Merrill Hintz: CDO/Subprime gore big bull believer
Bernstein Research analyst Brad Hintz has Street cred as an ex-Morgan Stanley treasurer and ex-Lehman CFO. But an examination of his record in covering Merrill Lynch and subprime’s impact on investment banks over the past several months shows he was anything but hard-hitting. Hintz’s recent dewey-eyed tribute to Stan O’Neal looks even worse in retrospect. (Hintz and his research reports are quoted everywhere, including in many Reuters news reports)
Hintz did not return messages for this story.
Let’s roll the tape and see what went wrong:
In February, the month for lovers, Hintz’s romance with Merrill shares flourished. His note, Thinking about Sub-Prime Risk, said Merrill faces only minor profit declines because of subprime. “So are the brokerage firms increasing their exposure?” he asked.
“We don’t think so. Brokers are simply not altruistic enough to heroically build massive portfolios of poor quality loans just to keep the subprime mortgage market active.”
April 3 - Hintz says worry about Merrill’s subprime exposure is overstated.
May 31 - Insights from the lead Steer - Hintz meets with O’Neal. Price target: $120.
July 18 - Merrill shares are battered. Hintz says buy more.
And like a lot of analysts and reporters, Hintz parroted Merrill’s refrain that the company’s 2006 aggregate exposure to the subprime industry would have been less than 2 percent of Merrill’s total net revenue.
That doesn’t sound like much. Great quarter, guys.
Oct. 1 - Hintz predicts soft third-quarter results. Goldman’s Tanona: Watch out! whopper $4.5 billion write-down coming.
“We still like this stock,” Hintz said. Merrill should be less affected by the fixed-income market missteps, he says
Oct. 5 - O’Neal unveils $5.5 billion write-down
Oct. 23 - Hintz not ready to break off the relationship.
“Let’s recognize that Merrill Lynch is not a fixed-income house,” Hintz said. He sees quick profit recovery in 2008 if management tightens risk controls.
Oct. 24 - Merrill Q3 write-down=$8.4 billion.
Oct. 30 - O’Neal quits under pressure. Hintz salutes O’Neal as stand-up guy.
“Perhaps we have become used to seeing politicians who refuse to accept the outcomes of their policy actions, corporate executives who fire subordinates and proudly announce that the problem is fixed and those Wall Street managers who pathetically cling to power after the market has lost confidence in their leadership. Mr. O’Neal displayed none of these characteristics. During Bernstein’s first meeting with Mr. O’Neal, years before he had been named CEO of Merrill, he confessed his love of the firm. And when he stood up and said ‘I’m responsible’ last week, he knew that, in the sharp elbowed world of Wall Street, he was sealing his fate and ending his career at his much-loved Merrill. If only all Wall Street executives recognized that with authority comes responsibility.”
What O’Neal actually did on the Oct. 24 conference call was share blame:
“We’re not — I’m not going to talk around the fact that there were some mistakes that were made. We — I am accountable for these mistakes as I am accountable for the performance of the firm overall, and my job, our job, the leadership team’s job is to address where we went wrong. …”




