Prius envy: Revenge of the hybrid driver

March 8, 2011

Jade Boyd in an undated handout photo. REUTERS/Handout/Jeff Fitlow/Rice UniversityJade Boyd lives in the People’s Republic of Pickup Trucks. As a science editor for Rice University in Houston, he’s literally surrounded on the road by Ford F-150s and Chevy Silverados. “I grew up in Texas, my dad always had a pickup, and if I had my druthers, I’d have a pickup too,” says the married father of two. “The Texan in me would love to drive a truck every single day.”

But then there’s the little issue of gas costs. With his friends filling up their pickups at around $75 a pop, twice a week, that’s $600 a month disappearing right into the tank. That’s why in 2007, Boyd went against his natural Texan instincts and bought himself a hybrid Toyota Prius.

Now with Libya in virtual civil war, the rest of the Mideast bubbling with unrest, and gas prices going through the roof, Boyd feels pretty prescient. He has a 60-mile work commute every day, but between carpooling and his gas-sipping Prius, he only has to fill up once a week. “For the longest time I couldn’t even put $20 worth of gas in the car,” he says. “It wouldn’t even hold that much.”

Great for him. Not so great for his truck-driving buddies, who are feeling Mideast turmoil right in their wallets. According to the Lundberg Survey of 2,500 gas stations around the country, gas prices just rose 33 cents a gallon in two weeks –- the second-biggest leap in the history of the gasoline market.

That’s why auto experts are now noticing a dramatic turn in car-buying behavior: Call it Prius Envy.

“We’ve seen conclusive evidence of that in the last two weeks,” says Karl Brauer, a senior analyst with auto-information site Edmunds.com. “There’s been a major shift in activity towards compact cars and hybrids, and away from large trucks and SUVs.”

Just take Toyota’s Prius sales numbers for February: 13,539 of the cars were sold last month, compared to 7,968 a year earlier. That’s a 70 percent year-over-year jump. When you look at average gas costs, it’s not difficult to figure out why. At 51 miles per gallon, Prius owners pay an average of $900 per year for fuel, while someone driving a 25-mpg car forks out more than double that, at $2,100.

Of course the Prius costs a good deal for a smaller car, starting at $23,050 for 2011 models. But once the gas savings start kicking in, Prius owners feel like they’ve hit a financial home run –- especially when other drivers are feeling pain at the pump.

It brings to mind the classic South Park episode, in which hybrid drivers produce a self-satisfied emission called “smug.”  Combined with similar storms over San Francisco, and one generated by a George Clooney acceptance speech at the Oscars, the “smug alert” ends up destroying thousands of homes in the town.

“The usual stereotype is that Porsche drivers are jerks, Lamborghini drivers are compensating, and Prius owners are all superior environmentalists who look down on the rest of us,” quips Brauer.

Prius owner Paul Baumbach tries to keep that kind of self-satisfaction under wraps, but he’s definitely thrilled with his purchase. The money manager from Newark, Delaware bought his back in 2006, not long after Hurricane Katrina, and figures he saves about $40 a month in gas costs.

“Once a buddy asked me which gas stations had the best prices,” remembers Baumbach. “I told him I don’t fill up that much, so I don’t really pay attention to where it’s the cheapest. He was just kind of stunned, and didn’t say anything.”

As a financial planner with Mallard Advisors, Baumbach does have to think about oil prices on a macro level, and how spikes will affect his clients’ portfolios. But when it comes to his own car, since there are “not a lot of gallons involved,” the oil crisis doesn’t really affect him one way or the other.

“It actually feels good to drive by a gas station,” Baumbach says. “It’s a nice position to be in.”

Comments

Alright, if your 51 MPG car costs $900 then a 25 MPG car would cost $1835. Unless this is taking into account some other mysterious costs that are not explained. Further, considering how much a Prius costs, if it’s 10k more than a 25mpg compact, he won’t pay for the difference for 20 years. And that’s assuming the batteries hold out. It’s just possible that buying a more expensive car without thinking the costs through isn’t actually cheaper.

Posted by Nil.kemorya | Report as abusive
 

they might be good on gas, but they sure are UGLY.

Posted by taurus1911 | Report as abusive
 

Prius: The slow moving car at the front of a long line of motorists aggravated by a reluctance to pull into a turn-out so they may pass.

Also, Top Gear showed that a Prius being flogged gets 15mpg while the V8 M3 following it got 18mpg: Most people don’t need an expensive hybrid to get better mileage, they need to moderate their driving style.

