Reuters Blogs

Reuters Soccer Blog

World Soccer views and news

03:51 November 25th, 2007

An Italian ‘Mister’ for England?

Posted by: Simon Evans
Tags: Reuters Soccer Blog

Capello head shotFabio Capello fancies the England job and he has already won the support of former England manager Terry Venables:

“People like Capello and Marcello Lippi, who won the World Cup with Italy, are tough guys who wouldn’t find it so difficult working here.”

There are signs of a media momentum building behind Capello in a similar fashion to how, a few years ago, the London press convinced themselves that Sven Goran Eriksson was the man to transform England into a sophisticated continental team.

There are, as always with these debates, plenty of fascinating arguments for and against appointing Capello (or Lippi) as manager of the English national side. Let us put Lippi aside for the moment — he has expressed no interest in the job and 18 months ago, when I attended his final press conference as Italy coach, the day after he had won the World Cup, I asked him whether he would ever consider working in England and he replied in the negative. The reason he gave was significant however — he doesn’t speak English and he wouldn’t want to work in a country where he can’t communicate with people. Lippi speaks Italian and French.

Unless he has been hiding his language skills — something a lot of Italians do — or he has been studying hard in the past year or so (something that wouldn’t be so surprising) Fabio Capello doesn’t speak much English, if any at all. He speaks Italian and Spanish.

Oliver Kay in The Times notes this may be a problem:

Capello is 61 and would be the oldest man to be appointed to the job, but his age is far less of an issue than his relatively poor grasp of English. He will probably need an English-speaking assistant if he gets the job.

In most walks of life the fact that you don’t speak the language of your employers or your staff would ruled you out of consideration for a position before you even brought your translator along with you to the job interview. For a job as a football coach — where communicating with your players is a huge part of the role — it seems incredible that a non-English speaker would even be considered for the England job.

Sure, you can always have an English speaking assistant or a translator along side you on the bench but, if you have ever seen coaches work like this, you will understand that it can be a major drawback. You can get the words translated but the emphasis, the passion, the urgency and sometimes the detail, get lost. Try telling a joke through a translator and see if you get a real laugh. Try asking a translator to yell at John Terry in the last five minutes of a crucial game at a packed Wembley.

There are some coaches that have succeeded without speaking the main language of their players and German Otto Rehhagel with Greece at Euro 2004 is probably the best example. There are also, as the Guardian’s Sid Lowe notes here, plenty of good arguments for giving Don Fabio a chance — he has a tremendous record in Italy and Spain having won titles with every club he has been in charge of. On top of that, English football no longer has a problem with having a foreigner in charge of the national side.

But is language going to be the barrier to Capello’s ambition?

PHOTO: Fabio Capello watches the Italian national team train at the Puskas stadium in Budapest August 21, 2007. REUTERS/Karoly Arvai

9 comments so far

Capello would be a sad, sad choice. I mean, has it come to this? Do we really want the England team playing the most mind-numbingly dull football in the history of the game? I mean, really.

- Posted by Dave x

England HAD the best coach currently available (as the loss of only 5 competitive games in five and a half years in charge of the national squad and his prior and subsequent club record confirms) but a “greatful and patriotic” British media drove him out of office.
Appointing the understudy “By default” was an obvious disaster waiting to happen, but in fairness to TheFA, very few world class managers appear to be interested in “football’s top job” after seeing Sven’s “reward” for turning England’s fortunes around?
Our fate next summer is saddly now known, but what are the chances to qualify for W-Cup2010?

- Posted by Derek Williams

Unfortunately it is the media who decides on the England manager an it is an interesting point made about them being in favour of Sven until eventually turning against him.

They may well get their wish and have Capello though few have probably found out if he can speak English.

Furthermore, it is the press who picks the team more or less and few England managers have been brave enough to stand up to them.

Whoever takes over will need to be strong enough to stand up against them and I can’t really see anybody who can.

- Posted by online sports guy

I get the feeling that this question is going to be a marathon, and not a sprint. And those names being bandied about now — or esp. those putting their own names forward — will probably not be in the running at the end of the race.

- Posted by An England fan

I cannot understand how an Italian can manage the England team. What would happen if England played Italy in an important game? Would Fabio Capello really wish Italy to lose? England need an English manager and the FA must not allow itself to be influnaced by the media, but I fear that the FA itself is weak, which probably explains Englands recent performance. If Dave X thinks Italian football is dull, most Italians think losing all the time extremely dull

- Posted by Mario Laurenza

some decent home talent perhaps???
big sam? jus pay the man what he asks!

- Posted by VIK

Capello would be in my opinion yet another mismatch as he as little or no experience of what is required of an England team.For this you need an English manager.
Previous national managers of this country that have tapped into this are Hoddle and Venebles who as a consequence have the best records in recent years.
Redknapp who is very patriotic, has shown his fine mangerial credentials with every club he has managed and can handle the media for me would be the ideal appointment.With Stuart Pearce aslong side him as is assistant this would be the dream team.

VIK, i’m not sure many Newcastle United fans would agree with big sam being decent home talent right now.

- Posted by Dean Morton

As capello is a documented right-wing nationalist - what would happen if he was manager of england and they had italy in the quarters,semis or (dreaming) the world cup final?
I wouldn’t trust him to give his all to beat his own national team!!

- Posted by Grant Beckerleg

Frankly, I don’t think that playing against Italy would be such a big problem for Capello. I’d be much more worried if his team had to play against AC Milan (his REAL national team), but this can’t happen in a World Cup…

- Posted by Alfredo

Post Your Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

House Rules:
  • We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information
  • We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous information.