Scary and scarier: rising prices and rising rates
Data expected out of Washington this week may raise anxiety levels of investors and consumers who are already worried about inflation and rising interest rates.
On April 12, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that U.S. import prices jumped in March. We’ll also get data on producer prices on April 14 and consumer prices on April 15. But here’s what we already know: It costs more to fill your car, and your belly. And what doesn’t run on food or fuel?
At the same time, Federal Reserve officials have gone out of their way to pooh-pooh the dangers of inflation. That just worries consumers and bond investors all the more. If niche commodity price increases start feeding through to other goods and services, or if the Fed starts throwing around too much cash, the end result could be rising long-term interest rates. And rising rates could slam bond investors, who would lose money if the prices of their bonds fell to create higher yields. That would be particularly bad for mom and pop retirement investors who have been told that bonds are “safer” than stocks.
So, what to do, what to do? Realize, first, that rising prices and rising long-term bond yields are two distinct and different situations. “Even though in theory, they should be linked together, the math shows they don’t move in lockstep,” says Tim Courtney of Burns Advisory Group in Oklahoma City. Long-term bond yields are more likely to rise ahead of consumer inflation. They’ll rise when bond fund investors start to expect future inflation.
That means investors and consumers should be planning for both eventualities separately. Here are five ways to protect yourself from rising rates. (We’ll address rising prices in a later post.)
Be careful about TIPs. Treasury inflation-protected securities promise to protect portfolios from the ravages of inflation, through a complex pricing mechanism. Their yield is divided into two parts: a fixed yield and a yield guaranteed to rise with the Consumer Price Index. Right now, they are more expensive than regular Treasuries — an expectation of two percent annual inflation is built into their price, says Courtney. That means they will only pay off if inflation runs higher than that, but that isn’t the real risk with these bonds. The real risk is that interest rates will rise, but prices won’t. Then what happens to TIPs holders? They’ll get slammed. Their yields won’t rise and their prices could fall.
Short bonds. This is something Pimco’s bond buff, Bill Gross, has already started to do. His Total Return Fund — the world largest bond fund — began shorting Treasury debt in March. Ed Easterling, president of Crestmont Research, an investment research firm, suggests that this is one of the very few ways you could buy “proactive protection” from future inflation. If rates go up in anticipation of future inflation, and you’re shorting long bonds (in effect, borrowing bonds and selling them at today’s prices), you’ll gain when bond prices fall and you can cover your short position with cheaper bonds. That sounds complex, but you could do that by buying shares of an exchange-traded fund, such as the Proshares Ultra Short 20 Yr Treasury, that inverts and doubles the performance of long term Treasury bonds. Even more aggressive, reports Lipper, is the Direxion Daily 20+ Year Treasury Bear 3x exchange-traded fund. That inverts the Treasury 20-year bond and then triples it.
Buy foreign bond funds that don’t hedge the dollar. That could work if either higher interest rates or higher prices hit. Foreign bonds tend to pay higher interest than U.S. bonds. Furthermore, if you buy them with today’s dollars and then prices rise, cheapening the value of the dollar, you’ll win again when you trade your foreign-denominated shares back into dollars.
Don’t be overly impressed with commodities. In the first place, you may have already missed the big gold rush. In the second place, commodities don’t typically beat inflation, they just match it, says Courtney. ”We don’t have commodities in our portfolio because the expected return of all of them together is just equal to inflation.” And that’s just not good enough for a hedge, he contends.
Don’t go crazy. Of course, it’s entirely possible that both prices and interest rates will remain under control, or even ratchet back down. So you wouldn’t want to devote your entire portfolio to positioning yourself for a price and rate blowout. Instead, keep the bulk of your portfolio on track, and reserve a slice for inflation and interest rate fighting. Then go worry about something else.
Comments RSS










A few corrections.
TIPS: “Pay off” is a crude term and your statement is only accurate for someone who is seeking to purchase a TIP on the market (and is only really true then because the yield is like 0%). If someone already owns some TIPs, they may have a higher coupon and could still profit. The second point you made is basically that real interest rates could rise (nominal rates rise, but inflation doesn’t). I think most people think this is a rather unlikely scenario unless GDP growth is 4%+ for a few quarters.
Foreign bonds: This is only true if the inflation rate in the countries you invest in is lower than in the U.S., otherwise your PPP argument is invalid.
Commodities: This argument is completely mistaken for several reasons. Assume its just some random asset, if it has the same expected return as inflation and other assets can return more, then a mean-variance investor might still hold some of it depending on its correlation with other assets (commodities had no correlation with stocks from 1974-1980 when inflation became elevated) and its volatility. Second, granting your argument, then there still might be some commodities you want to be exposed to. Eliminating the whole sector from your portfolio on that basis is ridiculous. Third, you’re looking at conditional returns for commodities (ie. return on commodities given inflation) but not the same conditional returns for other asset classes. It could be that an expected return on inflation is good during those time periods. Fourth, you’re ignoring the probability of rising inflation. Core inflation at 1.2% is far far away from the 1980s. Fifth, even if we were to look at how commodities traditionally did during inflation regimes, it is likely that a futures position could outperform the inflation rate since there is a cash component as well (from 1974-1980 when inflation was elevated, commodities rose 14% per year, compared to 8.2% for stocks, 3.2% bonds, and 8.5% for core inflation). No one expects those returns to play out exactly if there is another sharp rise in inflation. The point is merely that the last time we did have a sharp inflation, what you are predicting for commodities didn’t happen and there’s no reason that will be the case again.
The articl author is correct about the risk of either buying or holding TIPS. I presently have a pile of real return Canadas, which operate just like TIPs. Recently, I have had large portfolio value increases due to easy money policies causing artificially low nominal interest rates and rising inflationary expectations. These inflationary expectations and the low real rates of interest rates generally have driven up the prices of my real return bonds. The danger is however that a tightening of monetary policy will drive up nominal interest rates while driving down inflationary expectations. These factors would, of course, reduce the demand for the real return bonds, driving down their prices.
I am presently looking for a strategy of trying to lock in most of my recent gains from rising real return bond prices against this risk of monetary tightening. Would love suggestions.
This is a really interesting and insightful article, thank you for posting it. I think the best thing for all of us to do is just make sure that we are doing all we can to manage our finances so we know what is going on! I have been using an investment analysis software called Statpro which has helped me in analysing my value-based estate, litigation support, and acquisition activities. Even more so the most helpful tool I have used is the bond pricing which have really come into use when trying to assess my mortgage.