Desert Hockey

June 16, 2009

James Balsillie, the co-CEO of Research-in-Motion, can’t seem to catch a break. Having failed in previous efforts to buy NHL teams in Pittsburgh and Nashville and move them to Hamilton, Ontario, he’s now been shut out in his bid to buy the bankrupt Phoenix Coyotes. Arizona bankruptcy Judge Redfield Baum ruled late on Monday that a June 29 deadline set by Balsillie did not allow enough time to settle the complex case. It’s a shame things were so rushed. The decision could yet be a game changer for struggling sports franchises.

Balsillie (pictured above enjoying the game from the ice) and the owner of the Coyotes, trucking magnate Jerry Moyes, offered to put together a $212.5 million deal in May, when the franchise filed for bankruptcy protection, to move the team to Hamilton, about 200 miles northwest of Buffalo, N.Y. But NHL says the franchise is contractually obligated to stay in Phoenix.

Being a judge, Baum took the liberty to say both sides are wrong. He rejected Moyes’ attorneys’ argument that antitrust law allowed the sale and relocation of the Coyotes without NHL approval, and he dismissed concerns of other sports leagues that allowing the Coyotes to relocate would encourage other financially struggling teams to use bankruptcy court to get around league rules.

The Coyotes have never made a profit since moving to Arizona from Winnipeg in 1996 and lost $73 million from 2005 to 2008, according to court documents. If bankruptcy, with its power to renegotiate contracts, is not a good enough reason to find a better market for your product, what is?

Balsillie is keeping his game face on, saying there is still time for a deal to be worked out. He probably doesn’t need the deadlines. While the fortunes of the BlackBerry market may ebb and flow, its unlikely fans in Hamilton will lose their taste for a game that has proven so popular in Florida, North Carolina and Southern California, if not the desert.

4 comments so far | RSS Comments RSS

Let ‘em move. They’d be more viable elsewhere. LAst time I went to a game (tho it was last year), attendance was embarassingly low. These players deserve better than “fair weather” fans. Most in the area could care less about hockey

Posted by dshan | Report as abusive

I remeber when there was actually good attendance to the games, though not spectacular. That was when they played at America West Arena (now US Airways Arena) in Downtown Phoenix.

It’s too bad that Glendale won the battle for the new arena. It’s now out in the middle of nowhere on the west side of the metro, most of the teams fans lived on the east side of the metro. It’s not easy to get people to drive 20-30 miles in rush hour traffic to catch a game.

I agree that the players don’t deserve fair weather fans, however, when a teams is still relatively new to the area and consistently loses, it’s hard to blame the fans for not showing up.

Posted by Mark | Report as abusive

Let them go. It’s a good thing we have the Hurricanes here in Raleigh. Phoenix can’t support arguably the best Staal brother of the four, making him the best and the only one not playing on a team that can make it worth his while (even if he’s really only going to be old enough next year). That’s not to mention the rest of the players who can’t move to other teams with league-imposed team salary caps. And NO KIDDING he couldn’t buy the Penguins! Did he really think that the elite team of the east would sell??? Especially when they’ve been there since the 60′s? Yeah, right. Did he hope to get Crosby, Malkin, and Fleury, too? Hah!!

Posted by Steve D | Report as abusive

it is a wise decision.


Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see