Reuters Blogs

Shop Talk

Retailers, consumers and prices

17:25 May 28th, 2008

Barbie-Bratz legal tangle drives up Mattel options volatility

Posted by: Patrick Fitzgibbons
Tags: Shop Talk

costumeparty.jpgIt has surely crossed the mind of many a knit-browed parent that the Bratz doll prototype would land in trouble somewhere.

“The creators of the Bratz doll — the provocatively dressed, collagen-enhanced, bratily named successor to the Barbie mantle — is now in court in a lawsuit brought on by Barbie’s creator Mattel,” Interactive Brokers Group equity options analyst Rebecca Engmann Darst told Reuters.

“Thankfully, it has not involved the vice squad,” she said.

Instead, the company behind the wildly successful Bratz franchise, MGA Entertainment, has been hauled into court by Mattel on grounds that Carter Bryant, the creator of the sassy fashion dolls was employed by Mattel when he first conceived the sketches — making them Mattel’s rightful property, Darst said.

Shares in Mattel responded with restrained upside, up 14 cents to $20.25.

But Darst noted the potential fallout of a courtroom showdown left a more conspicuous impact on Mattel’s options.

Option volume of roughly 22,000 contracts late on Wednesday equaled about one third of Mattel’s total open interest of 67,000 lots and was 12 times the normal level, according to Interactive Brokers data.

Most of that volume was situated in Mattel calls and specifically in the July series in the $20 strike, which allows investors to buy Mattel shares at $20 by July 18.

The price of these options at $1.40 a contract during the session implies continued share price gains just to break even on that trade, she said.

Mattel’s implied volatility, a measure of anticipated stock price volatility used in the pricing of options, rose 14 percent to 33.8 percent from Tuesday’s close, making it one of the afternoon’s top volatility gainers in the U.S. options market, she said.

“The interest in the July calls suggested a whiff of confidence among option traders that the Barbie maker’s legal smack down against the Bratz creator has some merit,” Darst said. – By Doris Frankel in Chicago

(Photo: MGA Entertainment)

3 comments so far

[...] So I don’t know if you’ve been keeping up with the latest in toy industry news, but Mattel recently tried to sue MGA Entertainment, the company responsible for the popular Bratz dolls. Mattel is alleging that the designer who [...]

- Posted by Barbie vs. Bratz – Who’s the Winner? | theshoppingvine.com

well Im not a bratz fan but if the sketches of the bratz were originally from mattel, then mattel should had produced the dolls from the start, but hey its too late now, you lost, in the mean time make Barbie BETTER than ever!!!!!I own over 1,000 of the beauties and have no intentions of slowing down. Go Barbie, Go…

- Posted by Selena

This is a load of crap. The only reason Mattel is doing this is because Carter Bryant and MGA Cashed in big time on a great idea that was probably rejected by Mattel. Lets face it The Bratz became as big as Barbie in seven short years. The Bratz have a very big following and Mattel wants to shut MGA down because they don`t like competition. This is not the first time Mattel has done this. Rather than making a better product they do this. Sure they make toys but they are also a corperate bully.

- Posted by Dave

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.