Reuters Blogs

Reuters Soccer Blog

World Soccer views and news

November 22nd, 2007

Croatia follow in Hungary’s footsteps and give England a Wembley lesson

Posted by: Mike Collett
Tags: Reuters Soccer Blog

Gerrard walks off the pitch

It’s not the first time, of course, that a small eastern European country has humiliated England at Wembley, giving the nation that invented the game a lesson in how to play it.

Hungary’s famous 6-3 victory over England under Wembley’s Twin Towers in 1953 is the stuff of legend.

Croatia’s win under the floodlit Wembley Arch on Wednesday night ought to serve as just as big a wake-up call to the English game as that famous victory of the Mighty Magyars did, 54 years ago this week.

For what cannot be ignored in the wreckage of England’s humiliating 3-2 defeat was that Croatia outclassed England tactically and technically – just as Ferenc Puskas and his team did when they became the first ever foreign side to beat England at home.

The wet, slippery conditions were the same for both teams — but Croatia mastered them and England could not. Their players controlled the ball better, and Croatia coach Slaven Bilic outwitted England coach Steve McClaren, pulling the largely inexperienced England defence all over the pitch. Croatia had so much space and time. Their players looked sharper and fitter. Their passing was more accurate.

McClaren’s decision to drop Paul Robinson and David Beckham back-fired spectacularly. Scott Carson, making his first competitive appearance for England, was beaten twice in the opening 14 minutes and while not at fault for the second goal, he was for the first.

The sense of incredulity at Wembley was tangible. People were looking at each other saying, “I don’t believe what is happening here.”

But Carson cannot shoulder all the blame. At the heart of the matter is the fact that there are now far too many ordinary foreign players earning their fortunes in the Premier League.

No-one begrudges the fact that some of the world’s top players are here. But so, it seems, is everyone else who can kick a ball in a straight line. As a result, the pool of English players at the top level is diminishing.

When England won the World Cup in 1966, more than half of the goalkeepers playing in the old First Division were English. Right now there are four.

English pundits never stop telling the public the Premier League is the best, most exciting in the world, but as Steven Gerrard said last week, what’s the point of having the best league in the world if the national team is not good enough to qualify for major competitions.

It took England time to learn the lessons and catch up with the developing world of football in the 1950s after losing to Hungary. Thirteen years in fact.

There are different lessons to be learnt now, and in my view the main one is this.

England’s Premier League clubs should stop importing “ordinary” foreign players. That does not mean English football needs “quotas” to limit foreign players; it can impose its own by actually playing English players.

Clubs should concentrate on developing their own local talent instead of casting the nets ever wider across the world.

But we all know there is as much chance of that happening as England winning Euro 2008 in Austria and Switzerland.

PHOTO: Steven Gerrard walks off the pitch following England’s Euro 2008 qualifier against Croatia at Wembley, November 21, 2007. REUTERS/Kieran Doherty

11 comments so far

No its not the ordinary foreign players affecting the national team.Its the ordinary english players littering our league at clubs like newcastle tottenham etc that are regarded as world class in the premiership cos they scored two goals against wigan once.Its a joke english players are running the 100m in the prem week in week out but international football is all about the 1500m.Keep the ball and we could compete otherwise we will definatly be struggling for years to come.

- Posted by roger barclay

You can’t have it both ways Mike. English clubs import so many “ordinary” foreign players because they are cheaper than overrated and overpriced English players and more talented for that matter too. Unfortunately, I think slapping quotas to limit foreigners is the only right thing to do, not just in the Premier League but elsehwere too, as having teams with 11 foreigners in their starting line ups is quite simply ridiculous.

- Posted by Red Devil

I’m not sure I agree with this assessment. Why would anyone hire “ordinary” foreign players when there are enough “ordinary” English players to go around? You’re just introducing yet another level of difficulty (acclimatisation, language) in integrating these players who, as you argue, have nothing special to contribute in terms of skill. McClaren was the wrong man for the job; he was not ready to compete at that level. And hey, sometimes, sh*t just happens.

- Posted by Gonzalo

maybe you should start sending English youth players to play in smaller eastern european leagues to learn the “technical” game rather then trying to bring them up through the lower english leagues. The problem with the english game is it’s very one dimensional…zero creativity.

- Posted by mike

The problem with the english game is it’s very one dimensional…zero creativity.. i agree totally with that. Lets take a minute and realise most of the talent in the premiership.. of which is not even english. Its such a shame to see england go out and such a early stage but being honest they did not deserve to qualify regardless… mclaren should never have been made the man for the job.

I cant see england winning anything for a long long time, certainly in my life time.

- Posted by Samwse

Speaking as a Scot who had to watch his own team go out of the competition on Saturday evening,I have to say I fear for the England team right now. Most of your Premiership sides are overloaded with foreign players to the detriment of young home-grown talent. Some of those imports are top-quality - others are journeymen at best. England were without their best defenders last night - that had to be a handicap, since no team can afford to lose players like Cole, Neville, Terry and Ferdinand and not suffer. Playing a young keeper on such an important occasion was clearly a gamble that failed to pay off - incidentally, I thought he was at fault for the first Croatian goal, but also not entirely blameless for the third, either. What would worry me is that the squad as it stands is thin on quality - last night proves that, I’m afraid. Worse, though, is the scarcity of new young talent coming through - thanks, perhaps, to the presence of so many foreign players in your top league. I know there are players in the pipeline; the question is, are they as good as the players they’ll one day have to replace? I think not.

The tactical inadequacy of the management team simply compounded the problems. When talent is at a premium, the manager HAS to be able to make the best of the resources at his disposal. If I were England, I think I might look very hard at appointing Martin O’Neill for that very reason.

And BTW, I’m not gloating - the fact that Euro 2008 will happen without a single British team represented is a scandal.

- Posted by Doddie

Guys, I’m sure you should limit the number of foreigners like we in Russia did. In this season three Russians were on the pitch and not less. In the forthcoming season the minimal number will be four, than five, six, etc. And finally the quantity of foreigners allowed to take part in the match will be reduced to four only. And the results of this policy are clearly seen even now: we have a capable team, some players advanced themselves incredibly, and, of course, WE go to Austria and Switzerland, not you!

- Posted by Oleg

problem with england is that you don’t show any respect to other country’s and the fact that you invented football means nothing today. for example see the previous game against croatia. i’m not telling that because i’m croatian, in fact my uncle is welsh who serve in NATO forces for royal army and we talk about problems in britain often. You(english) must take serious this problem with football, and not just football because the same problem is reflected in British foreign politics as well, and if you don’t take serious you will fall deeper and deeper in football

- Posted by bubimir13

[…] course, that explains it! I was forgetting that this is English soccer - there are no expectations of covering the national team in a major tournament, silly me. Now I […]

- Posted by She never calls: Wannabes - an update - Reuters Photographers

I love it.

- Posted by A-A-Reisen - günstigster Anbieter für Balaton, Plattensee - Ferienhäuser | Ferienwohnungen | Pensionen in Ungarn und Tschechien

Nice post. Well done. Thanks.

- Posted by CREATIONPOOL - Agentur für Internetseiten und Flash Programmierung in Berlin

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word