Comments on: CFR on Pakistan: hold course (for now) Perspectives on Pakistan Thu, 01 Oct 2015 19:31:05 +0000 hourly 1 By: pakistan Sat, 27 Nov 2010 00:48:58 +0000 @Mortal
Grow up and grow out of rudeness. At least try it.
Rex Minor

By: Mortal1 Fri, 26 Nov 2010 02:32:55 +0000 Minor,

I have no intention of wasting my time, indulging in a sparring contest with you. Bottomline is, I don’t have much of an appetite for your factless, delusional & pshycic, “stomach based” line of thinking. I don’t think you’re a bad guy, just that most of your comments don’t make much sense to me. take care!

By: rehmat Fri, 26 Nov 2010 00:44:00 +0000 @Rex
“Sorry, in my view you a very poor knowledge or perhaps deliberately posting motherhood.”
***Was it you who said you do not have patience with anyone who does not follow your thinking. Use wide angle lens to understand what I say.

“deliberately posting motherhood.”

“You have definitely not been exposed to philosophy that is why I mentioned these countries. Not to belittle you.”

***Yes Dr. Minor, the father of crapilosophy, you are right, I have not been exposed to this particular area of philosophy. Trust me I am learning fast and prove to be a good student.

What a nut case!

By: pakistan Thu, 25 Nov 2010 13:30:45 +0000 @KPSingh
You are a hilarious personality. You would even outmatch the commedians of CNN and CNBC. There were minor errors though in your narration, BL is or was the son in law of the powerful Omar. Mr BL has died several years ago and Mr Omar is now permanently in meditation in the arabian world, perhaps a guest at the BL’s family saudi residence. Saudi Arabia as you know is the God father of the USA and keeping their economy going.

Rex Minor

PS Omar lost his one eye battling Russians the friends of the communist gang in Afghanistan, not at the hands of his cousins.

By: pakistan Thu, 25 Nov 2010 13:15:10 +0000 @Mortal
Doctrate yes, but not in nonsense. Do you also address your Professors in such a unfriendly way? Be careful, the break is over. Let us concentrate on the topic; CFR on Pakistan!
Rex Minor

By: pakistan Thu, 25 Nov 2010 13:08:34 +0000 @Rehmat
Sorry, in my view you a very poor knowledge or perhaps deliberately posting motherhood. I have no feelings for foreigners, neither love nor hate. I simply admirte the winners and ignore or pity the loosers. You have definitely not been exposed to philosophy that is why I mentioned these countries. Not to belittle you.
Have fun to use your words.

Rex Minor

By: rehmat Wed, 24 Nov 2010 23:15:03 +0000 Rex

“may I suggest that you schould better spend some time in French and German universities to study Philosophy, or straight go to the devil’s den in Brooking Institute or chattahm House.”

*** How do you know I did not spend sometime allover? It is stupid any way. Keep your German and Taliban love, and American hatred to yourself.

You are getting absurd by the day.

By: pakistan Wed, 24 Nov 2010 21:50:24 +0000 @KPSingh

You are right sir. I did not mean to run away from the article. I shall revert to it as soon as I have answered Rehmat.

I have no problem with your non-cynical questions. But since you are raising hypothetical questions, may I suggest that you schould better spend some time in French and German universities to study Philosophy, or straight go to the devil’s den in Brooking Institute or chattahm House.

The problem you have is faced by most history students, the time and the place when history is experienced is often forgotten. I once aked a question, if you do not recognise that the Europeans are at least a century ahead of your civilisation, then there is no need to discuss further certain questions.

I am not taking you back to the neandertaler humans, but let us try to go back to the good old days, when there was starvation in Europe. People were looking for jobs that were not there and food which was not sufficient. There was also anarchy and criminality and the police were unable to handle them.
Most criminals from the UK were then being despatched to Austarlia. The poor and adventrous Irish and other europeans went over to the USA along with criminals,bandits and starving families to find a land where they could grow grain and prosper.

Well they found the land and some natives, apaches in the USA and the aborignies in Austaralia as well. So what, the natives assimilated or vaniished, and their place was slowly taken over by the slaves from africa. Not to forget the so called civil war in america, I do not what was civil in that war.
There were battles in america among the primitive agnostics and the south lost.

The Americans and the Austraians gradualy became so called civilised, with support from their countries of origin, though I must admit the Americans took a longer time but then very shorly took a decline slowly and slowly.

During the ww2 the europeansand the Americans were more or less civilised humans. This was the single most important reason to confront the Germans who under Hitler suddenly felt like conquering and controlling the terrotories and the people of the world.
The USA has not nuked Japan to its knees(do not distort the history).
No I am not o’k, we were not living in the stone age, the americans bombed the Japanese as a revenge and the brits bombarding the Dresden was also a revenge and what we are witnessing in your part of the world is also the revenge. So stop calling the people radicals, talibans, terrorists etc etc. The survival of the fittest is no longer valid. There are people in this world who have allocated all their wealth for the benefit of those who need it. We are civilised now, we have lost a lot but have learned. We do not want Indians and Pakistanis to follow the ways of Americans. The USA cannot keep on consuming a larger share of the earth resorces, they must allow others like India and China with large populations to improve the standard of living for their people.

Apparently you have never met Pashtoons, they live on proteins and fruits. How can you even imagine about them being defeated. They manufacture KK’s, and take their opium right across the oceans and land to reach their customers across the world. Let the Americans at least destroy their opium fields to demonstrate that they are capable of confronting them at least. KPSingh knows their history, what is it all about.´Are they invisible in battles; they picked up a man supposedly the Taliban leader and supposedly brought him in a helicopter from Quetta to Kabul and then discovered that the guy was an imposter? France 24 cable network newsitem.

Rex Minor

By: rehmat Wed, 24 Nov 2010 14:40:59 +0000 Rex

“You are always acting like the devil’s advocate. No offence is intended.”

***Acting like Devil’s advocate is helpful since that challenges us to introspect.

Let me go further, what if USA nuke the hell out of Afghanistan and there is no living Pushtoon or any Taliban left, just their Kleshnikovs. There is nothing special about Pushtoons that it was not about Natives–both live simple lives, isn’t it?

I am trying to feel your survival of fittest theory. Then you should be OK with USA nuking Japan to its Knees. Survival of the fittest, right?

I am a person who asks questions to get better answers and a useful debate. Bit uncomfortable, but helpful. No offense, really!

By: KPSingh01 Wed, 24 Nov 2010 14:01:56 +0000 The topic is about Pakistan’s course in the wake of new American strategic thinking.

Mr. Rex,

I’d suggest sticking to the topic line as much as possible. This is not the forum for discussing religious beliefs, non-believers, stomach etc. You have basically hijacked the discussion with responses from Indians. This discussion is turning non-sensical.