What happens to the toxic surprise inside the batteries once it’s been totalled? Will our drinking water taste smug?

Posted by Nuvolari | Report as abusive
 

New math aside, the destruction of the environment by rare earth elements sold by China upon which the Prius and other hybrids rely, is a true irony:

A lady at the checkout counter of Whole Foods stuffed her big purse with groceries, claiming she didn’t want to add another paper bag into the recycle bin. Guess what?

I saw her get into a Prius out in the Whole Foods parking lot (LOL)! The neodymium magnets and other rare earth elements in her car will foul the environment so extensively in the future (when she replaces the battery or passes the car to a new owner, kicking the can further down the road) that she might as well drive a monster pickup truck and ask the Whole Foods cashier, “Double bag it, please.”

Posted by DisgustedReader | Report as abusive
 

DistinguishedReader makes a point that I considered when shifting from low MPG to high MPG. All hybrids have a huge energy footprint when driven off the lot, and directly contribute to environmental and human damages. I drive a 40 MPG VW TDI and delight in my decision of choosing a fuel-stingy wagon with better leg room and more cargo capacity. My vehicle is algal biodiesel ready should it become locally available in the coming years.

Posted by SanPa | Report as abusive
 

I am willing to bet his monthly car payments offset the savings at the pump. This is a picture perfect example of how even “educated” Americans have no idea how money works.

Posted by djlowballer | Report as abusive
 

I never met anyone else that new how bad a choice financially and environmentally those Toyota go-karts were. Nice to see you guys know at least :P

Posted by Sandy106 | Report as abusive
 

Not sure why the tag line for this said that Prius owners are “blissfully unaffected”. They burn 2.5 gallons of gas every 100 miles or so and they have to pay for it too. Yes they are spending less on gas per mile than most cars, but they’re still affected.

Also, comparing rare-earth pollution issues to global warming is like comparing TP-ing someone’s house to nuking a city.

Posted by Thalya | Report as abusive
 

In Japan, Prius hadn’t lost its strong sales while American paper and TV were releasing negative news about its liability. I was driving German cars in Japan. Now I moved in the US and purchased Prius; I impress with Prius’s electronic control system and its interior design rather than Gernam monsters. Clean for the environment is an important factor to choose a car for the modern people.

Posted by norisaic | Report as abusive
 

What about all the people that drive diesels?Why is there no discussion about them?I drive a VW passat TDI that can use biodiesel from reused vegie oil or regular diesel.whatever I fill my tank with, I get 38 around town and 47-50 on the freeway,depending if I do 65 or 75.Wake up America to what the Europeans do! Most cabs in Europe are Passat TDI’s or Schoda TDI’s(made by VW)Be responsible and buy a diesel.

Posted by Tibs | Report as abusive
 

I guess Prius owners think that batteries are free and not included in the cost of ownership of a Prius. I will take my 30+ MPG car over the Prius at this point. If gas keeps climbing I will see how long I can wait until I can get a hybrid. Gasoline isn’t the only thing that will climb, energy at the outlet will rise as well, Electric Vehicles aren’t viable until we start raising more power plants with solar, wind, nulcear, natural gas, and clean coal. I am hoping the next president takes this more seriosly than the current president has.

Posted by Trooth | Report as abusive
 

I own a ’07 Civic EX (non-hybrid). Drive it normally I average between 30-35 mpg (combined). When I drove ultra carefully, I got between 45-50 mpg. Remember, breaking wastes fuel. Minimize how much you break (timing lights, stop signs, and anticipating when other motorists are breaking), drive the speed limit, pump up your tires to the maximum recommended psi, get rid of the junk inside your trunk, and laugh at the silly overpriced hybrids.

Posted by brnrbr911 | Report as abusive
 

As a Prius owner I can tell the remarks posted are biased through second hand observation. I decided that the extra expense for the vehicle was better directed to a country that is friendly towards the west. The popularity of the Prius gives Toyota the R & D funds to continue to evolve their technology.

As to Top Gear’s bashing of the Prius, they needed some deprecating entertainment. The Prius is not a sports car and driving any vehicle hard will waste fuel. My driving patterns yield 51 mpg.

When all electric vehicles become commonplace, the electricity used to charge batteries will be a domestic product. Did I mention how dysfunctional the mid-east has become?

Posted by garyphillips | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/