My colleague Mitch Phillips wrote this on our blog towards the end of last year:
It was only a few weeks ago that the great and the good of football were talking about the lessons to be learned from the rugby World Cup, where players under just as much pressure but suffering infinitely more physical punishment, retained a respect for officials that utterly shames football by comparison.
Mitch was writing in response to a group of Chelsea players, led by team captain John Terry, who surrounded the referee in the latest example of multi-millionaire players ganging up on an official because of a decision they didn’t like.
The idea that it’s OK to approach the referee in such a way seems to be deeply ingrained in the Premier League and by all accounts, the behaviour is copied by players all the way down to schools football.
It’s refreshing, then, to see a scheme being run by the FA at the amateur level to try to get things moving in the right direction. Play the video above to see a report on a trial that will see the team captains designated as the only players able to talk directly with the referee.
It’s an appealing idea and one the game needs if, in the long term, we’re going to keep referees in soccer. As David Elleray says in the report:
We’re very good at getting people into refereeing but not so good at keeping people as referees and a part of that is the way they’re treated. In the broadest sense it’s the abuse and the unpleasantness they encounter and a lot of them turn around and say, ‘Why do I put up with this?’
So is this something that should be taken up in the Premier League and elsewhere in the professional game? Watch the report from Jim Drury and let us know via the comments.

Trackback
2 comments so far
Have to say that the whole idea of only allowing the Captain to discuss decisions with the referee is a good idea. It will be interesting to see what kind of punishment other players are given if they breach this law and when it is to be introduced.
- Posted by Betting Blue BoyThere are apparent flaws in the idea however. What if the players are discussing other aspects of the game, will this be deemed as punishable, I’m sure there will be a number of examples where teams appeal against cards etc.
Maybe it would help if football would follow rugby also by allowing video evidence for refs to make better decisions.
- Posted by FairFootball