GMAC: bottomless pit watch

October 28, 2009

The government has already poured $12.5 billion into GMAC since last December, and now the company is negotiating for $2.8-$5.6 billion more. Oh, and FDIC will allow the company to max out its borrowing capacity under TLGP, bringing the total there to $7.4 billion.

Yet another argument against those who say we “made money” on TARP because Goldman, AmEx and a few others bought back their warrants at a small premium. All the profits from those warrants wouldn’t add up to the amount we’ve already poured into GMAC, never mind this latest infusion. There’s also the small matter of $100 billion+ we’re never getting back from AIG….

Readers may recall that FDIC was rather peeved at GMAC for previously offering high rates on deposits. This is the ultimate moral hazard of deposit insurance. Depositors aren’t willing to impose discipline on the bank — taking their money out — because they know it’s guaranteed. GMAC knew this and, through its subsidiary GMAC Ally Bank, offered the highest deposit rates in the nation for a time.

In order to sell more government backed debt under TLGP program, FDIC struck a deal by which GMAC will “keep its [deposit] rates at certain amounts,” according to WSJ.

One would think a change of management might be in order. Well, it’s not gonna happen. CEO Alvaro de Molina — formerly CFO at Bank of America — will stay on.

The real reason behind this bailout is GM. In an age when cars are still purchased on credit, someone has to front the money if automakers are going to move inventory. For GM, that means GMAC, which in turn means taxpayers.

Taxpayers are lending themselves money to buy cars (via GMAC). To buy houses (via Fannie, Freddie and very soon FHA). To buy anything and everything that has to be financed.

My question: When are we actually going to pay for any of it? Also: When we realize we can’t, what’s going to happen to the economy?


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

So GMAC is the lender chosen to take over for Chrysler Financial?

Posted by Andrew | Report as abusive

I haven’t been following CF as closely Andrew. What’s been going on there?

Posted by Rolfe Winkler | Report as abusive

[…] than simply bailing out GMAC (again).  (Clusterstock, Baseline Scenario, Fund My Mutual Fund, Rolfe Winkler, Atlantic […]

Posted by Wednesday links: stale prices Abnormal Returns | Report as abusive

GMAC was selected to take over for Chrysler Financial in terms of auto lending when chrysler filed bankruptcy. That was my impression, at least.

Posted by Andrew | Report as abusive

uhm, who is going to be a chrysler? on credit?

Posted by tri | Report as abusive

[…] Most of the second-quarter losses came from real estate. GMAC also has an online banking company, Ally Banking (formerly GMAC Bank), which has come under fire for offering very high rates for deposits since […]

Posted by GMAC Wants $2.9 Billion More of Your Money | The CarGurus Blog | Report as abusive

FAKE bank ,,,fake money, this is a outrage!

Posted by Julie | Report as abusive

[…] to max out its borrowing capacity under the temporary liquidity guarantee program, Rolfe Winkler writes on a Reuters […]

Posted by Market Talk » Blog Archive » GMAC’s Latest Member To Join ‘Black Hole Club’ | Report as abusive

[…] than simply bailing out GMAC (again).  (Clusterstock, Baseline Scenario, Fund My Mutual Fund, Rolfe Winkler, Atlantic […]

Posted by Wednesday links: stale prices | Financial engineering resource center | Report as abusive

[…] alone burns through more than $1.4 billion of taxpayer’s cash a […]

Posted by Green Energy Reporter » $1.4B Per Year in Government Cleantech/Green Energy Investment is Not Enough | Report as abusive

[…] GMAC: Bottomless pit watch @ Rolfe Winkler […]

Posted by Interesting Reads 31st October 2009 | Report as abusive