Reuters Blogs

Pakistan: Now or Never?

Perspectives on Pakistan

08:04 August 13th, 2009

Pakistan’s Enemy No.1

Posted by: Sanjeev Miglani
Tags: Pakistan: Now or Never, , , , , , ,

Who is Pakistan’s biggest threat? Not the Taliban, not even India, but the United States, according to an overwhelming majority of Pakistanis surveyed in a poll just out.

On the eve of the 62nd anniversary of Pakistan’s creation, the Gallup Pakistan poll offers a window into the mind of a troubled, victimised nation. And it surely must make for some equally uncomfortable reading in the United States, led at this time by a president who has sought to reach out to the Muslim world and distance himself from the foreign policy adventurism of his predecessor.

Here is the poll summary and here the full poll conducted by Gallup Pakistan, an affiliate of Gallup International. The poll was commissioned by Al Jazeera and here are some highlights:

Fifty-nine percent of Pakistanis believe the United States poses the greatest threat to the nation, despite the billions of dollars of military and development aid. (There is, of course, a separate debate on about how heavily the previous administration skewed the aid towards the military instead of schools and hospitals as highlighted in a report by the influential Center for American Progress but that at some other point.)

About 18 percent of those polled said they felt most threatened by India. The number is not as high as you would ordinarily expect, given that the Pakistani establishment has long portrayed the neighbour as the existential threat. Is there an opportunity here? Will the peacemakers on the two sides seize on this to build greater people-to-people contacts?

Anyway to get back to the poll, only 11 percent thought that the Taliban were the greatest threat, despite all the bombings and suicide attacks they have carried out across the country. To a separate question, some 43 percent supported dialogue with the Taliban.

Is there a huge disconnect then? While America says the next major attack is likely to originate from the Taliban - al Qaeda strongholds in Pakistan’s northwest, quite a substantial number of Pakistanis do not think them to be a threat, and would like talks to resolve the problem.

“Drone anger” or public fury over U.S. Predator strikes inside Pakistan seems to be especially responsible for America’s unpopularity. A massive 67 percent of those polled said they opposed U.S. military operations on Pakistani soil.

Can America then really fight this war, with the Pakistani people so dead against it? For the United States to become even more hated than India, it takes quite a doing, the Gulf-based The Nation wrote.

“If it is less popular in Pakistan than India is, it must indeed be doing something wrong. Billions of dollars in aid and untold numbers of visits by US officials have failed to win Pakistan’s full support for efforts to defeat the Taliban,” the paper said.

This poll was conducted on July 26-27 in all four provinces of the country. Which means it was done before the reported death of Pakistani Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud in a U.S. drone strike. That has been widely welcomed in Pakistan and some people think it may blunt some of the hostility to U.S. drone attacks as The Times notes.

But it is hard to see the numbers drop dramatically, especially given that the Pakistani Taliban is not about to be finished despite the loss of its powerful leader.

So where do we go from here?  Rob Asghar, a Pakistan-American writing in the Huffington Post, kicks the ball back at Pakistanis, saying ultimately nobody can help them save themselves. Pakistan must stop thinking of itself as the victim, blaming first India, and now the United States for all its ills.

“As a Pakistani-American, let me offer my own poll response: The biggest threat posed to Pakistan comes not from the U.S. Not from the Taliban. And not from India.”

“No, the biggest threat to Pakistan comes from Pakistanis. The threat comes from the actions of some, and the inaction of others.”

[File photo of a protest in Lahore and U.S. Central Command chief General David Petraeus and Pakistani army chief General Ashfaq Kayani]

45 comments so far

[...] post by Sanjeev Miglani and software by Elliott Back Filed under 5286 Comment (RSS)  |  Trackback [...]

- Posted by Pakistan’s Enemy No.1 « Lounge PK

Aleithia,(cc bulletfish)

No.I dont mean madarassa curriculum, I mean the municipal state govt run regular schools for crying out loud. Please please google- pakistan, textbooks,hindus.

The regular school texts write history of their country as that after partition and demonize hindus living in small closed dark places and killing muslims on a daily basis. These are the books read by students since 1973 (remember Zia?) till today. Let first worry about state required school syllabus before going after the wahabi run madarassas.Thats (closing madrassas) a tall order.

Aleitha ask your Pak friends about the school TEXTBOOKS not madarassa books.That explains the hatred in a 20 yr old Pakistni for India for whom India and Brazil should nt differ much.Indian school text books depict no such hatred against a religion or a country.Just like those in Canada or UK.

- Posted by Azad

ask whats taught in the school college text books in Pak about other religions and nations and compare to USA/Canada/UK and India.

You will realize the underlying reason of the Paks hate filled existence. Keep good work. Cheers.
-Azad

There was an very detailed article in the Daily Mail (UK) about the madrassa education system. Even though this newspaper is right wing, it does not deviate from presenting the facts. In the article the journalist pointed out the at the children do not just read the holy Koran, they learn the alphabet too:
A is for Allah
B is for Bundook (rifle/gun)
C is for Cuffir
…etc.

Since 1979 have these madrassas been churning out boys to fight the Soviets and now they have turned their guns on to the USA who in turn have told Pakistan to eliminate them. If USA is enemy number one it has been in the making for a long time.

- Posted by bulletfish

Alethia

ask whats taught in the school college text books in Pak about other religions and nations and compare to USA/Canada/UK and India.

You will realize the underlying reason of the Paks hate filled existence. Keep good work. Cheers.

- Posted by Azad

Pakistan’s biggest enemy is PAKISTAN itself, why blame USA, they are doing what they shold be doing eg. protect their own intrest, the leaders there are not elected by pakistanis or for that matter Indians, they are elected by American, and they are answerable to them,
everybody talks about the nuclear deal with India well that is not bec suddenly they have fallen in love with india, but bec they need to sell the nuclear plant to india so americal co can make make as simple as that

Pakiatan should see its own intrest use america if possible or for that matter any country

the terrorist can be eliminated in a month time if india, pakistan , afganistan, bamgladesh, nepal get togather, just slaughter them, afterthat the only problem will be kashmir between india and pakistan, well i beleive if after working togather eliminating terrosim , i guess there will be so much goodwill generated in our countries, that sitting togather to solve the problem will be easier as ego and politics will not be there, as our politician willo longer be able to use it as a political tool, sadly armies will be without a job specially pakistani, as they will have no immediate enemy, unlike india who has china to deal with

ciao

- Posted by richie rodrigues

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.