If the takeover of Alliance Data Systems Corp. collapses under regulatory pressures, Blackstone Group would face the dubious distinction of tying with rival private equity shop Cerberus for having the largest number of withdrawn buyouts.
According to research firm Dealogic, Cerberus has had four withdrawn deals since 2006, while Blackstone and Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. each have seen three deals collapse in that time.
If the $6.76 billion buyout of Alliance Data, a credit-card transaction processor, crumbles, Blackstone would tie with Cerberus, which is named after the mythical three-headed guard dog at the gates of Hades, the Greek underworld. Blackstone could not be immediately reached for comment.
Last year, 25 U.S. buyouts valued at $84.19 billion were withdrawn, up from 16 deals valued at $42.49 billion in 2006, according to Dealogic.
The problem with the Alliance Data deal isn’t related to the price tag but instead stems from regulatory conditions that could be imposed on the deal, a source familiar with the transaction said.
Still, for months, the market has doubted this deal would close. Since the deal was announced in May, Alliance Data’s stock has regularly traded below the $81.75 takeover price. Twice this month alone, Alliance Data has tried to quell market concerns about the deal by saying the buyout was not being renegotiated and it believed deal-financing remained fully committed. Alliance Data’s stock had fallen 12.5 percent in January before the announcement on Monday, which sent the stock down another 36 percent in afternoon trading.
Blackstone said the U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency had demanded “unprecedented and unacceptable financial and operational requirements that would impose an unlimited and indefinite liability” on the buyout firm and its funds. These were “far in excess of any obligation” Blackstone has under the merger agreement.
The source familiar with the deal said the regulator had asked in November for an unlimited guarantee from the buyout firm, rather than the modest guarantee that had been expected. Blackstone said it was ready to work with Alliance Data to complete the deal and was willing to resubmit its proposal to the OCC.
Alliance Data said it believes Blackstone has the ability to close the deal and it would evaluate possible courses of action.
(Illustration: www.elucidationimages.com)