the Murdoch empire. When Rupert amped up the sleepy New York tabloid to take on the New York Daily News, he started a media revolution with the newspaper that had been founded by Founding Father Alexander Hamilton.

It all seems so quaint now, with cable news talk show hosts having no qualm about taking sides in the style set by Fox News, and with newspapers still struggling to re-establish their relevance as a medium.

It’s been a bummer of a summer so far for Murdoch, starting with the sale of MySpace for about seven cents on the dollar. Until recently News Corp had been almost a teflon empire. You could almost say it’s Murdoch’s world — we just live in it. Even slings and arrows and kitchen sinks tossed at the Australian-turned-American seemed to have no discernible effect on the Murdoch empire except perhaps to have made it grow exponentially.

But unbridled success sometimes brings unbridled hubris and greed — not just for money, but also to be first and original and in a league of one’s own. And then it’s Greek tragedy time.

The closing of the News of the World was a big concession to the seriousness of the self-inflicted wound that was a systematic program to scoop out “news” by hacking into the voicemails of celebrities, politicians and private citizens suffering through crises. But it is unlikely to be nearly enough. The snowball is already getting bigger: On Wednesday, News Corp withdrew its bid for the rest of BSkyB, a direct result of disgust over this tempest. And in his adopted country, Sen. John Rockefeller has called for an investigation of the hacking scandal to see if any U.S. laws were broken.

The NOTW scandal pushed buttons that everyone can relate to: We may not mind that Hugh Grant’s privacy has been violated. But hacking into the phones of missing children who turned up dead, and to victims of terrorist attacks, brings home the scary in a way which reminds us of how we romanticize mob turf wars — it’s a good read until civilians start getting killed.

The truth is that mobile phone voicemails are probably accessed without your knowledge all the time by divorce lawyers, police departments, spies — and, for that matter, family members. There is nothing particularly challenging about hacking this data: it lives on remote servers that are accessible via the internet, just like your credit card numbers, bank accounts and Playstation information. (Mom’s low-tech approach is much more direct: she need only grab your phone as you sleep).

The problem for News Corp now is that there are lots of people who won’t forget quickly or move on. Only on Tuesday Rupert Murdoch and son were summoned by British MPs to testify about the scandal. This a terrible prospect for the brand when the less said is the better and you are facing politicians who have the higher moral ground for a change.

Protests and boycotts of huge companies have a history of having little effect, but it’s different when the target’s very existence depends on the public trust. Arthur Andersen was a Big Five accountancy until it was convicted of ethical violations in its dealings with client Enron. The company literally dissolved into virtual non-existence in a matter of weeks.

Weiner blamed hacking when he stupidly used Twitter to sext with a woman not his wife and lied relentlessly about it until cracking under unrelenting media glare (led by Weiner’s home town paper, the New York Post). Even though there was no allegation of any actual illicit sex, Weiner was crushed in a nanosecond. Meanwhile, former President Bill Clinton did have sex with that woman, lied about it, survived what was only the second presidential impeachment trial in U.S. history, and now thrives as an elder statesman.

Murdoch blamed his messengers at NOTW — most of whom were not even working there when all that foul stuff was going on — by shuttering the place and sacking the entire staff as a grand sacrifice on the pyre of public opinion.

For lack of a nail, a kingdom can be lost. As long as this story doesn’t go away, the Murdoch empire is in jeopardy.  All because some private investigators were told to bang out a few commands on a keyboard.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Good left wing view of the Murdoch empire – just wishing for it to crumble so the left bias can once again dominate.

The reason for Murdochs success is exemplified by this article trying to conflate Anderson and Weiner with Murdoch.

Posted by eleno | Report as abusive

Sorry you misunderstand, @eleno. I am talking about trajectory when someone does stupid things. Or commit crimes and lie about it. But thanks for the irrelevant, conflated (articles like this are the reason for Murdoch’s success? Really?) political analysis.

Posted by johncabell | Report as abusive

[…] shares steady after News Corp pulls bidNewsday (subscription)RT -Reuters Blogs (blog) -AFP -Sky Newsall 7,865 news […]

Posted by Murdoch Withdraws Bid for Control of British Satellite Television Company – Voice of America (blog) — News Addicts | Report as abusive

[…] the News (Corp.)?CNNCable on Murdoch BSkyB withdrawalBBC NewsNPR -The Independent -Reuters Blogs (blog) -AFPall 9,371 news […]

Posted by BSkyB shares rally after News Corp pulls bid – Seattle Post Intelligencer — News Addicts | Report as abusive

I’d say I’m a progressive by American standards and I’ve never had any inclination to read any news whatsoever on Foxnewsdotcom or Drudge… I’m surprised so many dittoheads find their way on to real news sites and complain about them. If the ‘left-wing bias’ is so distasteful, go elsewhere. Anything beats reading the countless asinine comments left by you and your flock that show how little your reality is based on facts. But then again, I guess there are some topics that Fox just won’t cover so you HAVE to come here to get real news, huh.

Posted by CDN_Rebel | Report as abusive

For lack of a nail, a kingdom can be lost. As long as this story doesn’t go away, the Murdoch empire is in jeopardy…http://www.pizzeriaschezmaggy.c om

Posted by perurestaurants | Report as abusive