The hard jobs

March 20, 2012

By Denis Balibouse

If I had my dream life as a photographer, it would be a mix of working like Ansel Adams, Michael Kenna and Hirochi Sugimoto, contemplating nature and shooting landscapes in black and white. However, I am a photojournalist, and I cover news: mostly sport, politics and finance, but sometimes heart-breaking events.

Last week in Sierre, western Switzerland, a bus carrying 52 people crashed in a tunnel, killing 6 adults and 22 children.

Last Tuesday night I was at home, after a quiet day doing mostly administrative stuff. At 10.31pm I received an SMS. The message was brief but described an accident involving a foreign bus in a tunnel on a motorway. It mentioned multiple casualties and forbade the media from entering the tunnel.

After a short phone call to the duty police officer to assess the situation, I grabbed my equipment, told my wife that I would be back as soon as possible and drove the 120km (74 miles) to Sierre. Usually, these stories are over quickly, and often not deemed newsworthy, but I had a bad feeling about this one.

During the drive I had time to think about how to approach the job. I tried to prepare as much as I could, knowing that on the scene things could change quickly. I arrived shortly before midnight and took a safe position on the bridge of the way-out of the motorway, overlooking the entrance of the tunnel, some 400 yards away.

There were four helicopters positioned between the photographers and onlookers on the bridge and the entrance to the tunnel. Visibility on the bridge was poor. The situation down below seemed eerily calm. I only saw two ambulances in one hour.

By 1am all agencies had a photographer on the scene. We received another text message announcing a press conference at 5am. As we couldn’t return home, the local photographer invited us to her place for coffee.

After coffee, we decided to go back to the tunnel as the press officer was unable to tell us if we would have access to the crash site in the morning or if the bus would be pulled out before 5am.

Shortly after 5am the Head of the Valaisan Cantonal Police announced the 28 casualties. The scale of the tragedy came as a blow to us all.

I was about to start editing news conference pictures when we received the okay to access the crash site and photograph the removal of the wreckage. My pictures so far covered the start of the terrible story. I knew that what was to come was a long and unpleasant wait for the poor families of the victims.

I don’t think any photographer enjoys photographing the suffering of others, but part of our job is to bear witness to these events. We all know that our camera can serve as a sort of barrier, shielding us from the emotion of what is taking place in front of us. However, once it is all over the memories of what you have seen stay with you. A couple of times in my car going from one spot to the other over the days that followed I could sense the emotion surrounding this tragedy rising within me.

Stories such as this always lead to questions about the way we report the news. In a place as quiet and orderly as Switzerland, where there exists a gentlemen’s agreement with the police that we don’t photograph disturbing images or the deceased, how do we record the suffering of the people affected by this horrible event?

When I compared what I saw coming from conflict zones or even the pictures shot outside the school where my Belgian colleagues attended the arrival of schoolmates and parents after this crash it wasn’t long before I started asking myself about what ‘news’ is and where does the public’s right to know start and stop?

Should the police have allowed us into the tunnel to shoot the wreckage after the emergency services had finished their work? What about the poor little girl holding a flower and crying outside the parents hotel, should she be photographed at such a time? There are probably as many answers to those questions as we have clients; so many different cultures and ways to report news.

The days following that 5am press conference were filled with sorrow but also great teamwork and cooperation between pictures, text and the TV department of Reuters. Teamwork is an obvious requirement of this industry but it can prove elusive at times. I’m grateful for that sense of camaraderie during this difficult job, and for moments like my chief photographer and another colleague calling me while they were on holidays to offer their help and also to see how I was.

After three days and nights, I made it home, exhausted but ready to give my son and wife the biggest hugs I could ever give, my mind never far away from those poor families who had lost so much in Sierre.

5 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

the photo of the sorrow and grief portrayed on the face of the young girl enables all who see this feel the real tragedy of the tunnel accident…

Posted by together9 | Report as abusive

I am a decorated and disabled US Navy Veteran. When I tell folks that I have been around the world three times : once underwater going West to East, then again but that time otherway around so I won’t live a day longer than everyone else (international dateline crossing) and finally over both poles – my audience often questions the size of the fish. To be honest the ones that get away … are usually a bit bigger or smaller.

The point I am trying to make is I’ve been there and done that. Try Googling “USS Georgia sinks tug.” And NO! I wasn’t there either but for those of us who must play real “War Games” life and death becomes two sides of the same coin. If readers would do a little bit of research they should be able to verify the facts.

When I tell folks THIS one I usually make some casual remark about “lost cans of tuna” and/or fish food. That may seem inappropriate, rude or down right nasty. But death, destruction … war and many human activities are neither neat nor pleasant.

Think. Or better yet watch up close as the baby cow pops out; a young male bovine struggles while “we” remove a few of its body parts so it can grow up to be a prize steer and then be butchered so your darling little one (cat/dog or human?) can have a Hamburger “Happy Meal.”

That is what happens in REAL life. In my NOT so humble opinion or for what its worth, telling children “nice fairy tales” or educated adults to turn their heads to shield their eyes from the truth is wrong. It creates a world where false assumptions and the impossible demand for absolute safety rule the day.

Would those people have been safer climbing over the alps on foot? So take the pictures. Write and tell the story. If folks are offended – that just too bad!

Posted by GLsword | Report as abusive

This probably is the worst part of been photographer. Death, especially with kids. RIP for those peoples!

Posted by DanQueiroz | Report as abusive

All photographers offer their interpretation of the world’s colors and shapes, its action and its majesty. Some offer access, or humor, or juxtapositions, or sarcasm. Only a very few offer their humanity.

Posted by Mazzaschi | Report as abusive

der spiegel had photographs of the bus wreckage showing the bloody smears of the carnage as it scraped the passengers along the wall

photographs attract readers to the news and advertising revenue

but there is a point where imagination is more evocative and the photograph fades into the banality of rescue voyeurism

Posted by scythe | Report as abusive